{
  "state": {
    "schema_version": "sim-1.0.0",
    "record_id": "saltwind-sound-01-state",
    "record_status": "SIMULATION",
    "source": {
      "kind": "INITIALIZATION",
      "campaign_id": "saltwind-sound-01",
      "turn_id": "turn-001",
      "notes": "Fresh synthetic Saltwind initialization under explicit GM simulation authorization; no historical campaign imports."
    },
    "generation": {
      "source_version": "saltwind-sound-01-turn-003",
      "generated_at": "2026-09-07T17:50:43.044Z",
      "tool_version": "simulation-runner-1.0.0"
    },
    "campaign": {
      "id": "saltwind-sound-01",
      "name": "Simulation: Saltwind Sound",
      "rules_version": "saltwind-v0.2-sim1",
      "status": "ACTIVE",
      "current_turn": 3
    },
    "calendar": {
      "current_key": "Y01-M09",
      "display_label": "Late autumn, Year 1",
      "year": 1,
      "month": 9,
      "next_key": "Y01-M10",
      "legacy_source_label": null
    },
    "turn": {
      "id": "turn-003",
      "number": 3,
      "status": "CLOSED",
      "deadline": "2026-09-07T17:50:43.044Z",
      "maximum_submission_words": 1500,
      "current_blocker": null,
      "status_history": [
        {
          "status": "OPEN",
          "at": "2026-09-07T17:50:43.044Z",
          "approval_id": null
        },
        {
          "status": "INTAKE_LOCKED",
          "at": "2026-09-07T17:50:43.105Z",
          "approval_id": null
        },
        {
          "status": "ANALYZED",
          "at": "2026-09-07T17:51:51.219Z",
          "approval_id": null
        },
        {
          "status": "ADJUDICATION_APPROVED",
          "at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
          "approval_id": "T003-A-GM"
        },
        {
          "status": "RESULTS_DRAFTED",
          "at": "2026-09-07T18:01:29.964Z",
          "approval_id": null
        },
        {
          "status": "DELIVERY_APPROVED",
          "at": "2026-09-07T18:01:29.964Z",
          "approval_id": "T003-A-DELIVERY"
        },
        {
          "status": "DELIVERED",
          "at": "2026-09-07T18:05:42.667Z",
          "approval_id": "T003-A-DELIVERY"
        },
        {
          "status": "CLOSED",
          "at": "2026-09-07T18:05:42.667Z",
          "approval_id": null
        }
      ],
      "intake": [
        {
          "id": "T003-I-player1",
          "player_id": "player1",
          "classification": "VALID",
          "counts_as_miss": false,
          "consecutive_misses_before": 0,
          "consecutive_misses_after": 0,
          "word_count": 1252,
          "byte_count": 7720,
          "archive_path": "turns/turn-003/intake/player1/submission.md",
          "checksum_sha256": "44119b1f3fb606c3d329ba31538a680670ccdd4fbb169e1f4cf7669dbb9199bc",
          "ruling_id": null
        },
        {
          "id": "T003-I-player2",
          "player_id": "player2",
          "classification": "VALID",
          "counts_as_miss": false,
          "consecutive_misses_before": 0,
          "consecutive_misses_after": 0,
          "word_count": 1197,
          "byte_count": 7639,
          "archive_path": "turns/turn-003/intake/player2/submission.md",
          "checksum_sha256": "6a46966b3f64db3a7ff4c3228b0926c46fa4739b43a850f42f637e19d77a7d9e",
          "ruling_id": null
        },
        {
          "id": "T003-I-player3",
          "player_id": "player3",
          "classification": "VALID",
          "counts_as_miss": false,
          "consecutive_misses_before": 0,
          "consecutive_misses_after": 0,
          "word_count": 978,
          "byte_count": 6444,
          "archive_path": "turns/turn-003/intake/player3/submission.md",
          "checksum_sha256": "d78845ee0e7d650946f1578acb61db94ef8a7e66600222d6abcec8ab13f86873",
          "ruling_id": null
        },
        {
          "id": "T003-I-player4",
          "player_id": "player4",
          "classification": "VALID",
          "counts_as_miss": false,
          "consecutive_misses_before": 0,
          "consecutive_misses_after": 0,
          "word_count": 1327,
          "byte_count": 8026,
          "archive_path": "turns/turn-003/intake/player4/submission.md",
          "checksum_sha256": "e1175f5f8c966c12193bc05c7564875adc706c810f2228fbcb3bda7577a94f47",
          "ruling_id": null
        }
      ]
    },
    "players": [
      {
        "id": "player1",
        "clan_id": "saltmere",
        "leader_character_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "leader_title": "Leader of Saltmere",
        "control_status": "ACTIVE",
        "eligible": true,
        "expected_submission": true,
        "consecutive_misses": 0,
        "influence": "SUPPORTIVE"
      },
      {
        "id": "player2",
        "clan_id": "keelstrand",
        "leader_character_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "leader_title": "Leader of Keelstrand",
        "control_status": "ACTIVE",
        "eligible": true,
        "expected_submission": true,
        "consecutive_misses": 0,
        "influence": "SUPPORTIVE"
      },
      {
        "id": "player3",
        "clan_id": "high-barley",
        "leader_character_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "leader_title": "Leader of High Barley",
        "control_status": "ACTIVE",
        "eligible": true,
        "expected_submission": true,
        "consecutive_misses": 0,
        "influence": "SUPPORTIVE"
      },
      {
        "id": "player4",
        "clan_id": "ternhaven",
        "leader_character_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "leader_title": "Leader of Ternhaven",
        "control_status": "ACTIVE",
        "eligible": true,
        "expected_submission": true,
        "consecutive_misses": 0,
        "influence": "SUPPORTIVE"
      }
    ],
    "places": [
      {
        "id": "sound",
        "name": "Saltwind Sound",
        "kind": "REGION",
        "population": null,
        "summary": "A mundane narrow coastal sound with four resident communities, navigable shore segments and uncertain reception. No compulsory regional crisis.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere",
        "name": "Saltmere",
        "kind": "SETTLEMENT",
        "population": 151,
        "summary": "Your village stands on the western shallows of a narrow sound. Brine pools lie east, garden strips on the low rise west, and a coppice beyond them. A shingle path leads north to an empty marker beach; reeds conceal the shore south. The tidal mud looks walkable from above but holds deep runnels. Your two shallow fishing skiffs can follow the western shore in settled weather; neither is suited to an exposed crossing in a gale.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand",
        "name": "Keelstrand",
        "kind": "SETTLEMENT",
        "population": 149,
        "summary": "Your settlement occupies the northern timbered creek of the sound. The boat shed sits above the tide; the nearest straight timber grows uphill and must be dragged down a stony track. A western shore path reaches an empty marker beach in half a fair-weather day. A pack trail climbs southeast toward grazing country. Beyond its first ridge you have no current map. Your old fishing boat works within the creek; the unfinished larger boat cannot yet float.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley",
        "name": "High Barley",
        "kind": "SETTLEMENT",
        "population": 153,
        "summary": "Your village lies on a southern upland shelf above the eastern side of the sound. Fields surround the houses; rough grazing and a spring lie uphill. A pack trail runs northwest over a ridge; another descends east through alder ground toward distant coastal smoke. A small stream ford near the east descent rises after rain. You own pack goats and hauling frames, not a seaworthy boat. No coast-to-coast shortcut crosses the steep central ravine.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven",
        "name": "Ternhaven",
        "kind": "SETTLEMENT",
        "population": 150,
        "summary": "Your village sits inside the southeastern hooked inlet. Its inner landing is sheltered; beyond the bar, wind and ebb can make even a short boat journey dangerous. An alder path climbs west to a stream ford and upland meadow. The coast curves north around the eastern arm of the sound. Two small fishing boats work near shore; you have no current safe-weather survey of the full sound.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      }
    ],
    "characters": [
      {
        "id": "saltmere-leader",
        "name": "Leader of Saltmere",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "saltmere",
        "role": "Recognized player leader with modern memories",
        "goals": [
          "Determined by isolated player submissions"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "Not prescribed"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-c1",
        "name": "Nessa",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "saltmere",
        "role": "pan tender",
        "goals": [
          "protect skilled work and her witnessed fuel promise"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being treated as expendable"
        ],
        "relationships": [
          "saltmere-r1"
        ],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-c2",
        "name": "Orin",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "saltmere",
        "role": "net captain",
        "goals": [
          "preserve the catch and fair household shares"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "losing food to production targets"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-c3",
        "name": "Sava",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "saltmere",
        "role": "basket and drying-rack maker",
        "goals": [
          "test small improvements without wasting supplies"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being ordered to scale an untested device"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-c4",
        "name": "Fen",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "saltmere",
        "role": "bank and water keeper",
        "goals": [
          "maintain safe banks and clean drinking water"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "a warning being dismissed"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-c5",
        "name": "Evi",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "saltmere",
        "role": "shore walker",
        "goals": [
          "keep routes usable and journeys bounded"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being sent onto mud without a retreat"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-c6",
        "name": "Daro",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "saltmere",
        "role": "storekeeper",
        "goals": [
          "make ration and fuel allocations believable"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being accused of hiding shortages"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "name": "Leader of Keelstrand",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "keelstrand",
        "role": "Recognized player leader with modern memories",
        "goals": [
          "Determined by isolated player submissions"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "Not prescribed"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-c1",
        "name": "Mara",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "keelstrand",
        "role": "master carpenter",
        "goals": [
          "finish a durable boat and retain the yard’s reputation"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being forced to launch unsafe work"
        ],
        "relationships": [
          "keelstrand-r1"
        ],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-c2",
        "name": "Arel",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "keelstrand",
        "role": "fishing household speaker",
        "goals": [
          "receive the boat promised for shared food contributions"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "another indefinite postponement"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-c3",
        "name": "Tor",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "keelstrand",
        "role": "shelter keeper",
        "goals": [
          "get dry sleeping spaces before cold rain"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "the yard always taking first claim"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-c4",
        "name": "Ivo",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "keelstrand",
        "role": "timber and path scout",
        "goals": [
          "bring back usable timber safely"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "a preventable lifting accident"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-c5",
        "name": "Pell",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "keelstrand",
        "role": "rope worker with a strained wrist",
        "goals": [
          "teach sound lashings while recovering"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being expected to haul before healing"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-c6",
        "name": "Venn",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "keelstrand",
        "role": "garden and pack keeper",
        "goals": [
          "keep food moving without stripping local work"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "journeys that consume the harvest hands"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-leader",
        "name": "Leader of High Barley",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "high-barley",
        "role": "Recognized player leader with modern memories",
        "goals": [
          "Determined by isolated player submissions"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "Not prescribed"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-c1",
        "name": "Hesta",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "high-barley",
        "role": "field steward",
        "goals": [
          "bring the barley under cover before rain"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "avoidable crop loss"
        ],
        "relationships": [
          "high-barley-r1"
        ],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-c2",
        "name": "Cal",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "high-barley",
        "role": "care rota keeper",
        "goals": [
          "make dependent care a real labor commitment"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "quiet abandonment of less productive households"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-c3",
        "name": "Beren",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "high-barley",
        "role": "seed and threshing keeper",
        "goals": [
          "protect seed and dry handling"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "eating next year’s seed to conceal a shortfall"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-c4",
        "name": "Osa",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "high-barley",
        "role": "goat and pack handler",
        "goals": [
          "use modest transport reliably"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "overloaded animals on wet slopes"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-c5",
        "name": "Leth",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "high-barley",
        "role": "storehouse keeper",
        "goals": [
          "separate good grain from damp lots"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being blamed before the stores are inspected"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-c6",
        "name": "Jun",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "high-barley",
        "role": "spring and ford watcher",
        "goals": [
          "keep safe water and a usable descent"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "a crossing attempted during rising water"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "name": "Leader of Ternhaven",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "ternhaven",
        "role": "Recognized player leader with modern memories",
        "goals": [
          "Determined by isolated player submissions"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "Not prescribed"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-c1",
        "name": "Del",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "ternhaven",
        "role": "keeper of hospitality customs",
        "goals": [
          "honor a bounded welcome without shame"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "a visitor turned away in immediate danger"
        ],
        "relationships": [
          "ternhaven-r1"
        ],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-c2",
        "name": "Ves",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "ternhaven",
        "role": "household stores speaker",
        "goals": [
          "protect resident meals and dry beds"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "open-ended promises charged to unwilling homes"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-c3",
        "name": "Ruan",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "ternhaven",
        "role": "net and landing captain",
        "goals": [
          "keep crews fishing and landings orderly"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "hosting duties swallowing safe fishing days"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-c4",
        "name": "Kiri",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "ternhaven",
        "role": "boat and mooring tender",
        "goals": [
          "inspect gear before winter strain"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being pressured to launch with suspect rope"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-c5",
        "name": "Seli",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "ternhaven",
        "role": "alder-path guide",
        "goals": [
          "make careful journeys with clear return terms"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "being treated as an unlimited messenger"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-c6",
        "name": "Wen",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "ternhaven",
        "role": "well and hearth keeper",
        "goals": [
          "maintain water and clean sleeping spaces"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "crowding around damp bedding"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "May continue familiar tasks, inspect an observed problem, warn or appeal within known local capacity. No unobserved plans or foreign secrets are known.",
        "red_line": "Will object to immediate unsupported danger; further escalation requires established cause and means.",
        "escalation_position": "Ordinary cooperation with voiced local disagreement; no violent mobilization.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "visitor-ressa",
        "name": "Ressa",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "home_place_id": "sound",
        "role": "Independent seasonal basket mender traveling with two adult kin",
        "goals": [
          "Trade repairs for food while keeping the party safe"
        ],
        "fears": [
          "Being stranded after a refused open-ended demand"
        ],
        "relationships": [],
        "initiative": "Currently outside the immediate village routes on the southern coast. May approach Ternhaven during a suitable autumn travel window, carrying only personally observed news. No compulsory arrival; no knowledge of current private village conflicts.",
        "red_line": "Will not accept indefinite forced labor.",
        "escalation_position": "Small unarmed traveling household; bargaining or departure, no capacity to seize a village.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      }
    ],
    "factions": [
      {
        "id": "saltmere-households",
        "name": "Saltmere households",
        "scope": "LOCAL",
        "member_summary": "Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.",
        "leader_ids": [
          "saltmere-c1",
          "saltmere-c2"
        ],
        "interests": [
          "Household safety",
          "Credible allocation of finite labor"
        ],
        "controlled_resources": [
          "Household work time and customary shares"
        ],
        "current_agenda": "Late-autumn winterization is complete: pan bank is insulated against frost heave, skiffs are secured on high rollers, root stores are bedded in sand clamps, and households gather around shared longhouse hearths.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D01",
            "T002-D01",
            "T003-D01"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-households",
        "name": "Keelstrand households",
        "scope": "LOCAL",
        "member_summary": "Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.",
        "leader_ids": [
          "keelstrand-c1",
          "keelstrand-c2"
        ],
        "interests": [
          "Household safety",
          "Credible allocation of finite labor"
        ],
        "controlled_resources": [
          "Household work time and customary shares"
        ],
        "current_agenda": "Winter readiness is secured: boats are hauled on high skids, roofs are tied with lattice poles, the final timber sled run is safely stowed, and indoor boat joinery and cordage work continue in the shed.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D02",
            "T002-D02",
            "T003-D02"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-households",
        "name": "High Barley households",
        "scope": "LOCAL",
        "member_summary": "Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.",
        "leader_ids": [
          "high-barley-c1",
          "high-barley-c2"
        ],
        "interests": [
          "Household safety",
          "Credible allocation of finite labor"
        ],
        "controlled_resources": [
          "Household work time and customary shares"
        ],
        "current_agenda": "Upland winter defenses are in place: roofs are weighted with stones, grain stores and seed are rigorously inspected, pack goats are penned and fed, and communal hearths unite the households around the covered bowl.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D03",
            "T002-D03",
            "T003-D03"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-households",
        "name": "Ternhaven households",
        "scope": "LOCAL",
        "member_summary": "Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.",
        "leader_ids": [
          "ternhaven-c1",
          "ternhaven-c2"
        ],
        "interests": [
          "Household safety",
          "Credible allocation of finite labor"
        ],
        "controlled_resources": [
          "Household work time and customary shares"
        ],
        "current_agenda": "Landing hall air is clear and warm with smoke louvers in place, boats are hauled above storm tides, winter stores are audited and safeguarded on dunnage, and the trade embassy returned safely from the stream ford.",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D05",
            "T002-D05",
            "T003-D04"
          ]
        }
      }
    ],
    "facts": [
      {
        "id": "saltmere-scene",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "A gust carries white dust across the salt shed. At the hearth, two women hold opposite ends of the same split log. Neither pulls. Beyond them, wet nets drip onto the earth, and people stop talking when you step through the doorway.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-premise",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "You have awakened without memory of your old identity. You remember ordinary life in a modern society, but no modern equipment has come with you. The 151 people here treat you as their leader. Specific skills may be established through what you credibly attempt; doing or teaching work takes time.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-calendar",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "It is Early autumn, Year 1 (Y01-M07). The mornings are cool, with intermittent rain and occasional drying days. People expect wetter mid-autumn, stronger late-autumn winds, then short winter days, frost and occasional snow. Sea ice is not dependable. Weather can interrupt outdoor drying and travel; no particular storm or loss is foretold. Preparing roofs, fuel and stores now can work.",
        "domain": "WEATHER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-map",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "Your village stands on the western shallows of a narrow sound. Brine pools lie east, garden strips on the low rise west, and a coppice beyond them. A shingle path leads north to an empty marker beach; reeds conceal the shore south. The tidal mud looks walkable from above but holds deep runnels. Your two shallow fishing skiffs can follow the western shore in settled weather; neither is suited to an exposed crossing in a gale.",
        "domain": "GEOGRAPHY",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-conditions",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "The western pan bank is insulated against frost heave beneath a heavy revetment of reed bundles and turf flaps, with brine barreled in covered clay vats and greased pans stored under cover. Fishing skiffs rest lashed hull-up on high timber rollers above storm surges, while low-tide mudflat foraging and Sava's eel traps yield fresh catch. Garden roots are bedded in dry sand clamps, stores sit raised on dunnage, and longhouse hearths are banked for shared evening warmth.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D01",
            "T002-D01",
            "T003-D01"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-dispute",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-warning",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "After the last high tide, a thin damp line remained under the western pan bank. Fen says the bank has held for years but asks to inspect it at low water before another full boiling. You can see the line; you do not yet know what lies inside the bank.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-opportunity",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "Sava has woven a small raised drying rack whose fish stayed clean during the last fair spell. It has not been tested through prolonged rain. A sheltered clay hollow could store covered firewood if drained. These are possibilities for patient local work, not reasons you must leave home.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-neighbors",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "Evi shows you a shaped timber offcut washed onto the marker beach, bearing three chisel notches. From the rise, on clear mornings, you can see smoke north across the creek but cannot count houses. Evi has previously walked as far as the empty marker beach, half a fair-weather day north, and knows its tide retreat. She offers to guide a small party there or carry a message if you choose. No meeting or reply is promised.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-custom",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "At fuel allocations, each hearth lays a stone beside the claimant it supports. The stones witness a promise; they do not give every household a veto. People currently accept your leadership and await a decision. You may keep work local, change priorities or seek information without promising anyone a grand new order.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-contacts",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "Nessa is your pan tender. Orin is your net captain. Sava is your basket and drying-rack maker. Fen is your bank and water keeper. Evi is your shore walker. Daro is your storekeeper.",
        "domain": "CHARACTER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-concealed",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "A burrowing channel runs inside the western pan bank; it has not reached the spring. Fen knows only the damp line, not the channel. Inspection and packing can contain it; repeated full pans during high tides without repairs can widen seepage and lose brine or work time. Collapse, injury or spring contamination is not automatic.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "saltmere-capacity",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "statement": "151 residents, roughly 78 adults able to share heavy work; caregiving and meals occupy a substantial part of every day. Existing food about six weeks at ordinary consumption, with dependable small catches and roots if local labor continues. Dry fuel about six weeks for cooking alone or three with both industries at full rate; reduced salt output and air drying can preserve independent winter viability. No numeric automatic depletion rule.",
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-scene",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Rain has stopped on the half-built hull. Under its ribs, a child has arranged little boats from scraps. Above you, a roof mat lifts in the wind. A carpenter sets down her adze when the shelter keeper brings a leaking sleeping blanket into the boat shed.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-premise",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "You have awakened without memory of your old identity. You remember ordinary life in a modern society, but no modern equipment has come with you. The 149 people here treat you as their leader. Specific skills may be established through what you credibly attempt; doing or teaching work takes time.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-calendar",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "It is Early autumn, Year 1 (Y01-M07). The mornings are cool, with intermittent rain and occasional drying days. People expect wetter mid-autumn, stronger late-autumn winds, then short winter days, frost and occasional snow. Sea ice is not dependable. Weather can interrupt outdoor drying and travel; no particular storm or loss is foretold. Preparing roofs, fuel and stores now can work.",
        "domain": "WEATHER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-map",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Your settlement occupies the northern timbered creek of the sound. The boat shed sits above the tide; the nearest straight timber grows uphill and must be dragged down a stony track. A western shore path reaches an empty marker beach in half a fair-weather day. A pack trail climbs southeast toward grazing country. Beyond its first ridge you have no current map. Your old fishing boat works within the creek; the unfinished larger boat cannot yet float.",
        "domain": "GEOGRAPHY",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-conditions",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "All fishing craft are winched onto greased timber skids above storm tides on the gravel terrace. Dwellings are gale-proofed with lattice hold-down poles and doorway baffles, and runoff swales are cleared. The stabilized boat shed serves as an active indoor workshop where Mara shapes framing knees and oars for spring shipbuilding, Pell's apprentices repair nets and cordage, and stores are audited with a 20% winter reserve.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D02",
            "T002-D02",
            "T003-D02"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-dispute",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-warning",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Ivo points out powder beneath one old shed brace and a change in the door gap after rain. The shed still stands. Nobody has opened the brace to see how deep the damage goes. A heavy lift beneath it could be postponed, shored or inspected.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-opportunity",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Offcuts can repair smaller craft or make simple sled runners. Pell can demonstrate clean lashings while seated; training will occupy both learners and teacher. Covering the hull and renegotiating its delivery would preserve the investment, though people may disagree over what is owed.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-neighbors",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Venn brings a sack with barley husks caught in its seams, found beside the uphill pack trail, and recalls hearing a distant stock bell there before the last rain. Ivo has walked the western route to the marker beach, half a day away, where salt-smelling cord was once tied around a stake. Neither knows a neighboring leader or their current needs. You could investigate a route, send a bounded message or remain home. A small party following the pack trail can reach the first ridge in a day and return before dark only if it turns back early.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-custom",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Promises made in the yard are spoken over a laid keel with witnesses. Changed circumstances can reopen terms; that does not make the first promise imaginary. Households accept your authority, while expecting you to say whose work waits.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-contacts",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Mara is your master carpenter. Arel is your fishing household speaker. Tor is your shelter keeper. Ivo is your timber and path scout. Pell is your rope worker with a strained wrist. Venn is your garden and pack keeper.",
        "domain": "CHARACTER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-concealed",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "Rot is deep at the foot of the old shed brace but the adjacent frame remains sound. Ivo has observed powder and door movement only. An unsupported heavy hull lift can buckle this brace; inspection or temporary shores substantially reduce that risk. No sabotage, concealed enemy or inevitable collapse exists.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-capacity",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "statement": "149 residents, about 76 adults sharing heavy work. Food about six weeks plus garden roots and creek fishing; fuel adequate for ordinary cooking and partial heating with replenishment from managed offcuts. A dry local winter is feasible by staging the boat and roofs. Finishing hull requires the scarce carpenter plus several helpers for much of the month; full roof repair competes for that labor.",
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-scene",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "Cut stalks rasp against your legs on the path into the yard. A row of sheaves waits outside the storehouse. At the threshing cloth, a tired man rocks a sleeping child with one foot while keeping grain away from the damp edge.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-premise",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "You have awakened without memory of your old identity. You remember ordinary life in a modern society, but no modern equipment has come with you. The 153 people here treat you as their leader. Specific skills may be established through what you credibly attempt; doing or teaching work takes time.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-calendar",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "It is Early autumn, Year 1 (Y01-M07). The mornings are cool, with intermittent rain and occasional drying days. People expect wetter mid-autumn, stronger late-autumn winds, then short winter days, frost and occasional snow. Sea ice is not dependable. Weather can interrupt outdoor drying and travel; no particular storm or loss is foretold. Preparing roofs, fuel and stores now can work.",
        "domain": "WEATHER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-map",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "Your village lies on a southern upland shelf above the eastern side of the sound. Fields surround the houses; rough grazing and a spring lie uphill. A pack trail runs northwest over a ridge; another descends east through alder ground toward distant coastal smoke. A small stream ford near the east descent rises after rain. You own pack goats and hauling frames, not a seaworthy boat. No coast-to-coast shortcut crosses the steep central ravine.",
