GM record

Turn 003 · SIMULATION · Co-GM archive

Turn 003 — Adjudication checkpoint

Reading edition of a structured SIMULATION record. Repeated embedded state and generated views are omitted from phase checkpoints; the literal JSON below preserves the complete record. Commit pages show the turn’s decisions, approvals and status; the World State and Timeline pages provide the readable state history.

Gm

Decisions

T003-D01

Activated Rule Ids

None recorded.

Activated Victory Ids

None recorded.

Changes
saltmere-conditions
Collection

facts

Field

statement

Id

saltmere-conditions

Value

The western pan bank is insulated against frost heave beneath a heavy revetment of reed bundles and turf flaps, with brine barreled in covered clay vats and greased pans stored under cover. Fishing skiffs rest lashed hull-up on high timber rollers above storm surges, while low-tide mudflat foraging and Sava's eel traps yield fresh catch. Garden roots are bedded in dry sand clamps, stores sit raised on dunnage, and longhouse hearths are banked for shared evening warmth.

saltmere-households
Collection

factions

Field

current_agenda

Id

saltmere-households

Value

Late-autumn winterization is complete: pan bank is insulated against frost heave, skiffs are secured on high rollers, root stores are bedded in sand clamps, and households gather around shared longhouse hearths.

fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D01
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Fen's crew dressed the western pan bank with a thick revetment of dry reed bundles and heavy turf flaps to shield the clay core from frost heave. Full boiling was suspended to conserve firewood, concentrated brine was barreled in covered clay vats, boiling pans were greased with fish oil, and a thatched timber canopy was erected over the springhead.

Subject Id

saltmere

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player1
Scope

PLAYERS

K-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Holder Id

saltmere-leader

Id

K-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player1

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Value
Domain

RESOURCE

Id

fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D01
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Orin hauled both fishing skiffs well above storm-tide levels, lashing them hull-up on timber rollers beneath thatched mats. Foraging shifted to tidal shallows and Sava's woven wicker traps in the reed channels, harvesting cockles, mussels, and eels. Daro bedded roots in dry sand clamps, grain was raised on split-timber dunnage, and Sava's weavers shifted indoors to make draft screens and hampers.

Subject Id

saltmere

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player1
Scope

PLAYERS

K-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Holder Id

saltmere-leader

Id

K-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player1

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

Eliminated Player Ids

None recorded.

Id

T003-D01

Outcome

Saltmere is fully winterized: the western pan bank is insulated against frost heave with reeds and turf, brine is safely vatted, and pans are greased with fish oil. Fishing skiffs are secured on high rollers under thatch, while shallows foraging and reed traps provide steady fresh food. Stored roots are safeguarded in sand clamps, grain is elevated on dunnage, and communal longhouse hearths preserve firewood while maintaining community morale.

Rationale

Player 1's plan demonstrates exceptional discipline and environmental grounding (P=1.0). The decision to pause full salt boiling protects scarce dry firewood for domestic heating, while transferring concentrated brine to clay vats and greasing boiling pans prevents corrosion. Protecting the western clay pan bank with a thick revetment of reed bundles and turf flaps prevents frost heave during winter freezes. Canopying the springhead prevents debris and freeze fouling. Hauling the two fishing skiffs onto high rollers above storm tides eliminates hull damage, while shifting foraging to sheltered tidal mudflats (cockles, mussels) and Sava's eel traps maintains fresh protein without open-water risk. Bedding root crops in dune sand clamps protects against frost rot, and indoor basket weaving and communal longhouse hearth banking maintain domestic cohesion and fuel efficiency.

Verdict

ACCEPT

Warning And Causal Support

No elimination proposed or warranted; Saltmere maintains high internal stability, active leadership, and secure winter stores.

T003-D02

Activated Rule Ids

None recorded.

Activated Victory Ids

None recorded.

Changes
keelstrand-conditions
Collection

facts

Field

statement

Id

keelstrand-conditions

Value

All fishing craft are winched onto greased timber skids above storm tides on the gravel terrace. Dwellings are gale-proofed with lattice hold-down poles and doorway baffles, and runoff swales are cleared. The stabilized boat shed serves as an active indoor workshop where Mara shapes framing knees and oars for spring shipbuilding, Pell's apprentices repair nets and cordage, and stores are audited with a 20% winter reserve.

keelstrand-households
Collection

factions

Field

current_agenda

Id

keelstrand-households

Value

Winter readiness is secured: boats are hauled on high skids, roofs are tied with lattice poles, the final timber sled run is safely stowed, and indoor boat joinery and cordage work continue in the shed.

fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D02
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Arel's crews maximized the late-autumn fish runs before winching the fishing boat and creek skiffs onto greased log skids on the gravel terrace above storm tides, lashing them securely. Inside the stabilized boat shed, Mara and carpenters spent foul-weather days carving oars, shaping thole pins, drilling trunnels, and pre-fitting framing knees for Arel's spring vessel, while Pell's apprentices repaired nets and conditioned cordage with tallow and pitch.