        "domain": "GEOGRAPHY",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-conditions",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "Dwellings and storehouses are gale-proofed with stone-weighted thatch ropes and smoke baffles. Grain sacks rest secure on raised timber dunnage under Leth's weekly inspection, with prime seed locked by Beren. Pack goats are housed in sheltered dry-stone pens with winter fodder and salt licks, while fuel is stacked dry on log runners. Shared evening hearths and the faithful observance of the covered bowl maintain community warmth and unity.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D03",
            "T002-D03",
            "T003-D03"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-dispute",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-warning",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "An earthy smell rises from the lowest store bay after rain, and one sack has a dark patch underneath. Leth says the upper racks smell clean. The smell is evidence of damp, not proof that all grain is spoiled; an inspection can distinguish usable stores from damaged portions.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-opportunity",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "A disused wool loft could take raised drying hurdles if cleared and kept ventilated. Osa can use the goats to shift small loads without pulling every caregiver into the fields. A smaller surplus may be a sound choice if it preserves care and seed.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-neighbors",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "Osa found fresh pack impressions on the northwest ridge trail; their destination is beyond the village’s current map. On clear evenings, Jun sees smoke east below the alder descent and has heard gulls and a carried bell. Jun knows the ford and can lead a cautious descent to an empty lower meadow in a day. A message party could continue toward the smoke after checking the route, but no neighbor’s reception or stores are known. You need not make that journey during harvest.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-custom",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "At harvest, households set aside a covered bowl for those who cannot come to the field. The bowl is a witnessed obligation rather than a claim that care takes no work. People accept your leadership but watch who is asked to carry the burden.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-contacts",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "Hesta is your field steward. Cal is your care rota keeper. Beren is your seed and threshing keeper. Osa is your goat and pack handler. Leth is your storehouse keeper. Jun is your spring and ford watcher.",
        "domain": "CHARACTER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-concealed",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "A cracked buried drain directs rainwater beneath the lowest store bay. Leth knows the smell and dark sack but not the buried crack. Untreated damp can spoil that bay gradually. Raised storage, sorting, drainage or using the loft can contain loss; it does not justify declaring the whole harvest poisoned.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-capacity",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "statement": "153 residents, about 79 adults available across heavy work and care. Old food five weeks plus milk and roots; harvest potential enough for six winter months and protected seed, but sustained rain and drying labor constrain the usable surplus. Fuel from local brush and managed woodland is adequate with gathering. A smaller surplus and bounded care rota are independently viable.",
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-scene",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "A kettle swings above the landing hearth while the inlet lies still beyond the bar. Beside it, spare sleeping mats are stacked against sacks of meal. The person counting the mats has stopped at the same place twice. Out on the beach, a net crew waves you toward a catch that needs sorting.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-premise",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "You have awakened without memory of your old identity. You remember ordinary life in a modern society, but no modern equipment has come with you. The 150 people here treat you as their leader. Specific skills may be established through what you credibly attempt; doing or teaching work takes time.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-calendar",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "It is Early autumn, Year 1 (Y01-M07). The mornings are cool, with intermittent rain and occasional drying days. People expect wetter mid-autumn, stronger late-autumn winds, then short winter days, frost and occasional snow. Sea ice is not dependable. Weather can interrupt outdoor drying and travel; no particular storm or loss is foretold. Preparing roofs, fuel and stores now can work.",
        "domain": "WEATHER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-map",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "Your village sits inside the southeastern hooked inlet. Its inner landing is sheltered; beyond the bar, wind and ebb can make even a short boat journey dangerous. An alder path climbs west to a stream ford and upland meadow. The coast curves north around the eastern arm of the sound. Two small fishing boats work near shore; you have no current safe-weather survey of the full sound.",
        "domain": "GEOGRAPHY",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-conditions",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "The landing hall is warm and breathable following Wen's installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath roof vents, with exterior walls banked with earth and doorways baffled. Fishing craft are hauled onto greased skids on the high inner beach, pitched, and lashed under thatch. Ves's storehouse audit establishes measured winter rationing with twice-weekly dunnage checks, wellhead ditches remain clear, and shore teams gather shellfish at spring tides.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D05",
            "T002-D05",
            "T003-D04"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-dispute",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-warning",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "Kiri shows you a pale frayed strand in the outer mooring rope and says the float jerked sharply on the last ebb. The rope still holds the small working boat. The cause and condition below water have not been inspected. The inner beach remains available for hauling boats above the tide.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-opportunity",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "An upper drying ledge could take racks without occupying guest space. Guests could be offered bounded work or service if they consent; there is no assurance any will come or accept. Maintaining local catches and limiting hospitality can be a complete strategy.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-neighbors",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "Seli saw smoke above the westward slope after the last clear evening and found barley husks beside the upper ford on an earlier walk. She can reach that ford in a day along the alder path. Del remembers traveling basket menders who sometimes use this landing in autumn, but knows neither their present position nor other leaders’ wishes. A shore or uphill message is possible if someone makes the journey. Smoke and old visits establish that you are not alone, not that a treaty exists.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-custom",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "The first guest meal is traditionally placed at the edge of the hearth where both host and visitor can see it. Older hosts disagree about what follows that first night. You hold the recognized leadership seat; an honest limit, a negotiated welcome or a quiet month of local work remains yours to choose.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-contacts",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "Del is your keeper of hospitality customs. Ves is your household stores speaker. Ruan is your net and landing captain. Kiri is your boat and mooring tender. Seli is your alder-path guide. Wen is your well and hearth keeper.",
        "domain": "CHARACTER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-concealed",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "The mooring rope is rubbing against an old submerged stone edge outside the inner beach; no person has cut it. Kiri knows the fray and jerking only. Inspection, replacement or hauling inland can prevent a break. A break could lose gear if the outer mooring continues in rough ebb, but cannot on its own justify drowning a leader.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-capacity",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "statement": "150 residents, about 77 adults sharing heavy work and care. Food five to six weeks plus sustainable local fishing and roots if crews are maintained. Fuel enough for ordinary month with local replenishment. The hall can house a small visiting party briefly; prolonged support of a large party displaces resident stores and dry-space uses. Refusing future nonemergency hospitality carries no automatic survival penalty.",
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "sound-geography",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "statement": "Objective geography: Saltmere on west shallows; Keelstrand at north creek; High Barley on southeast upland shelf; Ternhaven inside southeast hook below High Barley. Saltmere–Keelstrand shore trail takes one fair-weather day, with marker beach midway. Keelstrand–High Barley ridge pack trail takes two fair-weather days one way; High Barley–Ternhaven alder/ford path takes two fair-weather days one way, lower meadow/ford midway. Keelstrand–Ternhaven shore boat journey takes two daylight stages in settled weather, with beach stops; Saltmere–Ternhaven takes two daylight stages around shore or one exposed day across sound in suitable craft and weather. Listed craft support sheltered legs, not automatic exposed crossings. Heavy loads roughly double walking times. Rain can close the ford for a day or more; riders must inspect water level. Winter journeys need dry stores, companions and turnback margins, often doubling fair-weather times. Every community has at least one locally known approach to a connecting route, so a deliberate bounded expedition can make contact by Turn 002, or earlier if supported. No leader knows exact foreign geography from this fact.",
        "domain": "GEOGRAPHY",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "sound-weather-range",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "statement": "Calendar Y01-M07 to M12: early, mid, late autumn then early, mid, late winter. Seasonal rain, gusts, frost and occasional snow constrain drying, fishing, care and travel. Do not prescribe a catastrophe. Establish actual weather and consequences during adjudication, preserve sensible preparation, and do not add new survival mechanics.",
        "domain": "WEATHER",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "sound-visitors",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "statement": "Ressa and two adult kin are independent seasonal basket menders south along the coast. Del recalls past traveling menders but has no current location or arrival commitment. They can bring only directly observed route conditions and voluntary messages. Their agency is conditional, not a scheduled encounter. No external army, organized predatory faction, magic, or predetermined winner exists.",
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-bank-reinforcement",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Fen and the leader inspected the western pan bank at low water, discovering small seepage channels through the lower earth. Fen's crew packed and reinforced the bank with dense clay from the rise and turf sods, stabilizing the foundation before any boiling resumes.",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-stores-and-shelter",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Saltmere's two damaged roofs were re-thatched with marsh reeds before mid-autumn rains. Garden roots were lifted and stored dry. The autumn fish catch was divided between the smokehouse using allocated dry billets, dry-salting with reserve cakes, and Sava's canopied drying racks, preventing spoilage.",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-fuel-coppice",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Work crews coppiced willow and alder, limbing billets to season for winter. Shallow drainage trenches were dug around the sheltered clay hollow, and an open-sided thatched timber shelter was constructed where fresh wood sits raised on stringers.",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-marker-beach-patrol",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Evi completed a cautious day patrol to the marker beach. She observed additional worked timber offcuts in the flotsam and sighted hearth smoke across the northern creek from cover, returning safely before nightfall without being detected or making contact.",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-shed-shoring",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Mara and Ivo inspected the boat shed brace, finding rot concentrated at the foot of the post while adjacent framing remains solid. Sturdy timber props were erected to shore the corner and cross-beam, stabilizing the shed against autumn winds.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-roofs-and-boats",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "The unfinished hull was securely cradled and sealed beneath pitched thatch. Mara overhauled and caulked the existing fishing boat with seasoned offcuts. Pell trained apprentices in knotting and split-root lashings, enabling Tor's crews to tie thatch and seal all four leaking houses.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-stores-and-sleds",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Carpenters shaped two wooden drag-sleds from heavy offcuts to haul timber over the stony track without fraying rope. Venn lifted garden roots and beans into dry straw pits, and surplus creek fish were smoked and salted.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-patrol",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Ivo scouted the southeast pack trail to the first ridgeline, observing pack animal tracks and spotting distant upland grazing herds before executing a midday turnaround and returning safely before nightfall.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-high-barley-care-and-harvest",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D03"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Cal's care rota was instituted, gathering dependents in central spaces and relieving weary caregivers, with the covered bowl honored at every evening meal. Hesta paced the barley cut to dry intervals, while Osa used pack goats with hauling frames to carry sheaves, keeping harvest flowing without overburdening households.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-high-barley-storehouse-and-loft",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D03"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Leth and the leader sorted the lower store bay, salvaging damp grain for immediate meals and removing mold. Raised timber dunnage was laid to lift sacks off the floor, Beren converted the disused wool loft into ventilated drying hurdles, and prime seed grain was secured on upper racks.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-high-barley-ford-surveillance",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D04"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Jun observed two distant coastal travelers advance along the alder path to the edge of the stream ford and lower meadow. The scouts observed the shelf from cover and withdrew peacefully eastward down the alder path without attempting to cross the ford or approach the village.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "GEOGRAPHY",
        "id": "fact-ternhaven-alder-scout-report",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D04"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Seli completed a three-day reconnaissance along the alder path to the stream ford and lower meadow. She confirmed the trail is passable in early autumn, found fresh goat and pack tracks near the water, and sighted dwellings on the high upland shelf above before withdrawing eastward in accordance with orders.",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-ternhaven-mooring-and-boats",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Both fishing boats were safely hauled onto the inner beach above high tide. During slack water, Kiri inspected the outer mooring and discovered the rope chafing against a submerged stone edge; the mooring was cleared and re-rigged with tested cordage, while inshore fishing continued safely.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-ternhaven-stores-and-hearth",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Work crews built drying racks on the upper ledge to dry split fish and roots off the ground. The landing hall roof seam was re-thatched and pitched, dry firewood was secured under lean-tos, and coughing children were nursed to recovery by the central hearth.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-ternhaven-hospitality-policy",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T001-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "The leader established an explicit village hospitality rule: visitors receive shelter and a hearth meal for their first night under custom; on the second day, guests must provide reciprocal labor or receive travel rations and depart peacefully.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-pan-thermal-test",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Nessa conducted a low-intensity test boil on an inland pan using salvaged drift and deadfall, while Fen monitored the western bank at low water. The clay reinforcement remained solid without cracking or seepage, confirming stability under low heat while core dry billets remain reserved for domestic warmth.",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Evi and a companion reached the southern bank of the northern creek under cover of dunes. They observed an active boat yard on the opposite bank with timber sleds, an overhauled fishing craft, and permanent thatched dwellings, confirming a substantial neighboring settlement before withdrawing unseen.",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Fresh willow and alder billets were split into thin laths and stacked under the drained hollow shelter, accelerating seasoning. Inshore fishing continued in calm windows, drying racks were sheltered beside longhouses, and Daro's weekly inspection confirmed stored grain and cured fish remain free of mold.",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-shed-underpinning",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Mara and Ivo jacked the boat shed cross-beam, excavated to firm subsoil, and seated a broad flat river stone plinth. The rotted base of the corner post was cut away, charred against fungus, and fitted with a seasoned timber block sistered with hardwood splints and treenails, permanently securing the structure.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-sled-timber-and-fuel",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Work crews cleared and corduroyed the uphill track, using the two drag-sleds to haul straight trunk timbers, curved framing knees, and bundled deadwood before rains softened the trail. Logs were debarked and stacked on skids under thatched lean-tos to season for spring.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-fiber-and-swales",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Tor organized swales along uphill walls to direct runoff toward the creek, inspected central hearth clearances, and culled storage pits. Pell led apprentices in retting and spinning nettle and bast fibers into cordage, while caulking pitch was rendered from resin, charcoal, and ash.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-and-marker-patrols",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Ivo scouted the western marker beach, finding the stake intact with faint shore tracks nearby. Later, from a concealed observation post on the southeast ridge, Ivo observed managed pack goat herds grazing across the distant upland shelf before executing a disciplined midday return.",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-high-barley-harvest-conclusion",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D03"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Hesta's teams completed final sickle sweeps of standing barley during dry spells. Beren managed a continuous rotation through the wool loft drying hurdles to threshing cloths, ensuring the entire crop was cured, winnowed, and bagged without rain spoilage, with straw bundled for goat fodder and bedding.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-high-barley-store-and-fuel-security",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D03"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Leth stacked all newly harvested grain sacks exclusively on raised dunnage away from outer walls, maintaining daily moisture checks. Beren secured prime seed grain in marked sacks on the driest upper racks, while goat-hauling teams stockpiled deadwood, brush, and peat under covered eaves.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-ford-contact-high-barley-view",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D04"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "A four-person delegation from the coastal inlet, led by a woman named Del and the guide Seli, hailed Jun from the eastern bank of the stream ford. They approached openly and unarmored, presenting a woven gift basket of cured smoked fish and clean sea-salt. High Barley's leader and elders met them at the stream, exchanging peaceful greetings and learning that their village, Ternhaven, is a coastal fishing settlement seeking peaceful trade, while maintaining the stream barrier without admitting visitors up to the shelf.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-ford-contact-ternhaven-view",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D04"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Del and Seli led Ternhaven's four-person embassy along the alder path to the stream ford, observing a stone boundary cairn bearing a woven willow ring. They were hailed across the water by the ford watcher Jun and met by the upland leader and elders. Del presented the gift basket of smoked fish and sea-salt, explained Ternhaven's hospitality customs, and discussed future barter. The upland community, High Barley, received the gift courteously and affirmed peaceful relations across the stream, while keeping the meeting at the water boundary.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Ves and Wen cleared all dried fish and roots from the upper ledge racks into the landing hall ahead of driving rains. Sacks and root bundles were raised on timber dunnage away from walls, while shallow diversion ditches were dug uphill from the fresh-water wellhead to steer autumn mud and runoff away from the water supply.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-ternhaven-marine-safety-and-craft",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Ruan confined fishing strictly to the sheltered inner inlet, hauling both craft above the storm line during rough swells. Kiri inspected the re-rigged mooring at slack tides, while net crews utilized stormy days inside the hall to twist fresh cordage from bast stores and repair damaged netting.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Fen's crew dressed the western pan bank with a thick revetment of dry reed bundles and heavy turf flaps to shield the clay core from frost heave. Full boiling was suspended to conserve firewood, concentrated brine was barreled in covered clay vats, boiling pans were greased with fish oil, and a thatched timber canopy was erected over the springhead.",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D01"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Orin hauled both fishing skiffs well above storm-tide levels, lashing them hull-up on timber rollers beneath thatched mats. Foraging shifted to tidal shallows and Sava's woven wicker traps in the reed channels, harvesting cockles, mussels, and eels. Daro bedded roots in dry sand clamps, grain was raised on split-timber dunnage, and Sava's weavers shifted indoors to make draft screens and hampers.",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Arel's crews maximized the late-autumn fish runs before winching the fishing boat and creek skiffs onto greased log skids on the gravel terrace above storm tides, lashing them securely. Inside the stabilized boat shed, Mara and carpenters spent foul-weather days carving oars, shaping thole pins, drilling trunnels, and pre-fitting framing knees for Arel's spring vessel, while Pell's apprentices repaired nets and conditioned cordage with tallow and pitch.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Tor's crews gale-proofed all dwellings with lattice hold-down poles pegged at eaves and chinked walls with moss and clay, hanging hide baffles over doorways. Mara and Ivo completed the final drag-sled run for firewood logs and birch bark before stowing the oiled sleds. Venn audited all winter reserves, establishing a transparent weekly household rationing schedule that preserves an untouched 20% emergency reserve, with seed beans sealed in rafter vessels.",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D02"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Ivo conducted a final pre-frost scout to the southeast ridge before winter weather set in. From concealed observation, he noted that the distant upland pastoralists have moved their pack goat herds off the exposed slopes into sheltered stone pens near their settlement, confirming pastoral winterization, before returning safely.",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D03"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Work parties retied thatch spars and weighted roof ropes with stones along the eaves of all dwellings and the storehouse, adjusting smoke-hole baffles against down-drafts. Winter fuel was stacked on log runners under eaves with drainage furrows. Leth maintained weekly dunnage inspections and rodent trapping, airing surface-chilled sacks on loft hurdles, while Beren kept prime seed grain locked under separate watch.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D03"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Osa transitioned the pack goats from open slopes into sheltered dry-stone pens, rationing coarse straw, alder browse, and heather while overhauling pack harnesses and maintaining passive watch over the northwest trail. Cal coordinated shared evening hearths across households for fuel efficiency, where resting adults carded wool, spun yarn, and repaired tools while dependents were cared for, with the nightly covered bowl faithfully honored.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D04"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Wen oversaw the construction and installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath landing hall roof vents, drawing heavy curing smoke cleanly outside while preserving interior heat. Work crews banked earth and dense reed screens against exterior walls and hung weighted door baffles, while three-foot gravel firebreaks and ready water buckets were established around all hearths, with fuel pre-dried indoors.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "RESOURCE",
        "id": "fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D04"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Kiri and Ruan winched both fishing boats onto greased timber skids on the high inner beach well above storm tides, pitching seams with tallow and resin before lashing them beneath thatched hurdle covers. Ves completed an itemized inventory of winter provisions, establishing measured rationing and twice-weekly dunnage rotations, while low-tide foraging along the rocky shore yielded mussels, limpets, and kelp.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Evi, an elder, and a companion reached the southern bank of the northern creek and hailed the boatbuilders across the water in broad daylight with open hands. Keelstrand received the hail with prepared numbers and calm composure; the seasonal gift basket of pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed goods was transferred across the water. Both parties affirmed peaceful intentions and agreed that Marker Beach will serve as a neutral ground for seasonal barter, returning home without crossing the creek.",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "The rotational creek lookout spotted a three-person party approaching the south creek bank in daylight with open hands. Elders received their hail; the visitors identified themselves as peaceful coastal folk from Saltmere on the southern shallows, offering a seasonal gift basket of fine pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed craft. The gift was accepted across the water, peaceful relations were affirmed, and Marker Beach was agreed as a neutral seasonal meeting ground. Later, Ivo walked the marker beach and aligned three verification stones on a driftwood log.",
        "subject_id": "sound",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Del and Seli's four-person embassy met High Barley's leader and elders at the stream ford cairn. Jun's crew had erected a sheltered trade lean-to, guide rope, and water-level markers on the western bank. High Barley presented a return gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint. Across the stepping stones, a successful trial barter was conducted: High Barley traded surplus barley grain, thick wool blankets, and medicinal herbs in exchange for clean sea-salt and smoked fish. Both parties agreed to a monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days while keeping the stream boundary uncrossed.",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "domain": "WORLD",
        "id": "fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view",
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D05"
          ]
        },
        "statement": "Del and Seli led Ternhaven's four-person delegation to the stream ford cairn, meeting High Barley's leader and elders. High Barley received them with a return hospitality gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint beside their new trade lean-to. Across the flat stepping stones, the parties conducted a successful trial barter, trading coastal sea-salt and smoked fish for upland barley grain, heavy woven wool blankets, and dried medicinal herbs. Both clans agreed to hold a regular monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days without uninvited entry into either village.",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "value": null,
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      }
    ],
    "knowledge": [
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-scene",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-scene",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-premise",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-premise",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-calendar",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-calendar",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-map",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-map",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-conditions",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-conditions",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-dispute",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-dispute",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-warning",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-warning",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-opportunity",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-opportunity",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-neighbors",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-neighbors",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-custom",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-custom",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-saltmere-contacts",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "fact_id": "saltmere-contacts",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-scene",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-scene",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-premise",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-premise",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-calendar",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-calendar",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-map",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-map",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-conditions",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-conditions",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-dispute",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-dispute",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-warning",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-warning",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-opportunity",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-opportunity",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-neighbors",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-neighbors",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-custom",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-custom",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-keelstrand-contacts",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "fact_id": "keelstrand-contacts",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-scene",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-scene",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-premise",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-premise",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-calendar",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-calendar",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-map",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-map",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-conditions",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-conditions",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-dispute",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-dispute",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-warning",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-warning",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-opportunity",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-opportunity",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-neighbors",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-neighbors",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-custom",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-custom",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-high-barley-contacts",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "fact_id": "high-barley-contacts",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-scene",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-scene",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-premise",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-premise",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-calendar",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-calendar",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-map",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-map",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-conditions",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-conditions",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-dispute",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-dispute",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-warning",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-warning",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-opportunity",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-opportunity",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-neighbors",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-neighbors",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-custom",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-custom",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "id": "K-ternhaven-contacts",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "fact_id": "ternhaven-contacts",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "source_type": "INITIAL",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "learned_turn": 0
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-bank-reinforcement",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-bank-reinforcement",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-stores-and-shelter",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-stores-and-shelter",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-fuel-coppice",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-fuel-coppice",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-marker-beach-patrol",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-marker-beach-patrol",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [
          "saltmere-c5"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-shed-shoring",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-shed-shoring",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-roofs-and-boats",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-roofs-and-boats",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-stores-and-sleds",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-stores-and-sleds",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-patrol",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-ridge-patrol",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [
          "keelstrand-c4"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-high-barley-care-and-harvest",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-high-barley-care-and-harvest",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-high-barley-storehouse-and-loft",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-high-barley-storehouse-and-loft",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-high-barley-ford-surveillance",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-high-barley-ford-surveillance",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [
          "high-barley-c6"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ternhaven-alder-scout-report",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ternhaven-alder-scout-report",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [
          "ternhaven-c5"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ternhaven-mooring-and-boats",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ternhaven-mooring-and-boats",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ternhaven-stores-and-hearth",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ternhaven-stores-and-hearth",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ternhaven-hospitality-policy",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ternhaven-hospitality-policy",
        "learned_turn": 1,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-pan-thermal-test",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-pan-thermal-test",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [
          "saltmere-c5"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-shed-underpinning",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-shed-underpinning",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-sled-timber-and-fuel",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-sled-timber-and-fuel",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-fiber-and-swales",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-fiber-and-swales",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-and-marker-patrols",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-ridge-and-marker-patrols",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [
          "keelstrand-c4"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-high-barley-harvest-conclusion",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-high-barley-harvest-conclusion",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-high-barley-store-and-fuel-security",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-high-barley-store-and-fuel-security",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ford-contact-high-barley-view",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-ford-contact-high-barley-view",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ford-contact-ternhaven-view",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ford-contact-ternhaven-view",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [
          "ternhaven-c1",
          "ternhaven-c5"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ternhaven-marine-safety-and-craft",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ternhaven-marine-safety-and-craft",
        "learned_turn": 2,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [
          "keelstrand-c4"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view",
        "holder_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "id": "K-creek-parley-saltmere-view",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player1",
        "propagation_path": [
          "saltmere-c5"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view",
        "holder_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "id": "K-creek-parley-keelstrand-view",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player2",
        "propagation_path": [
          "keelstrand-c4"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "OBSERVED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view",
        "holder_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "id": "K-ford-barter-high-barley-view",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player3",
        "propagation_path": [],
        "source_type": "DIRECT_OBSERVATION"
      },
      {
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "epistemic_status": "REPORTED",
        "fact_id": "fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view",
        "holder_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "id": "K-ford-barter-ternhaven-view",
        "learned_turn": 3,
        "player_id": "player4",
        "propagation_path": [
          "ternhaven-c1",
          "ternhaven-c5"
        ],
        "source_type": "PROPAGATED"
      }
    ],
    "relationships": [
      {
        "id": "saltmere-r1",
        "source_id": "saltmere-c1",
        "target_id": "saltmere-c2",
        "basis": "Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.",
        "stance": "Accepts the shared compromise of smokehouse fuel priority and dry-salting while boiling is paused for bank repairs.",
        "intensity": "LOW",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "obligation_ids": [
          "saltmere-custom"
        ],
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D01"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-r1",
        "source_id": "keelstrand-c1",
        "target_id": "keelstrand-c2",
        "basis": "Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.",
        "stance": "Cooperating peacefully under the witnessed keel compromise, with fishing households receiving roof repairs and guaranteed food shares while the big boat waits.",
        "intensity": "LOW",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "obligation_ids": [
          "keelstrand-custom"
        ],
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D02"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-r1",
        "source_id": "high-barley-c1",
        "target_id": "high-barley-c2",
        "basis": "Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.",
        "stance": "Working cooperatively under the protected care rota and covered-bowl recognition, balancing field work with household needs.",
        "intensity": "LOW",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "obligation_ids": [
          "high-barley-custom"
        ],
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D03"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-r1",
        "source_id": "ternhaven-c1",
        "target_id": "ternhaven-c2",
        "basis": "Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.",
        "stance": "In agreement following the enactment of the two-stage hospitality rule, balancing traditional welcome with resident store protection.",
        "intensity": "LOW",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "obligation_ids": [
          "ternhaven-custom"
        ],
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D05"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "basis": "Successful bilateral trial barter conducted across the stream ford stepping stones, exchanging surplus grain and wool for coastal salt and fish, establishing regular monthly low-water exchanges.",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "id": "rel-high-barley-ternhaven",
        "intensity": "LOW",
        "obligation_ids": [],
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D04",
            "T003-D05"
          ]
        },
        "source_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "stance": "Honorable trade partner; values sea-salt and fish in exchange for upland barley and wool across the guarded stream ford.",
        "target_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "basis": "Trial barter successfully conducted at the stream ford cairn, exchanging salt and fish for grain, wool blankets, and medicinal herbs with agreed monthly low-water barter terms.",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "id": "rel-ternhaven-high-barley",
        "intensity": "LOW",
        "obligation_ids": [],
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T002-D04",
            "T003-D05"
          ]
        },
        "source_id": "ternhaven-leader",
        "stance": "Respectful and valued trade partner; prized source of upland barley grain and warm wool blankets across the stream ford.",
        "target_id": "high-barley-leader",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "basis": "Initial peaceful parley across the northern creek; Saltmere presented a seasonal gift of salt and smoked fish, Keelstrand acknowledged peaceful terms, and both agreed to Marker Beach as a neutral future barter site.",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "id": "rel-saltmere-keelstrand",
        "intensity": "LOW",
        "obligation_ids": [],
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D05"
          ]
        },
        "source_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "stance": "Peaceful recognition and agreement to meet at Marker Beach for seasonal barter.",
        "target_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "basis": "Saltmere delegation hailed across the northern creek in daylight, presenting a gift basket of salt and smoked fish; Keelstrand received the gift peacefully and agreed to Marker Beach as a neutral seasonal meeting ground.",
        "confidence": "CONFIRMED",
        "id": "rel-keelstrand-saltmere",
        "intensity": "LOW",
        "obligation_ids": [],
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "T003-D05"
          ]
        },
        "source_id": "keelstrand-leader",
        "stance": "Guarded respect and acceptance of Marker Beach as a neutral seasonal meeting ground.",
        "target_id": "saltmere-leader",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      }
    ],
    "institutions": [],
    "obligations": [
      {
        "id": "saltmere-custom",
        "party_ids": [
          "saltmere-c1",
          "saltmere-c2",
          "saltmere-leader"
        ],
        "terms": "At fuel allocations, each hearth lays a stone beside the claimant it supports. The stones witness a promise; they do not give every household a veto. People currently accept your leadership and await a decision. You may keep work local, change priorities or seek information without promising anyone a grand new order.",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "witness_ids": [
          "saltmere-c3"
        ],
        "due_key": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-custom",
        "party_ids": [
          "keelstrand-c1",
          "keelstrand-c2",
          "keelstrand-leader"
        ],
        "terms": "Promises made in the yard are spoken over a laid keel with witnesses. Changed circumstances can reopen terms; that does not make the first promise imaginary. Households accept your authority, while expecting you to say whose work waits.",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "witness_ids": [
          "keelstrand-c3"
        ],
        "due_key": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-custom",
        "party_ids": [
          "high-barley-c1",
          "high-barley-c2",
          "high-barley-leader"
        ],
        "terms": "At harvest, households set aside a covered bowl for those who cannot come to the field. The bowl is a witnessed obligation rather than a claim that care takes no work. People accept your leadership but watch who is asked to carry the burden.",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "witness_ids": [
          "high-barley-c3"
        ],
        "due_key": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-custom",
        "party_ids": [
          "ternhaven-c1",
          "ternhaven-c2",
          "ternhaven-leader"
        ],
        "terms": "The first guest meal is placed at the edge of the hearth under ancient custom, granting a dry first night. By established village policy, guests staying beyond the first night must contribute reciprocal labor or receive one day's travel rations and depart in peace.",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "witness_ids": [
          "ternhaven-c3"
        ],
        "due_key": null,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D05"
          ]
        }
      }
    ],
    "pressures": [
      {
        "id": "saltmere-pressure",
        "subject_id": "saltmere",
        "name": "Opening allocation conflict",
        "state": "Fuel compromise enacted: dry billets prioritized for fish smoking, boiling paused while the pan bank was packed and reinforced with clay, and dry-salting used to preserve catch without household grievance.",
        "progress": null,
        "maximum": null,
        "status": "COMPLETED",
        "last_updated_turn": 0,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D01"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "keelstrand-pressure",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand",
        "name": "Opening allocation conflict",
        "state": "Keel compromise honored: large hull safely sealed under thatch, fishing households prioritized for roof repair and food shares, and old boat overhauled for autumn fishing.",
        "progress": null,
        "maximum": null,
        "status": "COMPLETED",
        "last_updated_turn": 0,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D02"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "high-barley-pressure",
        "subject_id": "high-barley",
        "name": "Opening allocation conflict",
        "state": "Labor balance achieved: Cal's care rota established and honored with the covered bowl, while goat hauling and loft drying hurdles enable steady harvest without caregiver burnout.",
        "progress": null,
        "maximum": null,
        "status": "COMPLETED",
        "last_updated_turn": 0,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D03"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "ternhaven-pressure",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven",
        "name": "Opening allocation conflict",
        "state": "Hospitality policy enacted: first-night welcome honored under Del's custom, with reciprocal labor or respectful departure required thereafter, satisfying Ves and Ruan.",
        "progress": null,
        "maximum": null,
        "status": "COMPLETED",
        "last_updated_turn": 0,
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "APPROVED_DECISION",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION",
            "T001-D05"
          ]
        }
      }
    ],
    "rules": [
      {
        "id": "saltwind-baseline",
        "name": "Frozen v0.2 simulation baseline",
        "status": "ACTIVE",
        "scope": "CAMPAIGN",
        "effect": "Mundane causality; 1500 words; simultaneous monthly turns; six anchored scores and P=.65 mean+.35 minimum; causal uncertainty target and prerequisites; persistent bounded character agency; privacy; specific AI_GM elimination and emergent activation gates within SIMULATION only. General mechanics fixed; source rules bundle supplies detail.",
        "approval_id": "SIM-BOOTSTRAP-saltwind-sound-01",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        },
        "provenance": {
          "source_kind": "PRIOR_STATE",
          "source_ids": [
            "SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION"
          ]
        }
      }
    ],
    "attractors": [],
    "decisions": [
      {
        "id": "T001-D01",
        "title": "Saltmere Fuel Allocation, Pan Bank Reinforcement, and Food Preservation",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player1"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T001-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 1's plan astutely addresses the immediate fuel dispute by prioritizing dry billets for fish smoking while pausing full salt boiling to inspect and reinforce the leaking pan bank. Using stored salt cakes for dry-salting and Sava's canopied drying racks absorbs the surplus catch without overtaxing fuel reserves. Preventive coppicing and drainage preparation in the clay hollow secure future wood, and Evi's patrol strictly obeys observational caution.\nThe fuel allocation conflict is peacefully resolved with dry billets allocated to fish smoking, solar pan management maintained, and stored salt cakes utilized for dry curing. Fen and the leader inspect the pan bank at low tide, finding seepage channels that are packed and reinforced with clay and turf. The two leaking roofs are thatched, garden roots stored dry, willow coppiced and stacked in a drained hollow shelter, and Evi scouts the marker beach safely from cover."
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-D02",
        "title": "Keelstrand Hull Construction Pause, Shed Shoring, and Roofing Priority",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player2"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T001-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 2 makes a disciplined and well-orchestrated decision to prioritize leaking sleeping quarters over capital shipbuilding ahead of winter rains. Pausing the large hull under pitched thatch prevents joint rot, while overhauling the old boat maintains autumn fishing. Shoring the boat shed brace before heavy work mitigates structural collapse risk, and deploying Pell to run a lashing school turns an injured specialist into an effective training asset.\nThe unfinished hull is securely cradled and sealed under thatch, with completion deferred to spring. Mara overhauls and caulks the existing fishing boat. Tor's crews, supported by Pell's newly trained apprentices, tie thatch on all four leaking houses. The rotted shed brace is shored with props, stabilizing the building. Heavy offcuts become two drag-sleds, garden crops are stored in straw pits, and Ivo conducts a bounded scout up the southeast trail to the ridge line."
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-D03",
        "title": "High Barley Care Rota Protection, Storehouse Salvage, and Harvest Pacing",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player3"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T001-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 3 grounds their plan in realistic human capacity, formally establishing Cal's dependent care rota and observing the covered bowl custom to prevent caregiver burnout. Pacing harvest cutting strictly to drying throughput prevents grain spoilage. Sorting the lower store bay and erecting raised dunnage protects stored sacks from rising damp, while converting the wool loft into ventilated drying hurdles adds vital indoor processing capacity. Deploying pack goats for sheaf hauling relieves human labor.\nCal's care rota is established and honored with the covered bowl, maintaining household morale and protecting caregivers. Barley harvesting proceeds steadily during dry weather, hauled by Osa's pack goats. In the storehouse, Leth and the leader separate damp grain for immediate consumption, compost spoiled grain, and install raised timber dunnage. Beren converts the disused wool loft into ventilated hurdle drying space, and prime seed is safeguarded on upper racks. Outward travel down to the coast is avoided."
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-D04",
        "title": "Eastern Trail Reconnaissance: Ternhaven Alder Scout and High Barley Ford Surveillance",
        "type": "CROSS_PLAYER",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player3",
          "player4"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T001-A-GM",
        "summary": "The simultaneous reconnaissance operations resolve with realistic spatial and temporal pacing. Seli's 3-day scout from Ternhaven along the alder path reaches the stream ford and lower meadow, discovering signs of upland cultivation. Jun, maintaining high-shelf watch in High Barley, spots the scouts at the meadow margin. Respecting strict orders of engagement, Seli observes from cover and withdraws eastward down the alder path toward Ternhaven without crossing the ford or forcing contact, establishing mutual awareness without friction.\nSeli completes a three-day scout along the alder trail to the stream ford, noting pack tracks and sighting upland structures on the high shelf before withdrawing peacefully eastward. Jun observes the coastal scouts from the high shelf above the ford, noting their peaceful demeanor and eastward return. Both leaders acquire credible, evidence-limited knowledge of neighboring presence."
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-D05",
        "title": "Ternhaven Mooring Line Relocation, Boat Safety, and Hospitality Rule Enactment",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player4"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T001-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 4's plan immediately eliminates marine risk by hauling boats onto the inner beach pending inspection of the suspect mooring. Inspecting the line at calm slack tide discovers and resolves underwater stone chafing before rope breakage occurs. The two-stage hospitality rule masterfully reconciles Del's traditional welcome (dry first night, hearth meal) with Ves and Ruan's resource concerns (reciprocal labor required thereafter or respectful departure with rations). Building upper ledge drying racks and pitching roof seams protects village stores.\nBoth fishing boats are kept safe on the inner beach while Kiri inspects the underwater mooring, finding the chafing stone and re-rigging the line with sound rope. Drying racks are constructed on the upper ledge, the landing hall roof seam is pitched, and coughing children are nursed at the hearth. The two-stage hospitality rule is established and accepted by the community."
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-D01",
        "title": "Saltmere Pan Bank Thermal Testing, Runoff Diversion, and Northern Creek Surveillance",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player1"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T002-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 1's plan is grounded, disciplined, and within clan capabilities. Fen and Nessa execute a low-heat test boil on a single inland pan using deadfall/driftwood, avoiding thermal blowout of the packed clay bank and preserving core dry billets for winter heating. Perimeter runoff ditches effectively divert rainwater from the brine basins. Sava moves drying racks into shelter, and Orin keeps skiffs to nearshore seining. Evi conducts a cautious patrol to the southern bank of the northern creek without crossing, observing Keelstrand's yard from concealment and withdrawing safely before nightfall. Power 0.80 (Strong) supports high quality and caution without complications.\nThe low-heat thermal test confirms the reinforced western pan bank holds without cracking or weeping under low heat, while reserving dry billets for domestic warmth. Runoff diversion trenches protect brine concentrations from rain dilution. Thin willow and alder billets dry faster under the hollow shelter. Skiffs remain safe, and drying racks are sheltered. Evi's patrol reaches the southern bank of the northern creek, observing an active timber and boat-building settlement (Keelstrand) from concealment without crossing or being detected."
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-D02",
        "title": "Keelstrand Boat Shed Permanent Foundation Underpinning and Sled-Hauling Operations",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player2"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T002-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 2's plan demonstrates exceptional carpentry grounding and operational focus. Mara and Ivo jack the cross-beam, excise the rotted post base, bed a broad river stone plinth, and sister a seasoned timber block pinned with hardwood treenails and pitched caulking, permanently eliminating structural failure risk. Uphill track corduroying and drag-sled logging successfully bring down straight boat timber and winter deadwood before autumn rains turn the track to mud. Tor's swale ditches protect structures from runoff. Pell's fiber works and pitch rendering maximize wet-day productivity. Ivo's scouting safely verifies the western marker beach and southeast ridge. Strong power (0.80) ensures high craft durability and flawless scout restraint.\nThe boat shed foundation is permanently repaired atop a stone plinth with sistered timber, securing the building against winter gales. Straight timber and fuel are safely sledded down and stacked on raised skids. Dwellings and the yard are protected by drainage swales. Pell's team produces spun cordage and caulking pitch. Ivo confirms the western marker beach remains undisturbed with faint coastal foot traffic, and observes grazing goat herds on the southeast upland shelf from concealed ridge watch before returning safely."
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-D03",
        "title": "High Barley Final Harvest Processing, Storehouse Dunnage Hygiene, and Boundary Fortification",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player3"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T002-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 3 executes a comprehensive, well-sequenced agricultural closing plan. Concluding field sweeps during dry intervals feed directly into Beren's wool loft hurdle rotation, ensuring continuous drying throughput without bottlenecks or rain mold. Threshed grain is stacked on raised dunnage away from walls, and Beren segregates prime seed grain on upper racks. Winter fuel is gathered from deadwood and peat using goat hauling frames, while thatch spars are tightened. Cal adapts the care rota to indoor processing and preserves the covered bowl. Strong power (0.80) ensures full grain salvation and high community morale.\nThe barley harvest is successfully concluded and fully preserved; threshed grain sits dry on storehouse dunnage, prime seed grain is safely isolated, and barley straw provides winter fodder and bedding. Winter fuel is stockpiled under eaves, dwellings are tightened against gales, and the care rota and covered bowl maintain strong social solidarity."
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-D04",
        "title": "Eastern Stream Ford Contact: Ternhaven Embassy and High Barley Boundary Reception",
        "type": "CROSS_PLAYER",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player3",
          "player4"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T002-A-GM",
        "summary": "Both leaders demonstrate high diplomatic grounding, mutual restraint, and excellent coordination with established character agency. Del and Seli lead an unarmored, peaceful 4-person delegation along the alder path to the stream ford, carrying a gift basket of cured smoked fish and sea-salt. Jun observes their approach, notes their open hands, and hails them across the stream while notifying High Barley's leader. Jun's stone cairn and willow ring signal inhabited, vigilant, yet peaceful territory. High Barley's leader and elders meet the embassy across the stream barrier. Del delivers Ternhaven's traveler greetings, shares their two-stage hospitality rule, presents the guest-gift basket, and discusses future quiet barter. High Barley accepts the gift, confirms peaceful intentions, but maintains boundary discipline by keeping the meeting at the ford rather than permitting unvetted ascent to the shelf. Both delegations part with enhanced mutual understanding and verified security. Strong power on both sides (0.80) ensures no misunderstandings, accidents, or boundary friction.\nPeaceful first contact is successfully achieved at the stream ford without tension or incident. Ternhaven's delegation presents a gift basket of cured fish and sea-salt, conveys their hospitality terms, and confirms High Barley as an established upland farming community before returning home safely. High Barley receives the coastal gift, recognizes Ternhaven as a peaceful coastal fishing village, and establishes stable, guarded diplomatic relations across the stream ford barrier."
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-D05",
        "title": "Ternhaven Storm Defense, Upper Ledge Store Clearance, and Indoor Curing Shift",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player4"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T002-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 4 implements timely, grounded storm precautions. Outdoor drying racks on the upper ledge are cleared into the landing hall and storehouses before autumn rains cause rot. Incoming catches and root crops are transitioned to indoor curing and overhead smoking with managed roof vent airflow. Storehouse goods are elevated on split-timber dunnage, and uphill diversion ditches protect the fresh-water wellhead from mud runoff. Inshore boating limits are strictly observed inside the hooked inlet, boats are beached during rough weather, and foul-weather labor is shifted to cordage twisting and net mending. Strong power (0.80) ensures food stores and boats remain undamaged throughout mid-autumn squalls.\nFood stores are fully protected from coastal rot by moving outdoor racks inside, elevating goods on dunnage, and transitioning to indoor smoking. Wellhead drainage prevents muddy contamination. Fishing boats and crews remain safe inside the hooked inlet and are hauled out during gales, with crews producing replacement cordage and mended nets."
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-D01",
        "title": "Saltmere Domestic Winterization, Pan Bank Preservation, and Shallows Foraging",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player1"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T003-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 1's plan demonstrates exceptional discipline and environmental grounding (P=1.0). The decision to pause full salt boiling protects scarce dry firewood for domestic heating, while transferring concentrated brine to clay vats and greasing boiling pans prevents corrosion. Protecting the western clay pan bank with a thick revetment of reed bundles and turf flaps prevents frost heave during winter freezes. Canopying the springhead prevents debris and freeze fouling. Hauling the two fishing skiffs onto high rollers above storm tides eliminates hull damage, while shifting foraging to sheltered tidal mudflats (cockles, mussels) and Sava's eel traps maintains fresh protein without open-water risk. Bedding root crops in dune sand clamps protects against frost rot, and indoor basket weaving and communal longhouse hearth banking maintain domestic cohesion and fuel efficiency.\nSaltmere is fully winterized: the western pan bank is insulated against frost heave with reeds and turf, brine is safely vatted, and pans are greased with fish oil. Fishing skiffs are secured on high rollers under thatch, while shallows foraging and reed traps provide steady fresh food. Stored roots are safeguarded in sand clamps, grain is elevated on dunnage, and communal longhouse hearths preserve firewood while maintaining community morale."
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-D02",
        "title": "Keelstrand Storm Haul-Out, Structural Gale-Proofing, and Boat Shed Joinery",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player2"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T003-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 2's submission demonstrates exceptional operational orchestration and grounding (P=1.0). Arel's fishing crews maximize the late-autumn fish runs before winching all boats onto greased log skids above the storm-tide line, eliminating hull destruction from winter swells. Mara and Ivo complete the final timber and fuel drag-sled run before track frost hardens into ruts, then grease and stow the sleds. Dwelling roofs are secured with lattice hold-down poles, doorway hide baffles installed, and swales cleared. Mara converts the draft-proofed boat shed into an indoor workshop to carve oars, thole pins, and internal framing knees for Arel's spring vessel, while Pell's apprentices repair nets and braid bast cordage. Venn establishes an itemized ration plan holding a 20% winter reserve, and Ivo confirms pastoral winterization from the southeast ridge.\nKeelstrand is thoroughly secured against winter gales: all watercraft are winched onto high gravel skids, dwellings are gale-proofed with roof lattice poles and doorway baffles, and the final sled run secures winter fuel. The boat shed operates as an efficient indoor joinery workshop preparing components for spring shipbuilding, and storehouses are audited with a 20% emergency reserve."
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-D03",
        "title": "High Barley Roof Gale-Proofing, Granary Dunnage Hygiene, and Herd Winter Penning",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player3"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T003-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 3's submission displays exemplary agricultural and community leadership (P=1.0). Roof ropes are systematically weighted with stones along eaves and smoke-hole baffles adjusted against down-drafts. Fuel is consolidated on log runners under eaves with runoff diversion furrows. Leth conducts rigorous weekly storehouse inspections, using traps against vermin and airing surface-chilled sacks on loft hurdles, while Beren keeps prime seed grain isolated. Osa transitions pack goats to sheltered dry-stone pens with rationed straw, browse, and pack gear maintenance, while keeping passive watch over the northwest trail without risky mountain crossings. Cal's shared communal hearths and the nightly covered bowl preserve warmth, social solidarity, and care for dependents.\nHigh Barley is fortified against upland winter: dwelling roofs are stone-weighted, fuel is stacked high on runners, and granaries are protected from damp and vermin with seed grain locked. Pack goats are housed in sheltered stone pens, and communal hearths and the covered bowl sustain community solidarity and domestic industry."
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-D04",
        "title": "Ternhaven Landing Hall Ventilation, Craft Haul-Out, and Storehouse Audit",
        "type": "GROUPED_REVERSIBLE",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player4"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T003-A-GM",
        "summary": "Player 4's submission demonstrates exceptional environmental adaptability and structural grounding (P=1.0). Wen's wattled smoke louvers beneath roof vents solve the chronic smoke inhalation issue while retaining indoor warmth, and exterior earth-banking and door baffles block drafts. Clear hearth firebreaks and water buckets prevent fire hazards. Staging pre-dried firewood indoors ensures clean burning. Ves conducts an itemized audit of winter provisions and institutes twice-weekly dunnage checks with culinary salvage of damp goods. Kiri and Ruan winch fishing boats onto greased skids on the high beach above storm surges, pitch seams, and shift crews to indoor net and cordage repair. Low-tide rocky foraging stretches stores without sea risk.\nTernhaven's landing hall is warm, well-ventilated, and protected from drafts, with wattled louvers drawing out smoke and banked earth sealing walls. Boats are securely hauled onto high beach skids and pitched, stores are audited with twice-weekly checks, and shoreline shellfish foraging supplements winter food."