Subject Id

keelstrand

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player2
Scope

PLAYERS

K-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Id

K-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player2

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Value
Domain

RESOURCE

Id

fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D02
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Tor's crews gale-proofed all dwellings with lattice hold-down poles pegged at eaves and chinked walls with moss and clay, hanging hide baffles over doorways. Mara and Ivo completed the final drag-sled run for firewood logs and birch bark before stowing the oiled sleds. Venn audited all winter reserves, establishing a transparent weekly household rationing schedule that preserves an untouched 20% emergency reserve, with seed beans sealed in rafter vessels.

Subject Id

keelstrand

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player2
Scope

PLAYERS

K-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Id

K-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player2

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D02
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Ivo conducted a final pre-frost scout to the southeast ridge before winter weather set in. From concealed observation, he noted that the distant upland pastoralists have moved their pack goat herds off the exposed slopes into sheltered stone pens near their settlement, confirming pastoral winterization, before returning safely.

Subject Id

sound

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player2
Scope

PLAYERS

K-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Id

K-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player2

Propagation Path
  • keelstrand-c4
Source Type

PROPAGATED

Eliminated Player Ids

None recorded.

Id

T003-D02

Outcome

Keelstrand is thoroughly secured against winter gales: all watercraft are winched onto high gravel skids, dwellings are gale-proofed with roof lattice poles and doorway baffles, and the final sled run secures winter fuel. The boat shed operates as an efficient indoor joinery workshop preparing components for spring shipbuilding, and storehouses are audited with a 20% emergency reserve.

Rationale

Player 2's submission demonstrates exceptional operational orchestration and grounding (P=1.0). Arel's fishing crews maximize the late-autumn fish runs before winching all boats onto greased log skids above the storm-tide line, eliminating hull destruction from winter swells. Mara and Ivo complete the final timber and fuel drag-sled run before track frost hardens into ruts, then grease and stow the sleds. Dwelling roofs are secured with lattice hold-down poles, doorway hide baffles installed, and swales cleared. Mara converts the draft-proofed boat shed into an indoor workshop to carve oars, thole pins, and internal framing knees for Arel's spring vessel, while Pell's apprentices repair nets and braid bast cordage. Venn establishes an itemized ration plan holding a 20% winter reserve, and Ivo confirms pastoral winterization from the southeast ridge.

Verdict

ACCEPT

Warning And Causal Support

No elimination proposed or warranted; Keelstrand demonstrates robust internal order, high morale, and secure winter preparations.

T003-D03

Activated Rule Ids

None recorded.

Activated Victory Ids

None recorded.

Changes
high-barley-conditions
Collection

facts

Field

statement

Id

high-barley-conditions

Value

Dwellings and storehouses are gale-proofed with stone-weighted thatch ropes and smoke baffles. Grain sacks rest secure on raised timber dunnage under Leth's weekly inspection, with prime seed locked by Beren. Pack goats are housed in sheltered dry-stone pens with winter fodder and salt licks, while fuel is stacked dry on log runners. Shared evening hearths and the faithful observance of the covered bowl maintain community warmth and unity.

high-barley-households
Collection

factions

Field

current_agenda

Id

high-barley-households

Value

Upland winter defenses are in place: roofs are weighted with stones, grain stores and seed are rigorously inspected, pack goats are penned and fed, and communal hearths unite the households around the covered bowl.

fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D03
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Work parties retied thatch spars and weighted roof ropes with stones along the eaves of all dwellings and the storehouse, adjusting smoke-hole baffles against down-drafts. Winter fuel was stacked on log runners under eaves with drainage furrows. Leth maintained weekly dunnage inspections and rodent trapping, airing surface-chilled sacks on loft hurdles, while Beren kept prime seed grain locked under separate watch.