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-D05",
        "title": "Sound Inter-Clan Diplomacy: Northern Creek Initial Parley and Stream Ford Barter Exchange",
        "type": "CROSS_PLAYER",
        "status": "APPROVED",
        "affected_player_ids": [
          "player1",
          "player2",
          "player3",
          "player4"
        ],
        "approval_id": "T003-A-GM",
        "summary": "Both diplomatic operations resolve with flawless coordination, realistic pacing, and profound mutual caution across all four clans. (1) In the northern sound, Saltmere's three-person delegation (Evi, elder, companion) travels the shingle path, halts on the southern bank of the northern creek in daylight with open hands, presents Sava's gift basket of pressed salt, smoked fish, and woven reed goods, and hails the boat yard across the water. Keelstrand's rotational creek watch spots their approach and alerts the settlement, allowing elders to receive the hail with prepared numbers and calm composure. A small craft ferries the seasonal gift across the water without either party trespassing into the other's territory. Both parties agree that Marker Beach—situated neutrally between them—will serve as a future barter ground when conditions permit. Later, Keelstrand scout Ivo patrols the beach and places three verification stones on a driftwood log as a neutral sign. (2) In the southeast, Del and Seli lead Ternhaven's four-person embassy along the alder path to the stream ford cairn. High Barley has erected a sheltered trade lean-to, tensioned guide rope, and water-level markers on their bank. High Barley's leader, Jun, and elders meet them across the water, returning Del's earlier gift with warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried upland mint. The two clans conduct a highly successful trial barter across the flat stepping stones—trading coastal salt and smoked fish for upland barley grain, woven wool blankets, and medicinal herbs—and establish a regular monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days without uninvited entry into either settlement.\nPeaceful inter-clan diplomacy is established at both ends of the sound. In the north, Saltmere and Keelstrand parley across the creek barrier, exchange gifts of salt and fish for neighborly goodwill, and agree on Marker Beach as a neutral future barter site. In the southeast, Ternhaven and High Barley complete a fruitful trial barter across the stream ford stepping stones—exchanging coastal sea-salt and fish for upland barley, warm wool blankets, and herbs—and establish a regular monthly Ford Exchange while strictly honoring boundary sovereignty."
      }
    ],
    "approvals": [
      {
        "id": "SIM-BOOTSTRAP-saltwind-sound-01",
        "kind": "RULE_ACTIVATION",
        "authority": "SIMULATION_POLICY",
        "approved_at": "2026-09-07T16:18:33.294Z",
        "target_ids": [
          "saltwind-baseline"
        ],
        "scope": "Run configuration imports the selected rules as simulation baseline only."
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-A-GM",
        "kind": "ADJUDICATION",
        "authority": "AI_GM",
        "approved_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "target_ids": [
          "T001-D01",
          "T001-D02",
          "T001-D03",
          "T001-D04",
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "scope": "AI GM reviewed the complete locked simultaneous turn."
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-A-DELIVERY",
        "kind": "DELIVERY",
        "authority": "AI_GM",
        "approved_at": "2026-09-07T16:35:08.253Z",
        "target_ids": [
          "player1",
          "player2",
          "player3",
          "player4"
        ],
        "scope": "Independent AI narrative review passed: Joint causal consistency and narrative disclosure audit passed across all four clans.\n\n1. Causality & Prerequisites: All player plans operate strictly within mundane physical limits and established clan capabilities. Labor allocations, seasonal constraints, and resource trade-offs (e.g., green wood seasoning in Saltmere, pausing the large hull to secure roofs in Keelstrand, pacing barley cutting to loft drying capacity in High Barley, and beaching boats pending slack-water mooring repairs in Ternhaven) are fully grounded. No missing prerequisites were bypassed or magically granted by leadership scores.\n\n2. Simultaneous Interactions & Contact Pacing: Cross-clan movements resolve with realistic spatial and temporal pacing. In the west/north, Player 1's scout (Evi) reaches the marker beach and observes smoke across the creek without crossing, while Player 2's scout (Ivo) explores the southeast ridge trail with a strict midday turnaround, avoiding collision. In the east/upland, Player 4's alder scout (Seli) advances to the stream ford/meadow on a 3-day scout and sights upland dwellings, while Player 3's watcher (Jun) monitors the ford from the high shelf. Neither forced contact or diplomatic overreach occurs, and mutual awareness is established with strict observational boundaries.\n\n3. Character Agency & Dramatic Pressure: Named NPCs act strictly according to established knowledge, motives, and local customs (witnessed stones, keel vows, covered bowls, hearth hospitality). Grievances and allocation disputes were de-escalated through grounded compromise rather than arbitrary compliance or score override. Trope reviews correctly resulted in REJECTED_ALL dispositions, ensuring no contrived literary tropes or forced dramatic escalations were imposed.\n\n4. Narrative Disclosures & Information Privacy: All four private narrative reports strictly preserve epistemic boundaries. Concealed structural conditions (pan bank seepage channel, boat shed rot, cracked storehouse drain, submerged mooring rock) were revealed only to the extent physically uncovered by active inspection. No hidden scores, GM reasoning, trope names, other players' private intentions, or omniscient geographic facts leaked into player reports. Machine visibility envelopes align with authored prose, and uncertainty regarding neighboring clans and approaching weather is properly preserved.\n\n5. Mechanics, Scoring & Validation: Submissions complied with word counts (738 to 1050 words) with concise-submission fairness maintained. Substantive decisions (5 approved) fit the required target, without unauthorized rule or victory activations. No eliminations occurred."
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-A-GM",
        "kind": "ADJUDICATION",
        "authority": "AI_GM",
        "approved_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "target_ids": [
          "T002-D01",
          "T002-D02",
          "T002-D03",
          "T002-D04",
          "T002-D05"
        ],
        "scope": "AI GM reviewed the complete locked simultaneous turn."
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-A-DELIVERY",
        "kind": "DELIVERY",
        "authority": "AI_GM",
        "approved_at": "2026-09-07T17:46:11.571Z",
        "target_ids": [
          "player1",
          "player2",
          "player3",
          "player4"
        ],
        "scope": "Independent AI narrative review passed: The adjudication, state transitions, and narrative draft reports for Turn 002 of Saltwind Sound pass all joint causal-consistency and narrative-disclosure criteria across all four clans.\n\n1. Joint Causality & Physical Prerequisites:\n- Saltmere (Player 1): Low-heat thermal testing on an inland pan using deadfall/driftwood safely tests the reinforced clay/turf bank without risking thermal blowout or depleting domestic winter firewood. Splitting freshly cut green willow and alder into thinner laths accelerates airflow curing under the drained hollow shelter. Nearshore fishing and sheltered drying rack relocation protect food and skiffs against autumn squalls.\n- Keelstrand (Player 2): Permanent underpinning of the rotted boat shed corner post follows sound, grounded historical carpentry (jacking the cross-beam with timber wedges, excavating to firm subsoil, seating a broad flat river stone plinth, charring the cut post end, and sistering with a seasoned hardwood block, treenails, and caulking pitch). Corduroying boggy trail sections enables the two drag-sleds to haul straight trunk timbers, framing knees, and windfall deadwood before mud sets in. Runoff swales, hearth flue clearances, Pell's cordage apprentices, and pitch rendering fully align with mundane capabilities.\n- High Barley (Player 3): Harvest completion is paced to dry intervals and loft drying hurdle capacity, preventing indoor bottlenecks or rain mold. Raised storehouse dunnage protects grain sacks from rising damp, while Beren isolates prime seed grain on upper racks. Deadwood and peat are gathered using goat hauling frames, and Cal's adapted care rota and the nightly covered bowl sustain household unity.\n- Ternhaven (Player 4): Prompt clearance of exposed upper ledge drying racks into the landing hall prevents mold from coastal rain. Overhead rafter smoking with managed roof vents, raised split-timber dunnage, and uphill wellhead diversion ditches safeguard food and drinking water. Inner inlet boat restrictions, hauling craft during gales, and slack-tide mooring inspections eliminate maritime loss, while stormy days are productively spent twisting bast cordage and repairing nets.\n\n2. Simultaneous Interactions & Contact Pacing:\n- West/North Creek & Marker Beach: Saltmere's scout (Evi) reaches the southern bank of the northern creek under dune cover and observes Keelstrand's boat yard, timber sleds, overhauled boat, and dwellings from concealment, withdrawing unseen. Keelstrand's scout (Ivo) patrols the western marker beach on a separate morning, finding the stake intact and noting faint tracks in gravel. Neither scout oversteps boundaries or forces premature collision.\n- Southeast Ridge & Upland Shelf: Keelstrand's scout (Ivo) establishes a concealed observation post on the southeast ridge, sightings managed pack goat herds grazing on the distant upland shelf, and executes a disciplined midday turnaround. High Barley's herder (Osa) grazes goats on the upper shelf while maintaining passive watch over the northwest trail. Both parties remain safe and unengaged.\n- Eastern Alder Trail & Stream Ford: Ternhaven's 4-person embassy (Del, Seli, and two companions) travels 2 days along the alder path to the stream ford, unarmored and bearing a gift basket of cured smoked fish and sea-salt. High Barley's ford watcher (Jun) halts them across the stream and alerts the elders. High Barley's leader meets them at the stream barrier, receiving the gift and acknowledging peaceful intentions while maintaining boundary vigilance. Both parties part with verified security and mutual respect.\n\n3. Character Agency & Dramatic Pressure:\n- Named NPCs (Fen, Nessa, Orin, Sava, Daro, Evi; Mara, Ivo, Tor, Pell, Venn, Arel; Hesta, Beren, Cal, Leth, Osa, Jun; Del, Seli, Ves, Ruan, Kiri, Wen) act strictly according to established roles, knowledge, motives, and local customs (witnessed stones, keel promises, covered bowls, two-stage hearth hospitality).\n- The dramatic-pressure review for the stream ford contact was properly conducted, and the trope review (PR-T002-01) correctly resulted in a REJECTED_ALL disposition, rejecting extreme melodramatic archetypes ('Broken Pedestal', 'Doomed Hometown') in favor of grounded mundane diplomacy.\n\n4. Narrative Disclosures & Information Privacy:\n- Each clan's narrative report strictly preserves epistemic boundaries.\n- No player learns another player's private submissions, hidden motives, or unobserved domestic developments.\n- Player 1 learns of a substantial boat-building settlement across the creek without learning Keelstrand's name or internal state. Player 2 confirms faint marker beach tracks and distant upland pastoralists without learning High Barley's identity. Player 3 and Player 4 learn only what was voluntarily spoken and observed across the stream ford barrier.\n- No hidden integer scores, power formulas (P=0.80), GM reasoning, or trope classifications appear in player reports. Uncertainty regarding approaching winter weather and future inter-clan relations is properly preserved.\n\n5. Mechanics, Adjudication & Schema Integrity:\n- All four submissions respected the word count limit (940 to 1315 words).\n- Five substantive decisions (T002-D01 through T002-D05) fall within the required 3-5 target, with all state changes correctly recorded in the authoritative JSON state. No unauthorized emergent rules or victory attractors were activated. No eliminations occurred."
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-A-GM",
        "kind": "ADJUDICATION",
        "authority": "AI_GM",
        "approved_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "target_ids": [
          "T003-D01",
          "T003-D02",
          "T003-D03",
          "T003-D04",
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "scope": "AI GM reviewed the complete locked simultaneous turn."
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-A-DELIVERY",
        "kind": "DELIVERY",
        "authority": "AI_GM",
        "approved_at": "2026-09-07T18:01:29.964Z",
        "target_ids": [
          "player1",
          "player2",
          "player3",
          "player4"
        ],
        "scope": "Independent AI narrative review passed: Turn 003 of Saltwind Sound satisfies all causal-consistency and narrative-disclosure criteria across all four clans.\n\n1. Joint Causality & Physical Prerequisites:\n- Saltmere (Player 1): Pausing full salt boiling directly preserves firewood for domestic survival hearths. Dressing the western pan bank with a thick revetment of reed bundles and turf flaps physically insulates the packed clay core against freezing frost heave. Greasing pans with rendered fish oil protects metal surfaces from salty atmospheric moisture, and canopied springhead drainage preserves potable water. Hauling skiffs hull-up onto timber rollers above storm surges avoids gale damage, while low-tide mudflat foraging and Sava's wicker eel traps sustain protein intake. Dune sand clamps effectively prevent root crop shriveling and frost-rot.\n- Keelstrand (Player 2): Fishing crews maximize late-autumn fish runs before winching boats onto greased skids above the storm-tide terrace, preventing winter swell damage. Completing the final timber/fuel drag-sled haul before track mud freezes solid preserves sled runners and trail integrity. Securing dwelling roofs with lattice hold-down poles, installing doorway hide baffles, and clearing swales protects structures from winter gales. Shifting skilled woodworkers into the stabilized boat shed to pre-fabricate oars, thole pins, and internal framing knees prepares for spring shipbuilding without risking outdoor exposure. Venn's itemized ration schedule establishes a transparent weekly plan with a 20% emergency reserve.\n- High Barley (Player 3): Stone-weighting roof ropes along eaves, retrying thatch spars, and adjusting smoke-hole baffles gales-proofs upland dwellings and granaries. Consolidating winter fuel on log runners with diversion furrows prevents ground moisture absorption. Leth's weekly dunnage inspections, rodent trapping, and loft hurdle aeration protect bagged barley, while Beren keeps prime seed grain locked on upper racks. Moving pack goats to sheltered dry-stone pens with coarse straw and browse protects the herd from mountain gales. Cal's shared communal hearths and the nightly covered bowl reinforce social solidarity and protect caregivers and dependents.\n- Ternhaven (Player 4): Wen's wattled smoke louvers beneath landing hall roof vents successfully exhaust curing smoke while maintaining ground-level warmth, resolving the chronic smoke hazard. Banked earth, reed screens, weighted door baffles, three-foot gravel hearth firebreaks, and pre-dried indoor firewood secure living quarters against drafts and fire hazards. Winching fishing craft onto high beach skids, pitching seams, and lashing under thatch protects timbers against frost splitting. Shifting to low-spring-tide rocky shoreline foraging (mussels, limpets, kelp) and indoor net repair safely stretches winter food. Ves's storehouse audit establishes a measured daily rationing baseline.\n\n2. Simultaneous Interactions & Contact Pacing:\n- Northern Creek & Marker Beach: Saltmere's three-person embassy (Evi, elder, companion) halts on the southern bank in broad daylight with open hands, hails across the creek, and presents a gift basket of salt, smoked fish, and reed craft. Keelstrand's rotational creek watch spots their approach and alerts elders, who receive the hail with prepared numbers and calm composure. The gift is transferred across the water without either party crossing the creek or entering foreign settlements. Both parties agree that Marker Beach will serve as a neutral seasonal meeting ground. Keelstrand scout Ivo later walks the beach and aligns three verification stones on a driftwood log.\n- Southeast Ridge & Upland Basin: Keelstrand scout Ivo conducts a final pre-frost patrol to the first ridgeline, observing from concealed watch that the upland pastoralists have moved their goat herds from open slopes into sheltered stone pens adjoining their settlement, confirming pastoral winterization before executing a disciplined, safe withdrawal. High Barley's herder Osa maintains passive watch over the northwest trail from the upper pens without crossing into unmapped territory.\n- Stream Ford Barter Exchange: Ternhaven's four-person delegation (Del, Seli, two companions) travels along the alder path to the stream ford cairn. High Barley has erected a sheltered trade lean-to, guide rope, and water-level markers on the western bank. High Barley's leader and elders meet them across the water, presenting a return hospitality gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint. Across the flat stepping stones, the two clans execute a highly successful trial barter—exchanging coastal sea-salt and smoked fish for upland barley grain, woven wool blankets, and medicinal herbs—and establish a regular monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days while strictly preserving boundary sovereignty.\n\n3. Character Agency, Customs, & Trope Reviews:\n- All named NPCs (Fen, Nessa, Orin, Sava, Daro, Evi; Mara, Arel, Tor, Ivo, Pell, Venn; Hesta, Beren, Cal, Leth, Osa, Jun; Del, Seli, Ves, Ruan, Kiri, Wen) act strictly in accordance with their recorded roles, knowledge, motives, and capacities. Witnessed stones, keel vows, covered bowls, and two-stage hearth hospitality customs meaningfully guide internal cohesion and external diplomacy.\n- Dramatic pressure reviews (PR-T003-01 for the Northern Creek encounter and PR-T003-02 for the Stream Ford barter) were conducted properly, with both resulting in REJECTED_ALL dispositions. No contrived literary tropes or forced dramatic escalations were introduced.\n\n4. Narrative Disclosures & Information Privacy:\n- All four narrative reports strictly adhere to player-specific epistemic envelopes.\n- No hidden integer scores, leadership power formulas (P=1.0), GM reasoning, or trope classifications leak into prose.\n- Cross-clan boundaries are scrupulously maintained: Player 1 learns that Keelstrand is a vigilant, organized community across the creek agreeing to Marker Beach barter, but learns none of Keelstrand's internal carpentry, hull oaths, or ridge patrols; Player 2 learns of Saltmere's peaceful greeting and observes upland herd penning without learning High Barley's name, culture, or store state; Players 3 and 4 learn only what was observed and spoken across the stream ford stepping stones, with neither gaining knowledge of the other's domestic arrangements or interior village life.\n- All material visible consequences, labor trade-offs, and unresolved seasonal pressures (shortened days, frost, rising stream levels, confinement) are communicated clearly.\n\n5. Mechanics, Adjudication, & Turn 003 Midpoint Review:\n- All four submissions respected the 1500-word limit (978 to 1327 words).\n- Five substantive decisions (T003-D01 to T003-D05) fall within the 3-5 target, with all changes accurately recorded in state records.\n- In accordance with the rules for the Turn 003 Midpoint Review, voluntary attractors were evaluated and no victory attractor was promoted, with evidence-based program observations properly recorded. No eliminations occurred."
      }
    ],
    "state_changes": [
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-1",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-pressure",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-2",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-pressure",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Fuel compromise enacted: dry billets prioritized for fish smoking, boiling paused while the pan bank was packed and reinforced with clay, and dry-salting used to preserve catch without household grievance.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-3",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-households\",\"name\":\"Saltmere households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"saltmere-c1\",\"saltmere-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-households\",\"name\":\"Saltmere households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"saltmere-c1\",\"saltmere-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Early autumn fuel compromise is holding: Nessa accepted paused boiling while repairing the pan bank, and Orin secured dry billets for smoking alongside dry-salting.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-4",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-r1",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-r1\",\"source_id\":\"saltmere-c1\",\"target_id\":\"saltmere-c2\",\"basis\":\"Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.\",\"stance\":\"Disagrees over the present allocation, while accepting ordinary discussion.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"saltmere-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-r1\",\"source_id\":\"saltmere-c1\",\"target_id\":\"saltmere-c2\",\"basis\":\"Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.\",\"stance\":\"Accepts the shared compromise of smokehouse fuel priority and dry-salting while boiling is paused for bank repairs.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"saltmere-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-5",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-r1",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-r1\",\"source_id\":\"saltmere-c1\",\"target_id\":\"saltmere-c2\",\"basis\":\"Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.\",\"stance\":\"Accepts the shared compromise of smokehouse fuel priority and dry-salting while boiling is paused for bank repairs.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"saltmere-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-r1\",\"source_id\":\"saltmere-c1\",\"target_id\":\"saltmere-c2\",\"basis\":\"Nessa, who tends the pans, asks for the dry billets promised at the last gathering. Orin, whose household fishes, points at the smoking rack and says fish will spoil if the pans take everything. Neither claims that all production must continue: both want the cost of a reduction to be acknowledged. Several families will work on either task, but cannot do both at once.\",\"stance\":\"Accepts the shared compromise of smokehouse fuel priority and dry-salting while boiling is paused for bank repairs.\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"saltmere-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-6",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"statement\":\"The storekeeper shows you dry fish, peas and barley sufficient for several weeks of ordinary meals, with garden roots still to lift. There are spare salt cakes, working pans, repairable nets, hand axes and few spare cutting edges. No forge operates here. The dry wood stack cannot sustain both full salt boiling and the customary smoking of the autumn catch. Willow cutting and air drying can add future fuel, but fresh wood will not immediately replace dry billets. Houses are standing; two thatched roofs need patching. Drinking water comes from a spring above the pools. There is no present outbreak or organized armed threat.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"statement\":\"Two roofs have been re-thatched against rain. Garden roots are lifted and stored, while the autumn catch is secured through smoking, dry-salting with reserve cakes, and Sava's canopied racks. Fresh willow billets season in a drained, thatched hollow shelter, and the western pan bank has been reinforced.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-7",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-bank-reinforcement",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-bank-reinforcement\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Fen and the leader inspected the western pan bank at low water, discovering small seepage channels through the lower earth. Fen's crew packed and reinforced the bank with dense clay from the rise and turf sods, stabilizing the foundation before any boiling resumes.\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-8",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-bank-reinforcement",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-bank-reinforcement\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-bank-reinforcement\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-9",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-stores-and-shelter",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-stores-and-shelter\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Saltmere's two damaged roofs were re-thatched with marsh reeds before mid-autumn rains. Garden roots were lifted and stored dry. The autumn fish catch was divided between the smokehouse using allocated dry billets, dry-salting with reserve cakes, and Sava's canopied drying racks, preventing spoilage.\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-10",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-stores-and-shelter",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-stores-and-shelter\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-stores-and-shelter\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-11",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-fuel-coppice",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-fuel-coppice\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Work crews coppiced willow and alder, limbing billets to season for winter. Shallow drainage trenches were dug around the sheltered clay hollow, and an open-sided thatched timber shelter was constructed where fresh wood sits raised on stringers.\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-12",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-fuel-coppice",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-fuel-coppice\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-fuel-coppice\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-13",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-marker-beach-patrol",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-marker-beach-patrol\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Evi completed a cautious day patrol to the marker beach. She observed additional worked timber offcuts in the flotsam and sighted hearth smoke across the northern creek from cover, returning safely before nightfall without being detected or making contact.\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-14",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-marker-beach-patrol",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-marker-beach-patrol\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-marker-beach-patrol\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[\"saltmere-c5\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-15",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-pressure",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-16",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-pressure",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Keel compromise honored: large hull safely sealed under thatch, fishing households prioritized for roof repair and food shares, and old boat overhauled for autumn fishing.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-17",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-households\",\"name\":\"Keelstrand households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"keelstrand-c1\",\"keelstrand-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-households\",\"name\":\"Keelstrand households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"keelstrand-c1\",\"keelstrand-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"The keel agreement is holding: sleeping quarters are weatherproofed, fishing families received garden shares, and the yard focuses on old boat maintenance and sled hauling.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-18",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-r1",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-r1\",\"source_id\":\"keelstrand-c1\",\"target_id\":\"keelstrand-c2\",\"basis\":\"Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.\",\"stance\":\"Disagrees over the present allocation, while accepting ordinary discussion.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"keelstrand-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-r1\",\"source_id\":\"keelstrand-c1\",\"target_id\":\"keelstrand-c2\",\"basis\":\"Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.\",\"stance\":\"Cooperating peacefully under the witnessed keel compromise, with fishing households receiving roof repairs and guaranteed food shares while the big boat waits.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"keelstrand-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-19",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-r1",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-r1\",\"source_id\":\"keelstrand-c1\",\"target_id\":\"keelstrand-c2\",\"basis\":\"Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.\",\"stance\":\"Cooperating peacefully under the witnessed keel compromise, with fishing households receiving roof repairs and guaranteed food shares while the big boat waits.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"keelstrand-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-r1\",\"source_id\":\"keelstrand-c1\",\"target_id\":\"keelstrand-c2\",\"basis\":\"Mara promised Arel and the fishing households a sound boat before the late-autumn runs. Arel has helped feed the yard and wants that promise kept. Tor asks that roof crews come first, showing you the wet blanket. Mara says the hull can be safely paused if covered; finishing it while making every roof sound will require more skilled hands than the yard has.\",\"stance\":\"Cooperating peacefully under the witnessed keel compromise, with fishing households receiving roof repairs and guaranteed food shares while the big boat waits.\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"keelstrand-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-20",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"statement\":\"Households have dried fish, beans and roots sufficient for several weeks, with garden crops still available. Timber and seasoned offcuts are plentiful by coastal standards, but sound cordage, resin and sharp tool edges are limited. Roof thatch is gathered but needs hands to tie it. Four houses leak over sleeping places. Most villagers are healthy; Pell is nursing a strained wrist and cannot haul beams. There is no standing force beyond ordinary watch and hunting tools.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"statement\":\"All four leaking houses have been re-thatched and lashed water-tight. The boat shed is safely shored with props, the unfinished hull is protected under pitched thatch, and the old fishing boat has been overhauled and caulked. Garden roots and beans are safely stored in straw pits, and two wooden drag-sleds are ready for timber hauling.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-21",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-shed-shoring",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-shed-shoring\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Mara and Ivo inspected the boat shed brace, finding rot concentrated at the foot of the post while adjacent framing remains solid. Sturdy timber props were erected to shore the corner and cross-beam, stabilizing the shed against autumn winds.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-22",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-shed-shoring",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-shed-shoring\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-shed-shoring\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-23",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-roofs-and-boats",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-roofs-and-boats\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"The unfinished hull was securely cradled and sealed beneath pitched thatch. Mara overhauled and caulked the existing fishing boat with seasoned offcuts. Pell trained apprentices in knotting and split-root lashings, enabling Tor's crews to tie thatch and seal all four leaking houses.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-24",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-roofs-and-boats",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-roofs-and-boats\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-roofs-and-boats\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-25",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-stores-and-sleds",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-stores-and-sleds\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Carpenters shaped two wooden drag-sleds from heavy offcuts to haul timber over the stony track without fraying rope. Venn lifted garden roots and beans into dry straw pits, and surplus creek fish were smoked and salted.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-26",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-stores-and-sleds",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-stores-and-sleds\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-stores-and-sleds\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-27",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-patrol",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-ridge-patrol\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Ivo scouted the southeast pack trail to the first ridgeline, observing pack animal tracks and spotting distant upland grazing herds before executing a midday turnaround and returning safely before nightfall.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-28",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-ridge-patrol",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-ridge-patrol\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-ridge-patrol\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[\"keelstrand-c4\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-29",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-pressure",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-30",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-pressure",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Labor balance achieved: Cal's care rota established and honored with the covered bowl, while goat hauling and loft drying hurdles enable steady harvest without caregiver burnout.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-31",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-households\",\"name\":\"High Barley households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"high-barley-c1\",\"high-barley-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-households\",\"name\":\"High Barley households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"high-barley-c1\",\"high-barley-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Caregivers and field workers are aligned: the covered bowl is honored nightly, dependents are cared for centrally, and goat hauling keeps sheaves moving into the loft.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-32",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-r1",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-r1\",\"source_id\":\"high-barley-c1\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-c2\",\"basis\":\"Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.\",\"stance\":\"Disagrees over the present allocation, while accepting ordinary discussion.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"high-barley-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-r1\",\"source_id\":\"high-barley-c1\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-c2\",\"basis\":\"Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.\",\"stance\":\"Working cooperatively under the protected care rota and covered-bowl recognition, balancing field work with household needs.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"high-barley-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-33",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-r1",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-r1\",\"source_id\":\"high-barley-c1\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-c2\",\"basis\":\"Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.\",\"stance\":\"Working cooperatively under the protected care rota and covered-bowl recognition, balancing field work with household needs.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"high-barley-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-r1\",\"source_id\":\"high-barley-c1\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-c2\",\"basis\":\"Hesta wants every able pair of hands in the fields during this dry interval. Cal reminds her that dependents still need feeding and tending, and brings you the unfilled household rota. Beren says some sheaves can wait, but not all the exposed crop through repeated rain. Counting caregivers twice will not bring the grain in sooner.\",\"stance\":\"Working cooperatively under the protected care rota and covered-bowl recognition, balancing field work with household needs.\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"high-barley-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-34",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"statement\":\"The standing barley is ripe. Covered old grain and beans will feed ordinary meals for several weeks, with milk, roots and a modest flock besides. A successful local harvest would cover winter eating and next year’s seed; the margin depends on drying and preserving the crop. Seed is kept separately by custom. Sickles, threshing cloths and baskets work, but dry covered floor space is tight. Homes are weatherproof except for minor eave leaks. Several caregivers are exhausted; there is no epidemic or present military threat.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"statement\":\"The barley harvest is successfully progressing, paced to dry spells and loft hurdle capacity. Cal's care rota protects household welfare, and the covered bowl is observed. The lower store bay is secured on raised dunnage, prime seed is separated on upper racks, and minor eave leaks have been patched.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-35",
        "subject_id": "fact-high-barley-care-and-harvest",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-high-barley-care-and-harvest\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D03\"]},\"statement\":\"Cal's care rota was instituted, gathering dependents in central spaces and relieving weary caregivers, with the covered bowl honored at every evening meal. Hesta paced the barley cut to dry intervals, while Osa used pack goats with hauling frames to carry sheaves, keeping harvest flowing without overburdening households.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-36",
        "subject_id": "K-high-barley-care-and-harvest",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-high-barley-care-and-harvest\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-high-barley-care-and-harvest\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-37",
        "subject_id": "fact-high-barley-storehouse-and-loft",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-high-barley-storehouse-and-loft\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D03\"]},\"statement\":\"Leth and the leader sorted the lower store bay, salvaging damp grain for immediate meals and removing mold. Raised timber dunnage was laid to lift sacks off the floor, Beren converted the disused wool loft into ventilated drying hurdles, and prime seed grain was secured on upper racks.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-38",
        "subject_id": "K-high-barley-storehouse-and-loft",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-high-barley-storehouse-and-loft\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-high-barley-storehouse-and-loft\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-39",
        "subject_id": "fact-high-barley-ford-surveillance",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-high-barley-ford-surveillance\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D04\"]},\"statement\":\"Jun observed two distant coastal travelers advance along the alder path to the edge of the stream ford and lower meadow. The scouts observed the shelf from cover and withdrew peacefully eastward down the alder path without attempting to cross the ford or approach the village.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-40",
        "subject_id": "K-high-barley-ford-surveillance",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-high-barley-ford-surveillance\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-high-barley-ford-surveillance\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[\"high-barley-c6\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-41",
        "subject_id": "fact-ternhaven-alder-scout-report",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"GEOGRAPHY\",\"id\":\"fact-ternhaven-alder-scout-report\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D04\"]},\"statement\":\"Seli completed a three-day reconnaissance along the alder path to the stream ford and lower meadow. She confirmed the trail is passable in early autumn, found fresh goat and pack tracks near the water, and sighted dwellings on the high upland shelf above before withdrawing eastward in accordance with orders.\",\"subject_id\":\"sound\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-42",
        "subject_id": "K-ternhaven-alder-scout-report",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ternhaven-alder-scout-report\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ternhaven-alder-scout-report\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[\"ternhaven-c5\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-43",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-pressure",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-44",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-pressure",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-pressure\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"name\":\"Opening allocation conflict\",\"state\":\"Hospitality policy enacted: first-night welcome honored under Del's custom, with reciprocal labor or respectful departure required thereafter, satisfying Ves and Ruan.\",\"progress\":null,\"maximum\":null,\"status\":\"COMPLETED\",\"last_updated_turn\":0,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-45",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-households\",\"name\":\"Ternhaven households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-households\",\"name\":\"Ternhaven households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"The landing community is united behind the two-stage hospitality rule; drying racks are filled on the upper ledge, and boats are safely handled.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-46",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-r1",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-r1\",\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-c1\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-c2\",\"basis\":\"Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.\",\"stance\":\"Disagrees over the present allocation, while accepting ordinary discussion.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"ternhaven-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-r1\",\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-c1\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-c2\",\"basis\":\"Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.\",\"stance\":\"In agreement following the enactment of the two-stage hospitality rule, balancing traditional welcome with resident store protection.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"ternhaven-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-47",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-r1",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-r1\",\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-c1\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-c2\",\"basis\":\"Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.\",\"stance\":\"In agreement following the enactment of the two-stage hospitality rule, balancing traditional welcome with resident store protection.\",\"intensity\":\"MATERIAL\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"ternhaven-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-r1\",\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-c1\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-c2\",\"basis\":\"Del recalls an old obligation to give seasonal visitors a dry first night and a meal. Ves asks whether an old welcome now means feeding whoever arrives all winter. No visitors are presently here and no arrival date is agreed. Ruan says limits spoken before arrival would be easier to honor than angry exclusions at the door.\",\"stance\":\"In agreement following the enactment of the two-stage hospitality rule, balancing traditional welcome with resident store protection.\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"obligation_ids\":[\"ternhaven-custom\"],\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-48",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-custom",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-custom\",\"party_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c2\",\"ternhaven-leader\"],\"terms\":\"The first guest meal is traditionally placed at the edge of the hearth where both host and visitor can see it. Older hosts disagree about what follows that first night. You hold the recognized leadership seat; an honest limit, a negotiated welcome or a quiet month of local work remains yours to choose.\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"witness_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c3\"],\"due_key\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-custom\",\"party_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c2\",\"ternhaven-leader\"],\"terms\":\"The first guest meal is placed at the edge of the hearth under ancient custom, granting a dry first night. By established village policy, guests staying beyond the first night must contribute reciprocal labor or receive one day's travel rations and depart in peace.\",\"status\":\"ACTIVE\",\"witness_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c3\"],\"due_key\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-49",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"statement\":\"Dry fish, roots and barley meal support several weeks of ordinary meals. Local catches and root beds can sustain the community if crews retain time for them. Fuel and mending twine are adequate for ordinary work but not limitless. Most roofs are sound; the landing hall has a damp corner. The fresh-water well is uphill of the beach. A few children have seasonal coughs, with no evidence of an outbreak. Hospitality uses food, dry space and labor that are already doing other work.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"PRIOR_STATE\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"statement\":\"The outer mooring has been inspected, freed from a rock snag, and re-rigged with sound cordage, while boats remain safely beached between runs. The upper drying ledge has new racks, the landing hall roof is sealed, and firewood is sheltered. Children with coughs are recovering, and household stores are well-managed.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-50",
        "subject_id": "fact-ternhaven-mooring-and-boats",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-ternhaven-mooring-and-boats\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"Both fishing boats were safely hauled onto the inner beach above high tide. During slack water, Kiri inspected the outer mooring and discovered the rope chafing against a submerged stone edge; the mooring was cleared and re-rigged with tested cordage, while inshore fishing continued safely.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-51",
        "subject_id": "K-ternhaven-mooring-and-boats",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ternhaven-mooring-and-boats\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ternhaven-mooring-and-boats\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-52",
        "subject_id": "fact-ternhaven-stores-and-hearth",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-ternhaven-stores-and-hearth\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"Work crews built drying racks on the upper ledge to dry split fish and roots off the ground. The landing hall roof seam was re-thatched and pitched, dry firewood was secured under lean-tos, and coughing children were nursed to recovery by the central hearth.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-53",
        "subject_id": "K-ternhaven-stores-and-hearth",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ternhaven-stores-and-hearth\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ternhaven-stores-and-hearth\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-54",
        "subject_id": "fact-ternhaven-hospitality-policy",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-ternhaven-hospitality-policy\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T001-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"The leader established an explicit village hospitality rule: visitors receive shelter and a hearth meal for their first night under custom; on the second day, guests must provide reciprocal labor or receive travel rations and depart peacefully.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T001-SC-55",
        "subject_id": "K-ternhaven-hospitality-policy",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ternhaven-hospitality-policy\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ternhaven-hospitality-policy\",\"learned_turn\":1,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T001-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T16:21:20.635Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-56",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"statement\":\"Two roofs have been re-thatched against rain. Garden roots are lifted and stored, while the autumn catch is secured through smoking, dry-salting with reserve cakes, and Sava's canopied racks. Fresh willow billets season in a drained, thatched hollow shelter, and the western pan bank has been reinforced.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"statement\":\"Mid-autumn rains have set in, but perimeter ditches divert runoff from brine pools. A low-heat test boil confirmed the reinforced pan bank holds without seepage. Split willow and alder billets cure under the open-sided shelter. Skiffs remain safely inshore, drying racks are sheltered near homes, and household hearths are shared in the evenings.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\",\"T002-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-57",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-pan-thermal-test",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-pan-thermal-test\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Nessa conducted a low-intensity test boil on an inland pan using salvaged drift and deadfall, while Fen monitored the western bank at low water. The clay reinforcement remained solid without cracking or seepage, confirming stability under low heat while core dry billets remain reserved for domestic warmth.\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-58",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-pan-thermal-test",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-pan-thermal-test\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-pan-thermal-test\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-59",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Evi and a companion reached the southern bank of the northern creek under cover of dunes. They observed an active boat yard on the opposite bank with timber sleds, an overhauled fishing craft, and permanent thatched dwellings, confirming a substantial neighboring settlement before withdrawing unseen.\",\"subject_id\":\"sound\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-60",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[\"saltmere-c5\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-61",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Fresh willow and alder billets were split into thin laths and stacked under the drained hollow shelter, accelerating seasoning. Inshore fishing continued in calm windows, drying racks were sheltered beside longhouses, and Daro's weekly inspection confirmed stored grain and cured fish remain free of mold.\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-62",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-63",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-households\",\"name\":\"Saltmere households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"saltmere-c1\",\"saltmere-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Early autumn fuel compromise is holding: Nessa accepted paused boiling while repairing the pan bank, and Orin secured dry billets for smoking alongside dry-salting.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-households\",\"name\":\"Saltmere households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"saltmere-c1\",\"saltmere-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Mid-autumn discipline holds: domestic heating billets are protected, communal hearths share warmth in the evenings, the pan bank is proven under low heat, and northern creek scouting confirms neighboring settlement.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\",\"T002-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-64",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"statement\":\"All four leaking houses have been re-thatched and lashed water-tight. The boat shed is safely shored with props, the unfinished hull is protected under pitched thatch, and the old fishing boat has been overhauled and caulked. Garden roots and beans are safely stored in straw pits, and two wooden drag-sleds are ready for timber hauling.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"statement\":\"The boat shed corner post is permanently underpinned on a raised stone plinth with sistered hardwood. Straight building timbers and winter fuel are sledded down and stacked on raised skids. Drainage swales protect dwellings, Pell's apprentices are spinning cordage and rendering pitch, and Ivo has confirmed upland herds to the southeast.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\",\"T002-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-65",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-shed-underpinning",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-shed-underpinning\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Mara and Ivo jacked the boat shed cross-beam, excavated to firm subsoil, and seated a broad flat river stone plinth. The rotted base of the corner post was cut away, charred against fungus, and fitted with a seasoned timber block sistered with hardwood splints and treenails, permanently securing the structure.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-66",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-shed-underpinning",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-shed-underpinning\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-shed-underpinning\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-67",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-sled-timber-and-fuel",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-sled-timber-and-fuel\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Work crews cleared and corduroyed the uphill track, using the two drag-sleds to haul straight trunk timbers, curved framing knees, and bundled deadwood before rains softened the trail. Logs were debarked and stacked on skids under thatched lean-tos to season for spring.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-68",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-sled-timber-and-fuel",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-sled-timber-and-fuel\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-sled-timber-and-fuel\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-69",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-fiber-and-swales",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-fiber-and-swales\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Tor organized swales along uphill walls to direct runoff toward the creek, inspected central hearth clearances, and culled storage pits. Pell led apprentices in retting and spinning nettle and bast fibers into cordage, while caulking pitch was rendered from resin, charcoal, and ash.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-70",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-fiber-and-swales",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-fiber-and-swales\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-fiber-and-swales\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-71",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-and-marker-patrols",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-ridge-and-marker-patrols\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Ivo scouted the western marker beach, finding the stake intact with faint shore tracks nearby. Later, from a concealed observation post on the southeast ridge, Ivo observed managed pack goat herds grazing across the distant upland shelf before executing a disciplined midday return.\",\"subject_id\":\"sound\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-72",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-ridge-and-marker-patrols",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-ridge-and-marker-patrols\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-ridge-and-marker-patrols\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[\"keelstrand-c4\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-73",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-households\",\"name\":\"Keelstrand households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"keelstrand-c1\",\"keelstrand-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"The keel agreement is holding: sleeping quarters are weatherproofed, fishing families received garden shares, and the yard focuses on old boat maintenance and sled hauling.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-households\",\"name\":\"Keelstrand households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"keelstrand-c1\",\"keelstrand-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"The yard is secure for winter: the shed post is permanently seated on stone, winter fuel and boat timbers are safely yarded, drainage swales prevent flooding, and ridge scouting confirms upland pastoralists.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\",\"T002-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-74",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"statement\":\"The barley harvest is successfully progressing, paced to dry spells and loft hurdle capacity. Cal's care rota protects household welfare, and the covered bowl is observed. The lower store bay is secured on raised dunnage, prime seed is separated on upper racks, and minor eave leaks have been patched.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"statement\":\"The barley harvest is complete and safely processed through the wool loft drying hurdles. Grain sacks rest dry on raised dunnage, seed grain is safeguarded under Beren, and winter fuel and straw bedding are stockpiled. Cal's adapted care rota and the covered bowl maintain household unity.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\",\"T002-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-75",
        "subject_id": "fact-high-barley-harvest-conclusion",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-high-barley-harvest-conclusion\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D03\"]},\"statement\":\"Hesta's teams completed final sickle sweeps of standing barley during dry spells. Beren managed a continuous rotation through the wool loft drying hurdles to threshing cloths, ensuring the entire crop was cured, winnowed, and bagged without rain spoilage, with straw bundled for goat fodder and bedding.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-76",
        "subject_id": "K-high-barley-harvest-conclusion",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-high-barley-harvest-conclusion\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-high-barley-harvest-conclusion\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-77",
        "subject_id": "fact-high-barley-store-and-fuel-security",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-high-barley-store-and-fuel-security\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D03\"]},\"statement\":\"Leth stacked all newly harvested grain sacks exclusively on raised dunnage away from outer walls, maintaining daily moisture checks. Beren secured prime seed grain in marked sacks on the driest upper racks, while goat-hauling teams stockpiled deadwood, brush, and peat under covered eaves.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-78",
        "subject_id": "K-high-barley-store-and-fuel-security",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-high-barley-store-and-fuel-security\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-high-barley-store-and-fuel-security\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-79",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-households\",\"name\":\"High Barley households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"high-barley-c1\",\"high-barley-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Caregivers and field workers are aligned: the covered bowl is honored nightly, dependents are cared for centrally, and goat hauling keeps sheaves moving into the loft.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-households\",\"name\":\"High Barley households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"high-barley-c1\",\"high-barley-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Harvest is gathered and secured on dunnage, prime seed is protected, fuel is stockpiled for winter, and the care rota and covered bowl continue to unite field workers and caregivers.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\",\"T002-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-80",
        "subject_id": "fact-ford-contact-high-barley-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-ford-contact-high-barley-view\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\"]},\"statement\":\"A four-person delegation from the coastal inlet, led by a woman named Del and the guide Seli, hailed Jun from the eastern bank of the stream ford. They approached openly and unarmored, presenting a woven gift basket of cured smoked fish and clean sea-salt. High Barley's leader and elders met them at the stream, exchanging peaceful greetings and learning that their village, Ternhaven, is a coastal fishing settlement seeking peaceful trade, while maintaining the stream barrier without admitting visitors up to the shelf.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-81",
        "subject_id": "K-ford-contact-high-barley-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ford-contact-high-barley-view\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ford-contact-high-barley-view\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-82",
        "subject_id": "fact-ford-contact-ternhaven-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-ford-contact-ternhaven-view\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\"]},\"statement\":\"Del and Seli led Ternhaven's four-person embassy along the alder path to the stream ford, observing a stone boundary cairn bearing a woven willow ring. They were hailed across the water by the ford watcher Jun and met by the upland leader and elders. Del presented the gift basket of smoked fish and sea-salt, explained Ternhaven's hospitality customs, and discussed future barter. The upland community, High Barley, received the gift courteously and affirmed peaceful relations across the stream, while keeping the meeting at the water boundary.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-83",
        "subject_id": "K-ford-contact-ternhaven-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ford-contact-ternhaven-view\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ford-contact-ternhaven-view\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c5\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-84",
        "subject_id": "rel-high-barley-ternhaven",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"basis\":\"Peaceful border encounter at the stream ford; Ternhaven presented a gift of salt and smoked fish, and High Barley acknowledged peaceful intentions while guarding the ford.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-high-barley-ternhaven\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\"]},\"source_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"stance\":\"Guarded respect and openness to future seasonal barter across the stream ford.\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-85",
        "subject_id": "rel-ternhaven-high-barley",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"basis\":\"Del and Seli met High Barley elders at the stream ford, presenting coastal gift provisions and receiving respectful acknowledgment and boundary recognition.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-ternhaven-high-barley\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\"]},\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"stance\":\"Courteous and hopeful for upland barter in grain, hides, or wool, respecting their boundary vigilance.\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-86",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"statement\":\"The outer mooring has been inspected, freed from a rock snag, and re-rigged with sound cordage, while boats remain safely beached between runs. The upper drying ledge has new racks, the landing hall roof is sealed, and firewood is sheltered. Children with coughs are recovering, and household stores are well-managed.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"statement\":\"Outdoor racks have been cleared and split fish and roots brought indoors. Curing continues over the landing hearth, meal sacks and root stores are raised on timber dunnage, and ditches protect the fresh-water wellhead. Boats fish only in the inner inlet and are beached during gales, while net mending and cordage twisting proceed inside.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\",\"T002-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-87",
        "subject_id": "fact-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"Ves and Wen cleared all dried fish and roots from the upper ledge racks into the landing hall ahead of driving rains. Sacks and root bundles were raised on timber dunnage away from walls, while shallow diversion ditches were dug uphill from the fresh-water wellhead to steer autumn mud and runoff away from the water supply.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-88",
        "subject_id": "K-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-89",
        "subject_id": "fact-ternhaven-marine-safety-and-craft",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-ternhaven-marine-safety-and-craft\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"Ruan confined fishing strictly to the sheltered inner inlet, hauling both craft above the storm line during rough swells. Kiri inspected the re-rigged mooring at slack tides, while net crews utilized stormy days inside the hall to twist fresh cordage from bast stores and repair damaged netting.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-90",
        "subject_id": "K-ternhaven-marine-safety-and-craft",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ternhaven-marine-safety-and-craft\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ternhaven-marine-safety-and-craft\",\"learned_turn\":2,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T002-SC-91",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-households\",\"name\":\"Ternhaven households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"The landing community is united behind the two-stage hospitality rule; drying racks are filled on the upper ledge, and boats are safely handled.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-households\",\"name\":\"Ternhaven households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Stores are brought indoors and raised on dunnage, the wellhead is protected from runoff, boats fish safely in the inner inlet, and the peaceful embassy to the upland ford returned successfully.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\",\"T002-D05\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T002-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:43:26.202Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-92",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"statement\":\"Mid-autumn rains have set in, but perimeter ditches divert runoff from brine pools. A low-heat test boil confirmed the reinforced pan bank holds without seepage. Split willow and alder billets cure under the open-sided shelter. Skiffs remain safely inshore, drying racks are sheltered near homes, and household hearths are shared in the evenings.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\",\"T002-D01\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"statement\":\"The western pan bank is insulated against frost heave beneath a heavy revetment of reed bundles and turf flaps, with brine barreled in covered clay vats and greased pans stored under cover. Fishing skiffs rest lashed hull-up on high timber rollers above storm surges, while low-tide mudflat foraging and Sava's eel traps yield fresh catch. Garden roots are bedded in dry sand clamps, stores sit raised on dunnage, and longhouse hearths are banked for shared evening warmth.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\",\"T002-D01\",\"T003-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-93",
        "subject_id": "saltmere-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-households\",\"name\":\"Saltmere households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"saltmere-c1\",\"saltmere-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Mid-autumn discipline holds: domestic heating billets are protected, communal hearths share warmth in the evenings, the pan bank is proven under low heat, and northern creek scouting confirms neighboring settlement.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\",\"T002-D01\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"saltmere-households\",\"name\":\"Saltmere households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"saltmere-c1\",\"saltmere-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Late-autumn winterization is complete: pan bank is insulated against frost heave, skiffs are secured on high rollers, root stores are bedded in sand clamps, and households gather around shared longhouse hearths.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D01\",\"T002-D01\",\"T003-D01\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-94",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Fen's crew dressed the western pan bank with a thick revetment of dry reed bundles and heavy turf flaps to shield the clay core from frost heave. Full boiling was suspended to conserve firewood, concentrated brine was barreled in covered clay vats, boiling pans were greased with fish oil, and a thatched timber canopy was erected over the springhead.\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-95",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-96",
        "subject_id": "fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D01\"]},\"statement\":\"Orin hauled both fishing skiffs well above storm-tide levels, lashing them hull-up on timber rollers beneath thatched mats. Foraging shifted to tidal shallows and Sava's woven wicker traps in the reed channels, harvesting cockles, mussels, and eels. Daro bedded roots in dry sand clamps, grain was raised on split-timber dunnage, and Sava's weavers shifted indoors to make draft screens and hampers.\",\"subject_id\":\"saltmere\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-97",
        "subject_id": "K-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D01"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-98",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"statement\":\"The boat shed corner post is permanently underpinned on a raised stone plinth with sistered hardwood. Straight building timbers and winter fuel are sledded down and stacked on raised skids. Drainage swales protect dwellings, Pell's apprentices are spinning cordage and rendering pitch, and Ivo has confirmed upland herds to the southeast.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\",\"T002-D02\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"statement\":\"All fishing craft are winched onto greased timber skids above storm tides on the gravel terrace. Dwellings are gale-proofed with lattice hold-down poles and doorway baffles, and runoff swales are cleared. The stabilized boat shed serves as an active indoor workshop where Mara shapes framing knees and oars for spring shipbuilding, Pell's apprentices repair nets and cordage, and stores are audited with a 20% winter reserve.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\",\"T002-D02\",\"T003-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-99",
        "subject_id": "keelstrand-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-households\",\"name\":\"Keelstrand households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"keelstrand-c1\",\"keelstrand-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"The yard is secure for winter: the shed post is permanently seated on stone, winter fuel and boat timbers are safely yarded, drainage swales prevent flooding, and ridge scouting confirms upland pastoralists.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\",\"T002-D02\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"keelstrand-households\",\"name\":\"Keelstrand households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"keelstrand-c1\",\"keelstrand-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Winter readiness is secured: boats are hauled on high skids, roofs are tied with lattice poles, the final timber sled run is safely stowed, and indoor boat joinery and cordage work continue in the shed.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D02\",\"T002-D02\",\"T003-D02\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-100",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Arel's crews maximized the late-autumn fish runs before winching the fishing boat and creek skiffs onto greased log skids on the gravel terrace above storm tides, lashing them securely. Inside the stabilized boat shed, Mara and carpenters spent foul-weather days carving oars, shaping thole pins, drilling trunnels, and pre-fitting framing knees for Arel's spring vessel, while Pell's apprentices repaired nets and conditioned cordage with tallow and pitch.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-101",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-102",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Tor's crews gale-proofed all dwellings with lattice hold-down poles pegged at eaves and chinked walls with moss and clay, hanging hide baffles over doorways. Mara and Ivo completed the final drag-sled run for firewood logs and birch bark before stowing the oiled sleds. Venn audited all winter reserves, establishing a transparent weekly household rationing schedule that preserves an untouched 20% emergency reserve, with seed beans sealed in rafter vessels.\",\"subject_id\":\"keelstrand\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-103",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-104",
        "subject_id": "fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D02\"]},\"statement\":\"Ivo conducted a final pre-frost scout to the southeast ridge before winter weather set in. From concealed observation, he noted that the distant upland pastoralists have moved their pack goat herds off the exposed slopes into sheltered stone pens near their settlement, confirming pastoral winterization, before returning safely.\",\"subject_id\":\"sound\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-105",
        "subject_id": "K-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[\"keelstrand-c4\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D02"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-106",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"statement\":\"The barley harvest is complete and safely processed through the wool loft drying hurdles. Grain sacks rest dry on raised dunnage, seed grain is safeguarded under Beren, and winter fuel and straw bedding are stockpiled. Cal's adapted care rota and the covered bowl maintain household unity.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\",\"T002-D03\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"statement\":\"Dwellings and storehouses are gale-proofed with stone-weighted thatch ropes and smoke baffles. Grain sacks rest secure on raised timber dunnage under Leth's weekly inspection, with prime seed locked by Beren. Pack goats are housed in sheltered dry-stone pens with winter fodder and salt licks, while fuel is stacked dry on log runners. Shared evening hearths and the faithful observance of the covered bowl maintain community warmth and unity.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\",\"T002-D03\",\"T003-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-107",
        "subject_id": "high-barley-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-households\",\"name\":\"High Barley households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"high-barley-c1\",\"high-barley-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Harvest is gathered and secured on dunnage, prime seed is protected, fuel is stockpiled for winter, and the care rota and covered bowl continue to unite field workers and caregivers.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\",\"T002-D03\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"high-barley-households\",\"name\":\"High Barley households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"high-barley-c1\",\"high-barley-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Upland winter defenses are in place: roofs are weighted with stones, grain stores and seed are rigorously inspected, pack goats are penned and fed, and communal hearths unite the households around the covered bowl.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D03\",\"T002-D03\",\"T003-D03\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-108",
        "subject_id": "fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D03\"]},\"statement\":\"Work parties retied thatch spars and weighted roof ropes with stones along the eaves of all dwellings and the storehouse, adjusting smoke-hole baffles against down-drafts. Winter fuel was stacked on log runners under eaves with drainage furrows. Leth maintained weekly dunnage inspections and rodent trapping, airing surface-chilled sacks on loft hurdles, while Beren kept prime seed grain locked under separate watch.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-109",
        "subject_id": "K-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-110",
        "subject_id": "fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D03\"]},\"statement\":\"Osa transitioned the pack goats from open slopes into sheltered dry-stone pens, rationing coarse straw, alder browse, and heather while overhauling pack harnesses and maintaining passive watch over the northwest trail. Cal coordinated shared evening hearths across households for fuel efficiency, where resting adults carded wool, spun yarn, and repaired tools while dependents were cared for, with the nightly covered bowl faithfully honored.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-111",
        "subject_id": "K-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D03"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-112",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-conditions",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"statement\":\"Outdoor racks have been cleared and split fish and roots brought indoors. Curing continues over the landing hearth, meal sacks and root stores are raised on timber dunnage, and ditches protect the fresh-water wellhead. Boats fish only in the inner inlet and are beached during gales, while net mending and cordage twisting proceed inside.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\",\"T002-D05\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-conditions\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"statement\":\"The landing hall is warm and breathable following Wen's installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath roof vents, with exterior walls banked with earth and doorways baffled. Fishing craft are hauled onto greased skids on the high inner beach, pitched, and lashed under thatch. Ves's storehouse audit establishes measured winter rationing with twice-weekly dunnage checks, wellhead ditches remain clear, and shore teams gather shellfish at spring tides.\",\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\",\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\",\"T002-D05\",\"T003-D04\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "PLAYERS",
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ]
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-113",
        "subject_id": "ternhaven-households",
        "prior_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-households\",\"name\":\"Ternhaven households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Stores are brought indoors and raised on dunnage, the wellhead is protected from runoff, boats fish safely in the inner inlet, and the peaceful embassy to the upland ford returned successfully.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\",\"T002-D05\"]}}",
        "new_value": "{\"id\":\"ternhaven-households\",\"name\":\"Ternhaven households\",\"scope\":\"LOCAL\",\"member_summary\":\"Resident households with differing labor, food and care interests; not a unanimous bloc.\",\"leader_ids\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c2\"],\"interests\":[\"Household safety\",\"Credible allocation of finite labor\"],\"controlled_resources\":[\"Household work time and customary shares\"],\"current_agenda\":\"Landing hall air is clear and warm with smoke louvers in place, boats are hauled above storm tides, winter stores are audited and safeguarded on dunnage, and the trade embassy returned safely from the stream ford.\",\"visibility\":{\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\",\"player_ids\":[]},\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"SALTWIND-INITIALIZATION\",\"T001-D05\",\"T002-D05\",\"T003-D04\"]}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-114",
        "subject_id": "fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D04\"]},\"statement\":\"Wen oversaw the construction and installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath landing hall roof vents, drawing heavy curing smoke cleanly outside while preserving interior heat. Work crews banked earth and dense reed screens against exterior walls and hung weighted door baffles, while three-foot gravel firebreaks and ready water buckets were established around all hearths, with fuel pre-dried indoors.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-115",
        "subject_id": "K-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-116",
        "subject_id": "fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"RESOURCE\",\"id\":\"fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D04\"]},\"statement\":\"Kiri and Ruan winched both fishing boats onto greased timber skids on the high inner beach well above storm tides, pitching seams with tallow and resin before lashing them beneath thatched hurdle covers. Ves completed an itemized inventory of winter provisions, establishing measured rationing and twice-weekly dunnage rotations, while low-tide foraging along the rocky shore yielded mussels, limpets, and kelp.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-117",
        "subject_id": "K-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D04"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-118",
        "subject_id": "fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"Evi, an elder, and a companion reached the southern bank of the northern creek and hailed the boatbuilders across the water in broad daylight with open hands. Keelstrand received the hail with prepared numbers and calm composure; the seasonal gift basket of pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed goods was transferred across the water. Both parties affirmed peaceful intentions and agreed that Marker Beach will serve as a neutral ground for seasonal barter, returning home without crossing the creek.\",\"subject_id\":\"sound\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player1\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player1"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-119",
        "subject_id": "K-creek-parley-saltmere-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view\",\"holder_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"id\":\"K-creek-parley-saltmere-view\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player1\",\"propagation_path\":[\"saltmere-c5\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-120",
        "subject_id": "fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"The rotational creek lookout spotted a three-person party approaching the south creek bank in daylight with open hands. Elders received their hail; the visitors identified themselves as peaceful coastal folk from Saltmere on the southern shallows, offering a seasonal gift basket of fine pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed craft. The gift was accepted across the water, peaceful relations were affirmed, and Marker Beach was agreed as a neutral seasonal meeting ground. Later, Ivo walked the marker beach and aligned three verification stones on a driftwood log.\",\"subject_id\":\"sound\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player2\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player2"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-121",
        "subject_id": "K-creek-parley-keelstrand-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view\",\"holder_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"id\":\"K-creek-parley-keelstrand-view\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player2\",\"propagation_path\":[\"keelstrand-c4\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-122",
        "subject_id": "rel-saltmere-keelstrand",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"basis\":\"Initial peaceful parley across the northern creek; Saltmere presented a seasonal gift of salt and smoked fish, Keelstrand acknowledged peaceful terms, and both agreed to Marker Beach as a neutral future barter site.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-saltmere-keelstrand\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D05\"]},\"source_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"stance\":\"Peaceful recognition and agreement to meet at Marker Beach for seasonal barter.\",\"target_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-123",
        "subject_id": "rel-keelstrand-saltmere",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"basis\":\"Saltmere delegation hailed across the northern creek in daylight, presenting a gift basket of salt and smoked fish; Keelstrand received the gift peacefully and agreed to Marker Beach as a neutral seasonal meeting ground.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-keelstrand-saltmere\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D05\"]},\"source_id\":\"keelstrand-leader\",\"stance\":\"Guarded respect and acceptance of Marker Beach as a neutral seasonal meeting ground.\",\"target_id\":\"saltmere-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-124",
        "subject_id": "fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"Del and Seli's four-person embassy met High Barley's leader and elders at the stream ford cairn. Jun's crew had erected a sheltered trade lean-to, guide rope, and water-level markers on the western bank. High Barley presented a return gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint. Across the stepping stones, a successful trial barter was conducted: High Barley traded surplus barley grain, thick wool blankets, and medicinal herbs in exchange for clean sea-salt and smoked fish. Both parties agreed to a monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days while keeping the stream boundary uncrossed.\",\"subject_id\":\"high-barley\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player3\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player3"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-125",
        "subject_id": "K-ford-barter-high-barley-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"OBSERVED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view\",\"holder_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ford-barter-high-barley-view\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player3\",\"propagation_path\":[],\"source_type\":\"DIRECT_OBSERVATION\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-126",
        "subject_id": "fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"domain\":\"WORLD\",\"id\":\"fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view\",\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T003-D05\"]},\"statement\":\"Del and Seli led Ternhaven's four-person delegation to the stream ford cairn, meeting High Barley's leader and elders. High Barley received them with a return hospitality gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint beside their new trade lean-to. Across the flat stepping stones, the parties conducted a successful trial barter, trading coastal sea-salt and smoked fish for upland barley grain, heavy woven wool blankets, and dried medicinal herbs. Both clans agreed to hold a regular monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days without uninvited entry into either village.\",\"subject_id\":\"ternhaven\",\"value\":null,\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[\"player4\"],\"scope\":\"PLAYERS\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [
            "player4"
          ],
          "scope": "PLAYERS"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-127",
        "subject_id": "K-ford-barter-ternhaven-view",
        "prior_value": "null",
        "new_value": "{\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"epistemic_status\":\"REPORTED\",\"fact_id\":\"fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view\",\"holder_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"id\":\"K-ford-barter-ternhaven-view\",\"learned_turn\":3,\"player_id\":\"player4\",\"propagation_path\":[\"ternhaven-c1\",\"ternhaven-c5\"],\"source_type\":\"PROPAGATED\"}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "scope": "GM_ONLY",
          "player_ids": []
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-128",
        "subject_id": "rel-high-barley-ternhaven",
        "prior_value": "{\"basis\":\"Peaceful border encounter at the stream ford; Ternhaven presented a gift of salt and smoked fish, and High Barley acknowledged peaceful intentions while guarding the ford.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-high-barley-ternhaven\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\"]},\"source_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"stance\":\"Guarded respect and openness to future seasonal barter across the stream ford.\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "new_value": "{\"basis\":\"Successful bilateral trial barter conducted across the stream ford stepping stones, exchanging surplus grain and wool for coastal salt and fish, establishing regular monthly low-water exchanges.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-high-barley-ternhaven\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\",\"T003-D05\"]},\"source_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"stance\":\"Guarded respect and openness to future seasonal barter across the stream ford.\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-129",
        "subject_id": "rel-high-barley-ternhaven",
        "prior_value": "{\"basis\":\"Successful bilateral trial barter conducted across the stream ford stepping stones, exchanging surplus grain and wool for coastal salt and fish, establishing regular monthly low-water exchanges.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-high-barley-ternhaven\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\",\"T003-D05\"]},\"source_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"stance\":\"Guarded respect and openness to future seasonal barter across the stream ford.\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "new_value": "{\"basis\":\"Successful bilateral trial barter conducted across the stream ford stepping stones, exchanging surplus grain and wool for coastal salt and fish, establishing regular monthly low-water exchanges.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-high-barley-ternhaven\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\",\"T003-D05\"]},\"source_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"stance\":\"Honorable trade partner; values sea-salt and fish in exchange for upland barley and wool across the guarded stream ford.\",\"target_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-130",
        "subject_id": "rel-ternhaven-high-barley",
        "prior_value": "{\"basis\":\"Del and Seli met High Barley elders at the stream ford, presenting coastal gift provisions and receiving respectful acknowledgment and boundary recognition.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-ternhaven-high-barley\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\"]},\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"stance\":\"Courteous and hopeful for upland barter in grain, hides, or wool, respecting their boundary vigilance.\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "new_value": "{\"basis\":\"Trial barter successfully conducted at the stream ford cairn, exchanging salt and fish for grain, wool blankets, and medicinal herbs with agreed monthly low-water barter terms.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-ternhaven-high-barley\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\",\"T003-D05\"]},\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"stance\":\"Courteous and hopeful for upland barter in grain, hides, or wool, respecting their boundary vigilance.\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-SC-131",
        "subject_id": "rel-ternhaven-high-barley",
        "prior_value": "{\"basis\":\"Trial barter successfully conducted at the stream ford cairn, exchanging salt and fish for grain, wool blankets, and medicinal herbs with agreed monthly low-water barter terms.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-ternhaven-high-barley\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\",\"T003-D05\"]},\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"stance\":\"Courteous and hopeful for upland barter in grain, hides, or wool, respecting their boundary vigilance.\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "new_value": "{\"basis\":\"Trial barter successfully conducted at the stream ford cairn, exchanging salt and fish for grain, wool blankets, and medicinal herbs with agreed monthly low-water barter terms.\",\"confidence\":\"CONFIRMED\",\"id\":\"rel-ternhaven-high-barley\",\"intensity\":\"LOW\",\"obligation_ids\":[],\"provenance\":{\"source_kind\":\"APPROVED_DECISION\",\"source_ids\":[\"T002-D04\",\"T003-D05\"]},\"source_id\":\"ternhaven-leader\",\"stance\":\"Respectful and valued trade partner; prized source of upland barley grain and warm wool blankets across the stream ford.\",\"target_id\":\"high-barley-leader\",\"visibility\":{\"player_ids\":[],\"scope\":\"GM_ONLY\"}}",
        "decision_ids": [
          "T003-D05"
        ],
        "applied_at": "2026-09-07T17:55:58.185Z",
        "visibility": {
          "player_ids": [],
          "scope": "GM_ONLY"
        }
      }
    ],
    "results": [
      {
        "id": "T003-R-player1",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "source_path": "turns/turn-003/results/player1/RESULTS.md",
        "visible_fact_ids": [
          "saltmere-scene",
          "saltmere-premise",
          "saltmere-calendar",
          "saltmere-map",
          "saltmere-conditions",
          "saltmere-contacts",
          "saltmere-neighbors",
          "fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization",
          "fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging",
          "fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view",
          "fact-saltmere-fuel-and-stores-discipline",
          "fact-saltmere-pan-thermal-test",
          "fact-saltmere-bank-reinforcement",
          "fact-saltmere-creek-reconnaissance"
        ],
        "authored": true,
        "approved": true
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-R-player2",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "source_path": "turns/turn-003/results/player2/RESULTS.md",
        "visible_fact_ids": [
          "keelstrand-scene",
          "keelstrand-premise",
          "keelstrand-calendar",
          "keelstrand-map",
          "keelstrand-conditions",
          "keelstrand-dispute",
          "keelstrand-contacts",
          "fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery",
          "fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores",
          "fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation",
          "fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view"
        ],
        "authored": true,
        "approved": true
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-R-player3",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "source_path": "turns/turn-003/results/player3/RESULTS.md",
        "visible_fact_ids": [
          "fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view",
          "fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores",
          "fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths",
          "high-barley-conditions",
          "high-barley-contacts",
          "high-barley-custom",
          "high-barley-map",
          "high-barley-calendar"
        ],
        "authored": true,
        "approved": true
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-R-player4",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "source_path": "turns/turn-003/results/player4/RESULTS.md",
        "visible_fact_ids": [
          "fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view",
          "fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety",
          "fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit",
          "ternhaven-conditions",
          "fact-ford-contact-ternhaven-view",
          "fact-ternhaven-stores-and-wellhead-defense",
          "fact-ternhaven-hospitality-policy",
          "ternhaven-calendar",
          "ternhaven-map",
          "ternhaven-contacts",
          "ternhaven-premise"
        ],
        "authored": true,
        "approved": true
      }
    ],
    "deliveries": [
      {
        "id": "T003-DEL-player1",
        "result_id": "T003-R-player1",
        "player_id": "player1",
        "source_path": "turns/turn-003/results/player1/RESULTS.md",
        "destination_path": "mailboxes/player1/inbox/turn-003-results/RESULTS.md",
        "source_checksum_sha256": "8e253c24ebfc2b8103202c6ab2f6b0c459a9b7408a76bd7577503a23af877994",
        "delivered_checksum_sha256": "8e253c24ebfc2b8103202c6ab2f6b0c459a9b7408a76bd7577503a23af877994",
        "approval_id": "T003-A-DELIVERY",
        "delivered_at": "2026-09-07T18:05:42.667Z",
        "verified": true
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-DEL-player2",
        "result_id": "T003-R-player2",
        "player_id": "player2",
        "source_path": "turns/turn-003/results/player2/RESULTS.md",
        "destination_path": "mailboxes/player2/inbox/turn-003-results/RESULTS.md",
        "source_checksum_sha256": "89559426151836eb62b0f2c598d884d970a79c17bdbf1983370fd51b30ee7dd0",
        "delivered_checksum_sha256": "89559426151836eb62b0f2c598d884d970a79c17bdbf1983370fd51b30ee7dd0",
        "approval_id": "T003-A-DELIVERY",
        "delivered_at": "2026-09-07T18:05:42.667Z",
        "verified": true
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-DEL-player3",
        "result_id": "T003-R-player3",
        "player_id": "player3",
        "source_path": "turns/turn-003/results/player3/RESULTS.md",
        "destination_path": "mailboxes/player3/inbox/turn-003-results/RESULTS.md",
        "source_checksum_sha256": "7a7880693c451061c8a8d57fe7ef166ec5017f246c62d43959a28fa2ccac9ac8",
        "delivered_checksum_sha256": "7a7880693c451061c8a8d57fe7ef166ec5017f246c62d43959a28fa2ccac9ac8",
        "approval_id": "T003-A-DELIVERY",
        "delivered_at": "2026-09-07T18:05:42.667Z",
        "verified": true
      },
      {
        "id": "T003-DEL-player4",
        "result_id": "T003-R-player4",
        "player_id": "player4",
        "source_path": "turns/turn-003/results/player4/RESULTS.md",
        "destination_path": "mailboxes/player4/inbox/turn-003-results/RESULTS.md",
        "source_checksum_sha256": "b6c79184dac5b9b79f57a5e3f04a8eea9fa5a8e79de1adf87d02ff4f5d9f0ab4",
        "delivered_checksum_sha256": "b6c79184dac5b9b79f57a5e3f04a8eea9fa5a8e79de1adf87d02ff4f5d9f0ab4",
        "approval_id": "T003-A-DELIVERY",
        "delivered_at": "2026-09-07T18:05:42.667Z",
        "verified": true
      }
    ]
  },
  "views": {
    "TURN_STATUS.md": "0abf168875935b35ecf36b7e4939a76800a74546a55486088ef39ea164c893fb",
    "INTAKE_MANIFEST.md": "1b520df198cd45944cc147b18879cc4359f6dcb3c888000007132523baa6066a",
    "ROSTER.md": "faad12c920cb9d1c4d461227578641c2bf6ac14b13ee9e603b0e53d2a038fd15",
    "WORLD_STATE.md": "7d7a74be246cf46f191e37082d5f2148328a916829a44e869a614730989103fa",
    "CAMPAIGN_TIMELINE.md": "6a65d0e30ed2b61c731318fb145999df6de5b07d53a3daf71a69fad6033c2017",
    "PRESSURES.md": "dbbd48af5ba4e15ff380ee14edb3d3e5c8a0d4d7690f537079a274ff4c89c96d",
    "RELATIONSHIPS_AND_OBLIGATIONS.md": "f76fa10eae393a6be5fe0f850a6c4ecb6019ba6e34dc1ae65fcfa0dc7039f77a",
    "DELIVERY_MANIFEST.md": "59f326cb0e78e8bd3db1738599e30de10502fc881e5662b7ff1bfb768e9fe73b",
    "DISCLOSURE_CHECK_SCAFFOLD.md": "d3ef8e513b022eb49d81a9c340e2ddfc8473e5ff5177b97af8619a5c6f37ef91",
    "CONSISTENCY_REPORT.md": "1058d54bb0b018ff45e2cd8638674b55795f985181c2bb9c2f9c10cca1e51061",
    "PLAYER_STATE_player1.md": "6b87b7bdfe32f77ed468d74a970f8e27c8932ae097a1136ce92a75f91e1179ff",
    "PLAYER_STATE_player2.md": "b73a7f03edda9175dfaaaad3b10a3a520e5f41a2c7ae529d532a51e83614136f",
    "PLAYER_STATE_player3.md": "e1000799325adcfd886d5c05c7bfa65ed4418ba4c361ef62aec0fdb2e70c003c",
    "PLAYER_STATE_player4.md": "e47f961d8e45f1bcf45f8022c815d34a3fe945cb2f141318a176ad0fdd93d6cd",
    "VIEW_MANIFEST.md": "23cf47c95df70dc45f8df543b1d9fc0bffad9c949a011fb74acddc59fb3a5739"
  },
  "players": [
    {
      "id": "player1",
      "absent": false,
      "memory": "Beliefs:\n- Winter is our most lethal adversary; frost-heave can destroy wet earthen banks, damp can rot our grain stores, and cold can burn through fuel reserves faster than green wood can cure.\n- The northern boat-builders represent an immense opportunity for metal-trade (axes, adzes, chisels) and sound craft, but first contact must be controlled, transparent, and conducted across the natural safety barrier of the creek.\n- Surrendering the initiative to be discovered accidentally in midwinter invites panic or predation; hailing them openly from across the creek with salt shows strength, courtesy, and commercial value.\n- Salt and preserved fish are our regional leverage; boatbuilders and fishers always need salt, while we desperately need metal tool replenishment and seasoned boat timber.\n\nIntentions:\n- Winterize Saltmere thoroughly: insulate Fen's repaired pan bank against frost heave with turf and reed cladding, oil the boiling pans against salt-air rust, and clamp root vegetables in dry sand.\n- Secure the two skiffs high above storm surges, caulking and covering them, shifting protein harvesting to sheltered tidal clamming and creel-trapping.\n- Maximize fuel efficiency via communal longhouse hearths, ash-banking, and aggressive post-gale driftwood sweeps along the sound tideline.\n- Conduct a cautious, open-handed first contact mission led by Evi at the northern creek, presenting salt cakes and proposing the Marker Beach as a neutral seasonal trading post.\n\nUnanswered Questions:\n- Who are the northern people, what language do they speak, and will they view our salt as an invitation to trade or a temptation to raid?\n- How severe is the coming winter—will the sound freeze over, and will our thin-split willow laths cure enough to supplement the dry billets before deep frost?\n- Will Fen's earthen bank hold against the expansion of winter ground frost?",
      "submission": "# Council of Late Autumn: The Hearth, the Frost, and the Northern Creek\n\nThe wind off the sound has turned bitter, carrying the smell of brine, sodden kelp, and approaching frost. Geese fly high and south over the marshes, their calls sharp against the darkening sky. Inside the longhouse, the village elders sit close to the embers. The roofs held tight against the mid-autumn rains, our roots and cured fish are dry in Daro’s store, and the western bank stood firm through the low-heat pan test. \n\nNow the true cold approaches. Winter is not an enemy that can be fought with spears or shouted down at the hearth; it must be met with tight walls, dry tinder, and cold patience.\n\nI place two smooth river stones on the council mat, and beside them, a clean, white cake of pressed salt.\n\n\"Saltmere has built its shelter and filled its bins,\" I tell them. \"Now we must lock down what we have, insulate what the frost would crack, and decide how we meet the neighbors Evi found across the northern creek.\"\n\n---\n\n### 1. Bank Insulation, Pan Winterization, and the Spring (Fen & Nessa)\n* **Protecting Against Frost Heave:** Water-saturated clay expands when frozen, which could tear apart the sod-and-clay repair on the western pan bank. Fen will lead a crew to dress the entire western bank with a thick, insulating revetment of dry reed bundles and heavy turf flaps. This protective blanket will shed rainwater and shield the core packed clay from deep freezing.\n* **Winterizing the Pans and Brine:** With freezing weather and late-autumn gales arriving, full boiling is suspended to preserve domestic fuel. Concentrated brine from the lower basins will be scooped and transferred into covered clay vats and barrels set in the storehouse lee. The boiling pans will be scrubbed free of scale, thoroughly dried, and greased with rendered fish oil to prevent corrosion and flaking during the damp winter months.\n* **Springhead Maintenance:** Fen will clear the runoff gullies above the fresh spring to prevent storm silt from contaminating our drinking water. A sturdy pitched timber canopy thatched with reed will be erected over the springhead to keep out frost, fallen leaves, and drifting snow.\n\n### 2. Craft, Stores, and Fleet Preservation (Orin, Sava, Daro)\n* **Lashing Down the Skiffs:** Late-autumn squalls and winter storm surges can batter wooden craft to splinters. Orin’s two fishing skiffs will be hauled well above the highest storm-tide mark, placed hull-up on raised timber rollers, checked and recaulked with resin and grease, and lashed down beneath double-layered thatched mats. \n* **Tidal Shallows Foraging:** Deep-water net fishing is concluded until spring. Orin’s crew will focus entirely on the sheltered shallows and mudflats during low-tide windows: gathering cockles, clams, and mussels, and placing Sava’s woven wicker traps in the southern reed channels to harvest eels and flatfish.\n* **Root Clamps and Storehouse Defense:** Daro will bed the lifted parsnips and turnips into bins of dry sand brought up from the dunes to prevent shriveling and frost-rot. Smoked fish, salted fillets, and grain sacks will be raised onto split timber racks off the earthen floor. Bi-weekly inspections will continue; any spoiled root or damp grain will be culled immediately.\n* **Winter Weaving:** Sava’s basketmakers will shift indoors to produce woven draft-screens for longhouse entrances, sleeping mats, and pack hampers for winter portage.\n\n### 3. Fuel Scavenging and Hearth Consolidation\n* **Post-Storm Shorecombing:** Late-autumn gales strip deadwood from coastal bluffs and wash seasoned driftwood ashore. After every blow, organized teams will walk the sound shore within our territory, hauling dry drift and wreckage above the high-water mark to cut and split for domestic burning.\n* **Seasoning Checks:** Under the hollow shelter, the thin-split willow and alder laths will be turned to expose fresh surfaces to the whistling autumn breeze. A small bundle of the oldest split laths will be brought indoors to test whether they can now burn cleanly when mixed with our core dry billets.\n* **Domestic Consolidation:** Individual household hearths will be banked. The settlement will gather each evening in the two primary longhouses, concentrating heat, sharing chores, and conserving precious wood. Hearth masters will strictly practice ash-banking overnight to preserve live coals without consuming fresh logs.\n\n---\n\n### 4. The Northern Embassy: First Contact at the Creek (Evi)\nEvi’s scouting confirmed a permanent village and active boat yard across the northern creek. They possess metal tools, timber craft, and permanent homes. Remaining hidden is no longer a viable long-term strategy; once sound waters settle or winter hunting parties wander south, an accidental encounter in the brush breeds fear and suspicion. We will initiate contact on our own terms, with dignity and caution.\n\n* **The Delegation:** Evi will lead a three-person party northward: Evi (who knows the shingle track and tide retreat), a respected elder who speaks clearly and calmly, and one steady companion. They will carry no drawn weapons—only their standard travel cloaks, walking staves, and small utility knives sheathed out of sight.\n* **The Token of Saltmere:** In a finely woven basket made by Sava, the party will carry:\n  1. Two prime, white cakes of our best pressed salt.\n  2. A neat package of dried, wood-smoked fish.\n  3. Clean woven reed goods.\n  *This communicates immediately that we are settled producers of preserved food and salt—valuable trade partners, not destitute raiders.*\n* **Protocol of Contact:**\n  - **The Water Boundary:** The party will travel along the shingle path past the marker beach and halt on the **southern bank of the creek**, in plain view of the boat yard across the water. They will **not** attempt to wade or cross the creek uninvited.\n  - **The Open Hail:** In broad daylight, during a clear morning, they will hail across the creek with open hands, calling a peaceful greeting to the boatbuilders and showing the basket.\n  - **The Message:** When answered, the elder will state: *“We come in peace from Saltmere, the village on the shallows south. We bring a seasonal gift of pure salt and cured fish for your hearths before the winter frost. We know the sea is hard and timber is dear; we come to see our neighbors and speak of trade.”*\n  - **The Meeting Ground:** If they respond peacefully and send a boat across, our people will receive them at the south water’s edge. If they invite discussion, our party will propose that the **Marker Beach**—situated neutrally between our two settlements—become a recognized meeting ground for seasonal barter when spring opens, or for limited exchange before winter locks the shore.\n  - **Strict Safety Rules:**\n    - If the northerners show bows, arm themselves aggressively, or shout threats, Evi’s team is under absolute orders not to advance or argue. They will lay the basket on the southern shingle bank as a token of goodwill, retreat immediately into the dunes, and return swiftly along the shingle path.\n    - Under no circumstances will our party lead strangers back to Saltmere this turn, nor enter any enclosed dwelling across the creek.\n\n---\n\nI look around the circle of elders. Outside, the wind rattles the dry reeds against the longhouse walls, but the fire is warm and the faces are resolute.\n\n\"We do not grovel, and we do not hide like mice in the marsh,\" I say quietly. \"We hold the salt that cures the winter meat, and our houses are tight against the gale. Let them see that Saltmere is steady, peaceful, and ready to deal as an equal. Now let us bank the fires and ready our people.\"",
      "report": "Late autumn has brought biting winds and approaching frost across the sound, but Saltmere’s preparations have secured the settlement’s core defenses and opened peaceful contact with your northern neighbors.\n\n### Pan Bank Protection and Brine Winterization\n\nFen’s crew completed the fortification of the western pan bank before the onset of hard ground frost. The packed clay core and lower bank were covered under a thick revetment of dry reed bundles and heavy turf flaps, insulating the structure against the expansion of frost heave and shedding surface water. In accordance with your decision to conserve firewood for domestic survival, full brine boiling has been formally suspended. \n\nNessa oversaw the transfer of concentrated brine from the lower pools into covered clay vats and barrels set in the storehouse shelter. The boiling pans were cleaned of scale, greased with fish oil to ward off rust in the salt air, and stored safely under cover. Over the fresh springhead, a thatched timber canopy was raised, preventing fallen leaves, silt, and early frost from fouling the village drinking supply.\n\n### Craft, Shallows Foraging, and Storehouse Discipline\n\nOn the beach, Orin’s crew pulled both shallow skiffs high above the line of autumn storm surges. The hulls were turned, inspected, and lashed hull-up onto raised timber rollers beneath thatched protective mats, taking them out of the water until spring. Deep-water netting has ceased; village fishing now relies on low-tide foraging across the mudflats for cockles and mussels, alongside Sava’s woven wicker traps anchored in the southern reed channels, which continue to yield eels and flatfish.\n\nIn the storehouses, Daro bedded the harvested roots into clamps of dry dune sand to prevent shriveling and cold-rot, while sacks of grain were elevated onto split-timber dunnage to keep them away from rising floor moisture. Indoors, Sava’s weavers have shifted to crafting reed draft-screens for longhouse doorways and hampers for transport. Each evening, families consolidate into the longhouses, banking the hearths to share warmth and stretch dry fuel.\n\n### First Contact at the Northern Creek\n\nEvi, accompanied by a village elder and a companion, carried out the embassy along the shingle track to the northern creek. Halting on the southern bank in clear daylight with open hands, they hailed the boatbuilders on the far shore and presented the woven gift basket containing pressed salt cakes, wood-smoked fish, and reed work.\n\nThe settlement across the creek—identified as Keelstrand—responded with calm composure and prepared numbers, showing no surprise or immediate hostility. The gift basket was transferred across the water. Both parties openly affirmed peaceful intentions and reached a clear initial understanding: Marker Beach, lying between the two territories, will serve as neutral ground for seasonal barter. Neither party crossed the creek or entered the other's settlement, and Evi’s party returned safely to Saltmere before dusk.\n\n### Visible Costs and Immediate Pressures\n\nAs winter approaches, the village faces several immediate realities:\n- **Halted Salt Boiling:** Suspending the pans preserves firewood for longhouse hearths, but locks Saltmere's salt reserves at current levels. No fresh salt can be boiled until winter breaks and fuel permits.\n- **Subsistence Shift:** Securing the skiffs protects fragile craft from gale damage, but restricts fresh catches strictly to tidal flats and reed traps. As temperatures fall, mudflat foraging will grow increasingly grueling and frost may hamper the reed shallows, increasing dependence on Daro's stored grain, roots, and cured fish.\n- **Relations with Keelstrand:** While peaceful intent and a designated barter site at Marker Beach have been agreed upon, Keelstrand demonstrated organized manpower and vigilance. What specific goods they will bring to trade, what terms they will expect, and how barter will be conducted once travel becomes restricted by frost remain open questions for the council."
    },
    {
      "id": "player2",
      "absent": false,
      "memory": "Beliefs:\n- Late-autumn winds and oncoming winter frost require an orderly transition from outdoor timber hauling to indoor workshops, shelter insulation, and harbor storm defense.\n- Arel and the fishing households carried the community through autumn; capitalizing on the late-autumn fish runs while securing boats and gear against storm tides fulfills their trust.\n- The upland pack-goat herders to the southeast and the travelers along the western coast are real factors; winter weather will likely determine whether they are seasonal migrants or permanent neighbors.\n- Maintaining disciplined lookouts and fair, transparent rationing will prevent both external surprise and internal friction through the dark, cold months.\n\nIntentions:\n- Maximize the late-autumn fish run and preserve surplus via smoking and salting, while establishing a high-water haul-out station to protect our boats from gales and storm surges.\n- Conclude outdoor felling and sled hauling before ground freezes; winterize timber stacks, the paused hull, and dwelling roofs with cross-poles and bast lashings.\n- Seal dwellings against drafts with moss, daub, and door baffles; clear drainage swales; inspect hearths and flues for winter fire safety.\n- Shift labor into the stabilized boat shed for pre-fabricating oars, trunnels, nets, cordage, and winter gear under Mara, Pell, and Venn.\n- Conduct a final pre-frost scout to the southeast ridge to observe pastoralist winter movements, inspect the western beach stake, and set up a quiet settlement lookout.\n- Audit all food stores and institute a structured household rationing plan with a protected spring seed cache.\n\nUnanswered Questions:\n- Will the upland pastoralists migrate down toward Keelstrand's creek valley as frost hits the ridge, or do they retreat to lower inland basins?\n- Who made the faint tracks near the western marker beach, and does coastal travel cease entirely during the winter gales?\n- Will our smoked/salted fish and root/bean caches comfortably sustain all 149 people through late winter without depleting our emergency buffer?",
      "submission": "### 1. The Late-Autumn Runs & Harbor Storm Readiness\nThe late-autumn fish runs are our final opportunity to build substantial caloric reserves before frost and winter gales shut down coastal gathering. We will balance intense harvesting with strict precautions against rising coastal storms.\n* **Harvesting the Run:** Arel’s crews will take the overhauled fishing boat and creek skiffs into the creek mouth and sheltered sound whenever sea and wind allow. We will prioritize netting schooling fish. All available smoking racks and salting troughs will run continuously under shelter; every fish beyond daily sustenance will be hard-smoked or packed into salt barrels to guarantee winter self-sufficiency.\n* **Harbor Safety & Storm Haul-Out:** Late-autumn brings sudden gales and violent storm tides. Mara and Arel will establish a prepared haul-out station on the gravel terrace above the highest spring-tide line, laying greased log skids and driving deep anchor stakes. At the first warning of heavy swell or onshore gale, the fishing boat and creek craft will be winched completely clear of the surf and lashed down, eliminating the risk of hull damage from pounding driftwood or tidal surges.\n\n---\n\n### 2. Final Yard Operations & Winterizing Timber\nWith shortening days and oncoming frost, outdoor timber felling and sled hauling must conclude before mud freezes into jagged ruts or snow covers the rocky track.\n* **Final Sled Run:** Before the ground freezes solid, Mara and Ivo will lead one final, concentrated haul using both drag-sleds to bring down seasoned firewood logs, birch bark rolls (for waterproofing and quick kindling), and any remaining felled framing knees.\n* **Securing the Yard & Sleds:** Both drag-sleds will be cleaned, oiled with rendered fish grease to prevent wood checking, and stowed under cover in the boat shed. The curing timber stacks on skids will be given a final inspection: bark fully stripped, spacing battens straight to promote air circulation, and the thatched lean-to roofs reinforced with heavy weighting logs against wind shear.\n* **Hull Protection:** Mara and Tor will inspect the thatched cradle over the paused hull. Any loose thatch mats will be retightened using Pell’s apprentice-spun bast cordage and secured with transverse binding poles.\n\n---\n\n### 3. Hearth, Shelter & Cold-Weather Defense\nLiving quarters must withstand freezing winds, long nights, and heavy snow loads.\n* **Gale-Proofing Roofs:** Tor’s repair crews will secure all dwelling roofs against seasonal gales by lashing lattice hold-down poles across the thatch, pegged at the eaves and tied with heavy-duty split-root and bast lines.\n* **Draft Insulation & Eaves:** Households will chink wall seams and foundation gaps with dry moss, wood shavings, and clay daub. Heavy woven rush mats and cured hides will be hung over outer doorways to create airlock baffles against biting winds.\n* **Drainage Maintenance:** The runoff swales dug last month will be cleared of fallen leaves and forest debris so freeze-thaw slush drains freely into the creek rather than pooling around timber sills.\n* **Fuel Caches & Fire Safety:** Firewood brought down from the hill and yard offcuts will be stacked under leeward eaves, ensuring dry kindling and split cordwood are within arm's reach of each hearth. Tor will continue bi-weekly inspections of central hearths, stone surrounds, and smoke-hole flues to ensure intense winter firing does not ignite soot or roof poles.\n\n---\n\n### 4. Indoor Winter Workshops: Boatyard & Crafts\nCold, wet days will not be idle. With the boat shed permanently stabilized on its stone plinth and draft-proofed, it serves as the central dry workshop.\n* **Mara’s Joinery & Pre-Fabrication:** Mara and the woodworkers will use the indoor winter period to carve spare oars, shape thole pins, shape and drill trunnels (hardwood treenails), and pre-fit internal framing knees and ribs for Arel’s vessel. When spring thaw arrives, hull construction can resume at high speed without waiting on preparatory woodwork. All edged iron tools will be carefully honed, coated with rendered tallow, and stored dry.\n* **Pell’s Fiber Works & Gear Repair:** Pell and his apprentices will focus on repairing torn fishing nets, braiding heavy cordage from retted wild bast fibers, and conditioning stored cordage with tallow and pine-pitch mixtures to prevent dry rot. They will also construct lightweight snowshoe frames and sled-binding lashings in preparation for heavy snowfall.\n* **Clothing & Boot Husbandry:** Venn will oversee leather and wool maintenance across the households. Footwear will be thoroughly greased with rendered fat to keep feet dry in slush, and winter cloaks and blankets mended.\n\n---\n\n### 5. Reconnaissance, Border Awareness & Diplomacy\nWith neighbors confirmed inland and activity along the western shore, we will maintain clear situational awareness as winter sets in without overextending personnel or provoking conflict.\n* **The Southeast Ridge & Upland Pastoralists:**\n  * Ivo and a small, quiet scouting pair will make a final pre-frost ascent to the first ridge before snow blocks the high pack trail.\n  * *Observations:* Monitor the pack-goat herds in the upland basin. Are they driving the animals down to lower winter valleys, moving south toward sheltered scrub, or erecting winter camps on the plateau? Are smoke plumes visible from fixed dwellings?\n  * *Discipline & Contact:* Observe from concealment. If a lone herder or small wandering party is encountered on our side of the ridge, maintain a calm, friendly, but composed stance: identify as Keelstrand coastal folk, offer hot tea or smoked fish if they are stranded by weather, exchange polite observations about trails and oncoming frost, but do not invite them down to inspect the settlement or disclose our food caches and population.\n* **The Western Marker Beach:**\n  * Ivo will walk the western shore path once mid-month during a calm morning tide.\n  * *Investigation:* Examine the stake and gravel for new footprint patterns or boat haul marks. Place an unobtrusive natural marker (three small stones aligned on a specific driftwood log) to easily verify whether someone passes along the beach.\n* **Local Lookout:** Establish a simple, rotational daytime watch at the creek entrance and on the timbered bluff overlooking the sound. If strangers approach by land or sea, Keelstrand will have ample advance notice to secure children, gather working parties, and receive visitors with dignity and prepared numbers.\n\n---\n\n### 6. Stores, Rationing & Winter Governance\n* **Storehouse Audit:** Venn and Tor will conduct a meticulous census of all winter reserves: smoked fish racks, salted barrels, straw-lined root cellars, dried bean sacks, and rendered fat tubs. We will establish a transparent, weekly household ration plan designed to sustain our 149 people through early spring, holding back an untouched 20% emergency reserve against late freezes.\n* **Seed Protection:** Seed beans and choice root stock for spring planting will be sealed in dry clay vessels, lined with wood ash to deter pests, and suspended from rafters away from damp and rodents.\n* **Community Life & The Keel Oath:** As darkness lengthens, village cohesion is vital. We will hold regular communal meals in the boat shed around raised braziers, sharing the fish harvest, hearing Ivo’s trail reports, and keeping spirits high. Standing beside the sheltered hull, we will remind Arel, Mara, and all households that our unity kept everyone dry and fed, and that the coming spring thaw will see the new ship finished and launched into the sound.",
      "report": "# Turn Report: Keelstrand — Late Autumn, Year 1\n\n### The Late-Autumn Catch, Craft Haul-Out, and Boat Shed Workshop\nArel’s fishing crews took advantage of every fair window during the late-autumn fish runs, bringing in hauls to be processed along the shore before rising swells and seasonal gales shut down coastal operations. Once the runs tapered and sea conditions worsened, all craft—the fishing boat and creek skiffs—were winched out of the water onto greased timber skids laid out on the gravel terrace well above the highest storm-tide marks, where they were securely lashed down against gale winds.\n\nWith outdoor boatwork suspended, activity shifted into the stabilized boat shed, which functioned as an active indoor workshop during foul-weather days. Mara and her woodworkers carved spare oars, shaped thole pins, bored trunnels, and pre-fitted internal framing knees and ribs for Arel’s spring vessel, ensuring joinery will be ready when construction resumes. Meanwhile, Pell’s apprentices repaired torn nets and conditioned stores of cordage with tallow and pitch to prevent winter rot.\n\n### Shelter Hardening, Yard Winterization, and Stores Audit\nTor’s crews completed the gale-proofing of all dwellings before freezing weather arrived. Roof thatch was secured against wind shear with crisscrossing lattice hold-down poles pegged firmly at the eaves, walls were chinked with dry moss and clay daub to seal drafts, and heavy hide baffles were hung across outer doorways to buffer interior rooms against biting winds. Uphill runoff swales were cleared of debris to ensure slush drains freely into the creek rather than pooling against timber foundations.\n\nMara and Ivo carried out a final timber haul with both drag-sleds, bringing down firewood logs and rolls of birch bark before frozen ruts could damage the trail. The sleds were subsequently cleaned, oiled with grease to prevent checking, and stowed under cover. Venn completed a thorough census of all settlement provisions, establishing a transparent weekly household rationing schedule designed to sustain the 149 residents through the cold months while preserving an untouched 20% emergency reserve. Seed beans and root stock were sealed in rafter vessels to safeguard next year’s planting against moisture and pests.\n\n### First Contact with Saltmere and the Marker Beach Agreement\nThe settlement’s rotational watch at the creek entrance yielded significant new information. Lookouts hailed a three-person party that approached the southern creek bank in daylight with open hands. Settlement elders met their call across the water. The visitors introduced themselves as peaceful coastal people hailing from Saltmere on the southern shallows, offering a goodwill gift basket containing fine pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed craft.\n\nThe gift was accepted across the creek, and peaceful intentions were confirmed by both parties. By mutual agreement, the western Marker Beach was designated as a neutral seasonal meeting ground for future interaction. Following the encounter, Ivo walked the western shore trail to the beach, confirming the route and aligning three small verification stones on a driftwood log to provide a simple physical sign if travelers pass the marker.\n\n### Southeast Ridge Reconnaissance\nBefore frost and oncoming snow could seal the high passes, Ivo made a final pre-frost reconnaissance patrol up the southeast pack trail to the first ridgeline. Remaining concealed at the crest, he observed that the upland pastoralists in the basin have moved their managed pack goat herds off the exposed upland grazing slopes and penned them into sheltered stone enclosures adjoining their settlement. Having confirmed that the inland pastoralists have entered their own winterized posture, Ivo executed a disciplined, timely withdrawal and returned safely before nightfall.\n\n### Immediate Pressures and Open Decisions\n* **Onset of Winter:** Shorter daylight hours, freezing temperatures, frost, and inevitable snow will soon curtail outdoor work and trail travel. Dwellings and fuel caches are prepared, but living through prolonged indoor confinement will test community patience.\n* **Winter Rations & Preservation:** While Venn’s rationing schedule protects a 20% emergency reserve, household consumption and storage pits must be monitored continually against damp, spoilage, or premature depletion before spring thaw.\n* **The Saltmere Relationship:** The peaceful greeting across the creek and the gift of salt and reed craft open possibilities for coastal trade. However, formal terms of exchange and safe protocols at Marker Beach will need to be determined once travel resumes.\n* **Upland Pastoralists:** Ivo’s scouting confirms fixed stone dwellings and stone pens across the ridge, but winter conditions will likely restrict contact across the high pass until spring.\n* **Spring Shipbuilding Preparations:** With oars, thole pins, trunnels, and framing knees shaped and staged indoors, Mara and Arel have kept faith regarding the promised vessel. When the ice and winter gales clear, assembling the hull will be the yard’s foremost priority."
    },
    {
      "id": "player3",
      "absent": false,
      "memory": "Beliefs:\n- With our harvest safely gathered and fuel banked, High Barley is well-positioned for winter, but late-autumn gales and freezing rains require vigilant structural and herd protection.\n- Ternhaven represents a tremendous diplomatic and economic opportunity: coastal salt and smoked fish provide essential minerals, protein, and flavor that complement our grain and bean stores.\n- Trade should be conducted on neutral, secure terms at the ford/lower meadow; maintaining the stream boundary protects our community's privacy and grain security until deep mutual trust is forged over time.\n- Preserving seed grain remains non-negotiable; only excess consumption grain and craft goods (wool, woven textiles) should enter trade.\n- Social cohesion, hearth-sharing, and Cal's care rota with the nightly covered bowl remain vital as daylight shrinks and people spend more time indoors.\n\nIntentions:\n- Conduct an initial, measured trade parley with Del at the stream ford, offering a modest quantity of cured barley, wool yarn/blankets, and upland herbs in exchange for sea-salt and smoked fish.\n- Install a secure guide rope and stone markers at the ford to keep the crossing manageable and safe during autumn rain surges.\n- Winterize all dwellings and outbuildings against late-autumn gales: batten thatch, lash roof spars, ensure fuel stacks are elevated and protected from wind-driven moisture.\n- Move the goat herd into winter penning; feed straw, cut browse, and provide salt lick if acquired from Ternhaven.\n- Maintain passive surveillance of the northwest ridge pack trail without launching risky late-season expeditions.\n- Reinforce communal hearths and winter indoor crafts (spinning, weaving, mending) under Cal's balanced rota.\n\nUnanswered Questions:\n- What is the size, political structure, and seasonal need of Ternhaven, and will their fishermen seek regular seasonal trade?\n- How high does the stream rise during peak late-autumn gales, and will it cut off contact entirely during winter?\n- Who uses the northwest ridge pack trail, and will cold weather suppress or increase travel across that pass?",
      "submission": "# High Barley — Turn 003 (Late Autumn, Year 1) Plan\n\n### 1. Trade & Diplomacy with Ternhaven (Del & Jun)\nThe peaceful arrival of Del, Seli, and their companions opens a vital opportunity to diversify our winter stores. High Barley will meet this overture with warmth, fair dealing, and prudent boundaries:\n- **Neutral Trade Station at the Ford:** We will not bring visitors up the ridge path into the village or storehouses. Instead, Jun and our builders will establish a modest, sheltered trading post on our bank of the stream ford—a simple dry-stone windbreak and timber-framed lean-to. This allows negotiations and exchanges to happen comfortably under cover while preserving the privacy and security of our upland settlement.\n- **Crossing Infrastructure & Safety:** As seasonal rains swell the stream, Jun will string a stout, tensioned guide rope across the ford between anchored posts and place heavy, flat stepping stones where possible. Simple water-level markers will clearly signal safe versus hazardous crossing conditions.\n- **Initial Trade Offering:** \n  - *What we offer:* A carefully measured allotment of cured barley (strictly drawn from general consumption stocks, never seed), warm spun wool yarn, thick woven wool blankets or cloaks (which coastal fishermen exposed to freezing spray and winter gales will prize highly), and dried upland medicinal herbs and roots.\n  - *What we seek:* Clean sea-salt (essential for preserving food, seasoning winter porridge, and supplementing livestock health) and smoked/cured marine fish to enrich our winter protein and fat supplies.\n- **Establishing Relations & Parley Protocol:** I will personally meet Del and Seli at the ford post alongside Jun and two respected village elders. We will return Del’s generous gift with an equal hospitality gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried upland mint. We will propose regular, scheduled exchanges at the ford on low-water days, discuss seasonal needs for both communities, and inquire about conditions along the sound, travel routes, and broader regional news.\n\n### 2. Gale-Proofing & Structural Winterization (Leth, Beren, & Village)\nWith late-autumn winds rising and daylight contracting, we must harden our buildings against wind-driven rain, drafts, and early frost:\n- **Thatch & Roof Reinforcement:** Work parties will systematically inspect every dwelling, the storehouse, and outbuildings. Thatch spars will be retied, roof ropes weighted with stones along eaves to resist gale gusts, and smoke-hole baffles adjusted to prevent down-drafts while allowing proper hearth ventilation.\n- **Fuel Consolidation & Shielding:** Peat blocks, deadwood, and split dry timber gathered last month will be consolidated under covered eaves, lean-tos, and porch overhangs. We will ensure all woodpiles rest on dry log runners rather than bare earth, and dig shallow diversion furrows around wood storage areas to carry cold ground runoff away from fuel stacks.\n- **Storehouse Hygiene & Vermin Defense:** Leth will maintain rigorous weekly inspections of the lower bay and upper racks. Grain sacks will remain on raised timber dunnage away from exterior stone walls. Leth and Beren will deploy traps and secure timber floorboards against rodents seeking autumn shelter. Grain sacks will be turned and checked for cool condensation; any bag showing surface chill will be aired immediately on the ventilated loft hurdles. Beren will keep prime seed stocks locked and sealed under separate watch.\n\n### 3. Herd Management & Northwest Watch (Osa)\nAs upland grazing withers and frost hardens the turf:\n- **Winter Penning & Fodder Allocation:** Osa will transition the pack goats from open slope grazing to sheltered dry-stone pens and lean-tos near the settlement. Fodder will be rationed methodically: coarse barley straw, dried leafy alder browse, and reserved heather. If sea-salt is secured from Ternhaven, Osa will establish a salt lick in the pens to maintain flock vigor and digestion through the cold.\n- **Pack Gear Overhaul:** Osa and the herd hands will spend rainy days cleaning, greasing, and repairing leather harnesses, hauling frames, and pack baskets so our transport gear is in prime order before winter settles.\n- **Northwest Trail Monitoring:** While conducting short grazing rounds along the sheltered upper shelf on clear mornings, Osa will maintain a vigilant, passive watch over the northwest ridge trail. We will look for fresh foot or pack prints, smoke beyond the ridge, or unusual movements. We will **not** dispatch scouts over the ridge into unmapped territory during late-autumn gales, prioritizing safety and home security.\n\n### 4. Domestic Life, Care Rota, and Indoor Labor (Cal)\nAs cold weather drives activity indoors, village unity depends on shared warmth and purposeful work:\n- **Communal Hearths & Fuel Conservation:** To maximize heat and minimize fuel consumption, Cal will coordinate shared evening hearths among neighboring households. Families will gather in larger, well-insulated homes for cooking, storytelling, and evening company rather than burning separate fires in every small cottage.\n- **Integrated Indoor Labor:** Cal’s care rota will coordinate light, warm domestic industry around communal fires. While children and elders are sheltered and tended, resting adults will engage in indoor crafts: carding and spinning sheep/goat wool, weaving coarse cloth, mending clothing and blankets, carving wooden spoons and bowls, and repairing field tools for the coming year.\n- **The Covered Bowl:** We will maintain the solemn tradition of the nightly covered bowl without compromise. Those tending the sick, infants, and frail elders will receive their witnessed portion first at the communal hearths, reinforcing the moral foundation that care work is the backbone of High Barley’s survival.\n\n### 5. Personal Leadership & Daily Presence\nMy attention this month will focus on:\n- Leading the trade delegation at the stream ford, negotiating equitable terms with Del, and establishing a lasting, honorable relationship with Ternhaven;\n- Walking the village perimeter and stores with Leth, Beren, and Cal to verify roof lashings, drainage ditches, and fuel dryness before the first gale strikes;\n- Spending evenings among the communal hearths, listening to household needs, supporting Cal’s rota keepers, and ensuring every family feels secure, valued, and ready for the coming winter.",
      "report": "# High Barley — Turn Report: Late autumn, Year 1\n\nLate-autumn winds have begun scouring the upland shelf, but High Barley enters the darkening season fortified, tightly roofed, and supplemented by its first successful trade with the coast.\n\n### The Ford Exchange with Ternhaven\nAt the stream ford cairn below the alder descent, Jun's crew erected a sheltered trade lean-to, anchored a stout guide rope, and set water-level markers along the western bank before the embassy arrived. You and the village elders met Del, Seli, and their two companions at the water's edge. High Barley presented a return gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint to honor their earlier overture. \n\nAcross the stepping stones, a successful trial barter was conducted. High Barley traded measured allotments of surplus barley grain, thick wool blankets, and medicinal herbs in exchange for clean coastal sea-salt and smoked fish. The exchange was conducted smoothly and peacefully, with both sides agreeing to establish a monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days. The stream boundary was strictly maintained throughout, ensuring coastal visitors remained at the crossing without ascending the ridge path toward the village.\n\n### Gale-Proofing and Storehouse Security\nAcross the settlement, work parties reinforced every building against incoming coastal gales. Roof ropes were weighted with heavy stones along the eaves of all dwellings and the storehouse, thatch spars were retied, and smoke-hole baffles were adjusted to prevent down-drafts while keeping interior hearths clear. Winter fuel—peat, deadwood, and split timber—was stacked atop dry log runners under eaves and overhangs, protected by freshly cut drainage furrows that guide runoff away from fuel stacks.\n\nIn the storehouse, Leth maintained weekly inspections beneath the raised timber dunnage and deployed rodent traps to protect bagged grain. Surface-chilled sacks were turned and aired on the ventilated wool loft hurdles, while Beren kept prime seed grain locked under separate, vigilant watch on the upper racks.\n\n### Herd Penning and Northwest Watch\nAs frost stiffened the upland grass, Osa brought the pack goats down from the open slopes into sheltered dry-stone pens. The herd is rationed on coarse barley straw, dried alder browse, and heather, with salt licks established in the pens using the newly acquired sea-salt. During foul weather, herd hands overhauled pack harnesses, hauling frames, and baskets. From the sheltered upper pens, Osa maintained a passive watch over the northwest ridge trail; no travelers or signs of movement were spotted, and the route beyond the ridge remains quiet and unmapped.\n\n### Shared Hearths and the Care Rota\nTo preserve fuel and maintain spirits as temperatures drop, Cal coordinated shared evening hearths across neighboring households. Families gathered in the larger dwellings for communal warmth. While dependents, elders, and young children were sheltered and tended, resting adults carded wool, spun yarn, and repaired tools for the coming year. The nightly covered bowl was faithfully honored at every shared table, ensuring those bound to domestic care received their witnessed share and maintaining solid community unity across all 153 people.\n\n### Pressures Ahead\nHigh Barley is secured for early winter, but seasonal challenges are mounting:\n- **Rising Ford Waters:** Autumn rain causes the stream ford to rise unpredictably. Maintaining the newly agreed monthly exchange with Del and Seli will depend heavily on timing trips to low-water windows.\n- **Winter Onset:** Days are growing markedly shorter, with frost setting in and snow expected soon. Outdoor travel will become increasingly hazardous as wind and freezing conditions intensify.\n- **Unmapped Northwest:** The upland ridge trail to the northwest remains unmapped and uncontacted, though quiet for now."
    },
    {
      "id": "player4",
      "absent": false,
      "memory": "Beliefs:\n- High Barley is a disciplined, cautious, and settled upland community that values territorial boundaries. Their decision to hold council strictly at the willow-ring cairn reflects prudence rather than hostility; honoring their water boundary and trading neutrally at the cairn is the most reliable way to build trust and long-term trade.\n- With late-autumn gales setting in and winter frosts ahead, our maritime operations must shift entirely to preservation and caution. Boats cannot be left at the outer mooring during seasonal squalls; hauling them high on inner skids eliminates the risk of catastrophic loss.\n- Indoor living will intensify as weather deteriorates. Proper smoke ventilation in the landing hall, wall insulation against biting drafts, sufficient dry firewood, and strict dunnage rotation for food stores are paramount to prevent illness and rot among our 150 people.\n- Trading coastal salt and smoked fish for upland barley, fleece, or hides will diversify our winter reserves and provide essential warmth.\n\nIntentions:\n- Propose a neutral, regular barter station at the stream ford's willow-ring cairn with High Barley, offering clean sea-salt and smoked fish in exchange for barley grain and goat wool/fleece.\n- Improve smoke draft and ventilation in the landing hall with adjustable woven louvers/baffles while banking windward walls against autumn gales.\n- Keep both fishing craft hauled high on timber skids above the storm tide line, winterizing their timbers with pitch and tallow, and relying on calm-day inshore netting and tidal shellfish foraging.\n- Complete a thorough pre-winter inventory tally with Ves, stack all available dry firewood under shelter, and maintain wellhead diversion channels.\n\nUnanswered Questions:\n- Will High Barley agree to a scheduled cairn barter (salt/fish for grain/wool), and what exchange rates will they consider fair?\n- Do traveling artisans, such as Del's remembered basket menders, stop at High Barley or visit the coast before deep winter?\n- How harsh is the coming winter in this inlet—does sea spray freeze along the landing, or does the inner water freeze over?",
      "submission": "### Council of the Frost Gate\n\nThe late-autumn wind has begun to bite off the sound, driving sea spray against the outer bar and rattling the alder branches above the path. Inside the landing hall, the central hearth burns warm, but the thick cure-smoke lingering in the high rafters shows that living and curing together indoors requires care. \n\nI gathered Del, Ves, Ruan, Kiri, Seli, and Wen around the hearth stones to set our work for late autumn. \n\n\"The harvest is gathered, the roofs are tight, and High Barley knows we come with open hands and respect,\" I said. \"Now the cold winds are upon us, and winter is a month away. We will secure our hall against smoke and frost, pull our boats beyond the reach of storm tides, establish an honest trade at the stream cairn, and tally every sack and fillet that will carry our hundred and fifty through the dark months.\"\n\n---\n\n### 1. Hall Winterization, Ventilation, and Fuel (Wen & Work Crews)\n\n* **Smoke Baffles and Hearth Draft:** With curing fish and daily heating filling the landing hall rafters with heavy smoke, Wen will oversee the installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath the roof vents. These angled hurdle flaps can be set according to the wind direction to draw smoke out cleanly through the eaves without letting driving rain or squalls dump cold air directly onto the floor.\n* **Insulation and Draft Defenses:** Work crews will bank earth, cut sod, and weave dense reed screens along the windward exterior base of the landing hall and family dwellings. Doorways will be hung with double-layered mats weighted at the hem to cut cold draughts.\n* **Fire Safety:** With hearth fires burning constantly and dunnage lofts filled with split wood and cured fish, Wen will ensure a clear three-foot stone and gravel border is maintained around all hearth pits. Fresh-water buckets filled from the well will stand ready near the doorway at all times.\n* **Fuel Gathering and Seasoning:** Before late-autumn mud freezes solid or snow blocks the alder trail, teams will haul seasoned deadfall from the lower alder woods and dry driftwood from the inner beach. All gathered wood will be split, stacked on raised skids off the wet ground, and shielded under extended lean-tos. Each evening, two days' worth of logs will be staged inside the hall near the hearth to drive off moisture before burning.\n\n---\n\n### 2. Stores, Tally, and Tidal Foraging (Ves)\n\n* **Pre-Winter Storehouse Audit:** Ves will conduct a full, itemized inventory of all winter provisions: sacks of barley meal, bundles of dried split fish, cured roots, and sea-salt crocks. She will establish a measured rationing baseline calibrated for our 150 people to ensure our food lasts through the cold months without sudden shortages.\n* **Moisture and Pest Rotation:** Stores on the split-timber dunnage will be inspected twice weekly. Sacks and bundles will be rotated to prevent damp spots from forming near interior walls. Any root or fish showing surface moisture will be trimmed and boiled into the daily hearth pot immediately.\n* **Tidal Shelf Foraging:** On days when winds make boat travel unwise, shore teams will scour the sheltered inner rocky shoreline and gravel bars at low spring tides. We will harvest mussels, limpets, whelks, and edible kelp to provide fresh protein and stretch our cured stores without risking lives on the water.\n\n---\n\n### 3. Boat Winterization and Inlet Fishery (Kiri & Ruan)\n\n* **Hauling Out for Winter Gales:** With late-autumn winds building and dangerous swells pushing against the bar, both fishing boats will be hauled entirely out of the water onto greased timber skids on the high inner beach, well above the reach of the highest storm surges.\n* **Craft Maintenance:** Kiri will inspect the hulls for worm or rot, clean off growth, and treat the seams and planking with tallow and heated pitch before freezing cold sets in. The boats will be lashed down to ground stakes and sheltered under thatched hurdle covers to protect the wood from frost splitting.\n* **Outer Mooring Safeguard:** The re-rigged outer mooring line will remain buoyed and weighted with its sound sinker stone, but no boat will be left moored unattended during late-autumn squalls.\n* **Opportunistic Inshore Netting:** If clear, calm slack days occur, Ruan may launch a single craft with an experienced crew to shoot nets strictly within the sheltered hook of the inlet. At the first sign of rising whitecaps or falling pressure, the boat will return and be winched back onto the skids.\n* **Indoor Tackle Work:** On rough days, Ruan's net crews will work around the hearth twisting fresh cordage from bast fibers, carving wooden net floats, and repairing torn mesh for the coming spring.\n\n---\n\n### 4. Bounded Barter at the High Barley Ford (Del & Seli)\n\nHigh Barley received our embassy courteously and affirmed peace, but made it clear that their boundary is the stream ford. We will honor their boundary scrupulously—good neighbors are made by respecting fences.\n\n* **The Delegation:** Del and Seli will lead a party of four to the stream ford during a clear weather window, carrying a modest trade pack. They will not attempt to cross the stream, but will halt at the stone cairn marked with the woven willow ring.\n* **The Barter Proposal:** \n  * Del will hail ford watcher Jun and invite the elders to the water's edge for a formal trade council across the stream.\n  * Del will thank them for their courteous welcome and propose a regular, neutral **Ford Exchange** held at the cairn on the full moon of each month, or signaled by a single smoke fire at the meadow's edge when travel permits.\n  * **Our Offer:** Clean coastal sea-salt (valuable for preserving their winter meat and seasoning goat fodder) and prime wood-smoked fish.\n  * **Our Request:** In exchange, we seek upland barley grain (to supplement our meal stores), raw wool or woven goat-fleece (to provide winter blankets and warm clothing against coastal frosts), or cured hides.\n  * We will conduct a trial barter on the spot using the sample goods brought by Del's party, allowing both sides to weigh and inspect items across the stepping stones without either party crossing into the other's territory uninvited.\n* **Inquiries:** Del will also ask Jun and the elders whether Del's remembered traveling basket menders commonly pass through High Barley before winter, or if any other coastal or mountain communities trade along the upper paths.\n* **Boundary Discipline:** Under no circumstances will our people cross the water or press past the willow ring unless explicitly invited by High Barley's leadership.\n\n---\n\n### 5. Community Morale, Health, and Personal Leadership\n\nAs the days shorten and our world contracts to the landing hall and the inner beach, maintaining purpose and good spirits is essential. \n\n* **The Hearth and the Well:** Wen will ensure the fresh-water diversion ditches remain free of autumn leaves and ice debris, keeping our drinking water clean. She will keep hot herbal decoctions simmering by the hearth for anyone coming in from the wet.\n* **Hospitality Watch:** If unexpected travelers or itinerant menders arrive at the inlet before winter seals the trails, Del will enact our established law: shelter and a warm hearth-meal on their first night; in the morning, an honest offer of shelter in exchange for mending work or winter labor, or travel rations and a peaceful farewell.\n* **My Station:** I will work alongside the village daily:\n  * Helping Wen construct and fit the roof smoke louvers to ensure the hall remains breathable.\n  * Assisting Kiri with the tallow and timber skids on the beach, mastering the knots and woodwork that protect our craft.\n  * Sitting with Ves at night to review our supply ledgers by firelight, ensuring our people know their leadership is watchful, steady, and prepared.\n\nThrough careful storekeeping, secure boats, respectful trade at the ford, and a warm, well-ventilated hearth, Ternhaven will meet the winter frost with quiet confidence.",
      "report": "### The Ford Exchange with High Barley\n\nDel and Seli led Ternhaven's four-person party along the alder path to the stream ford cairn. At the water's edge, ford watcher Jun hailed the delegation, and High Barley's leader and elders came down to meet them beside their newly erected trade lean-to. High Barley received the delegation courteously and presented a return hospitality gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint.\n\nAcross the flat stepping stones, the two groups carried out a successful trial barter without setting foot past the boundary. Ternhaven traded coastal sea-salt and smoked fish in exchange for upland barley grain, heavy woven wool blankets, and dried medicinal herbs. Del and High Barley's leadership formally agreed to establish a regular monthly Ford Exchange at the cairn on low-water days, maintaining peaceful commerce while strictly honoring the mutual boundary against uninvited entry into either settlement.\n\n### Landing Hall Winterization and Hearth Safety\n\nAt the landing, Wen oversaw the construction and mounting of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath the hall's roof vents. These baffles successfully vent heavy curing smoke outside while holding heat near the floor, leaving the hall warm, dry, and breathable. \n\nAround the exterior, work crews banked earth and dense reed screening against the windward walls and fitted weighted baffles at the doorways to stop draft leaks. Wen also established three-foot gravel firebreaks and ready water buckets around all hearth pits, ensuring firewood is safely pre-dried indoors away from open flame. The diversion ditches uphill from the fresh-water wellhead remain open and clear, protecting the drinking supply from late-autumn mud and runoff.\n\n### Craft Haul-Out and Shore Foraging\n\nWith late-autumn winds rising and rough swells pressing the outer bar, Kiri and Ruan directed the haul-out of both fishing boats onto the high inner beach. The craft were winched onto greased timber skids well above the storm-tide line. Kiri treated and pitched the seams with tallow and resin to seal the hulls, after which both boats were lashed down firmly beneath thatched hurdle covers to shield the timbers from frost splitting.\n\nWith boat fishing suspended, shore crews turned to low spring tides along the inner rocky shoreline and gravel beds, gathering limpets, mussels, and kelp to provide fresh food without risking craft beyond the sheltered inlet.\n\n### Storehouse Audit and Winter Rationing\n\nVes completed an itemized inventory of all stored winter provisions, incorporating the newly bartered upland grain alongside sacks of meal, cured roots, salt crocks, and bundles of dried fish. Based on this tally, Ves established a measured daily rationing schedule calculated to sustain the settlement's 150 people through the dark months. Dunnage inspections and sack rotations continue twice weekly to ensure dampness does not settle against walls or beneath the bottom timber layers.\n\n### Immediate Pressures and Open Questions\n\n* **Winter Weather and the Alder Path:** With winter frost, snow, and shortened days arriving, keeping the alder path passable to the stream ford will become increasingly arduous, leaving the timing of the next monthly Ford Exchange dependent on trail conditions and low stream water.\n* **Reliance on Preserved Stores:** With both fishing boats hauled and thatched on the beach until spring, the settlement is now entirely committed to Ves’s winter rationing baseline, supplemented only by low-tide shellfish gathering and seasoned firewood reserves.\n* **Border Relations:** While trade across the stepping stones proved peaceful and fruitful, High Barley remains firm on maintaining the stream cairn as a strict boundary, leaving future barter confined entirely to the water's edge."
    }
  ]
}