Subject Id

high-barley

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player3
Scope

PLAYERS

K-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Holder Id

high-barley-leader

Id

K-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player3

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Value
Domain

RESOURCE

Id

fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D03
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Osa transitioned the pack goats from open slopes into sheltered dry-stone pens, rationing coarse straw, alder browse, and heather while overhauling pack harnesses and maintaining passive watch over the northwest trail. Cal coordinated shared evening hearths across households for fuel efficiency, where resting adults carded wool, spun yarn, and repaired tools while dependents were cared for, with the nightly covered bowl faithfully honored.

Subject Id

high-barley

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player3
Scope

PLAYERS

K-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Holder Id

high-barley-leader

Id

K-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player3

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

Eliminated Player Ids

None recorded.

Id

T003-D03

Outcome

High Barley is fortified against upland winter: dwelling roofs are stone-weighted, fuel is stacked high on runners, and granaries are protected from damp and vermin with seed grain locked. Pack goats are housed in sheltered stone pens, and communal hearths and the covered bowl sustain community solidarity and domestic industry.

Rationale

Player 3's submission displays exemplary agricultural and community leadership (P=1.0). Roof ropes are systematically weighted with stones along eaves and smoke-hole baffles adjusted against down-drafts. Fuel is consolidated on log runners under eaves with runoff diversion furrows. Leth conducts rigorous weekly storehouse inspections, using traps against vermin and airing surface-chilled sacks on loft hurdles, while Beren keeps prime seed grain isolated. Osa transitions pack goats to sheltered dry-stone pens with rationed straw, browse, and pack gear maintenance, while keeping passive watch over the northwest trail without risky mountain crossings. Cal's shared communal hearths and the nightly covered bowl preserve warmth, social solidarity, and care for dependents.

Verdict

ACCEPT

Warning And Causal Support

No elimination proposed or warranted; High Barley demonstrates exceptional domestic cohesion, food security, and herd health.

T003-D04

Activated Rule Ids

None recorded.

Activated Victory Ids

None recorded.

Changes
ternhaven-conditions
Collection

facts

Field

statement

Id

ternhaven-conditions

Value

The landing hall is warm and breathable following Wen's installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath roof vents, with exterior walls banked with earth and doorways baffled. Fishing craft are hauled onto greased skids on the high inner beach, pitched, and lashed under thatch. Ves's storehouse audit establishes measured winter rationing with twice-weekly dunnage checks, wellhead ditches remain clear, and shore teams gather shellfish at spring tides.

ternhaven-households
Collection

factions

Field

current_agenda

Id

ternhaven-households

Value

Landing hall air is clear and warm with smoke louvers in place, boats are hauled above storm tides, winter stores are audited and safeguarded on dunnage, and the trade embassy returned safely from the stream ford.

fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D04
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Wen oversaw the construction and installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath landing hall roof vents, drawing heavy curing smoke cleanly outside while preserving interior heat. Work crews banked earth and dense reed screens against exterior walls and hung weighted door baffles, while three-foot gravel firebreaks and ready water buckets were established around all hearths, with fuel pre-dried indoors.

Subject Id

ternhaven

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player4
Scope

PLAYERS

K-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Holder Id

ternhaven-leader

Id

K-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player4

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Value
Domain

RESOURCE

Id

fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D04
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Kiri and Ruan winched both fishing boats onto greased timber skids on the high inner beach well above storm tides, pitching seams with tallow and resin before lashing them beneath thatched hurdle covers. Ves completed an itemized inventory of winter provisions, establishing measured rationing and twice-weekly dunnage rotations, while low-tide foraging along the rocky shore yielded mussels, limpets, and kelp.

Subject Id

ternhaven

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player4
Scope

PLAYERS

K-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Holder Id

ternhaven-leader

Id

K-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player4

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

Eliminated Player Ids

None recorded.

Id

T003-D04

Outcome

Ternhaven's landing hall is warm, well-ventilated, and protected from drafts, with wattled louvers drawing out smoke and banked earth sealing walls. Boats are securely hauled onto high beach skids and pitched, stores are audited with twice-weekly checks, and shoreline shellfish foraging supplements winter food.

Rationale

Player 4's submission demonstrates exceptional environmental adaptability and structural grounding (P=1.0). Wen's wattled smoke louvers beneath roof vents solve the chronic smoke inhalation issue while retaining indoor warmth, and exterior earth-banking and door baffles block drafts. Clear hearth firebreaks and water buckets prevent fire hazards. Staging pre-dried firewood indoors ensures clean burning. Ves conducts an itemized audit of winter provisions and institutes twice-weekly dunnage checks with culinary salvage of damp goods. Kiri and Ruan winch fishing boats onto greased skids on the high beach above storm surges, pitch seams, and shift crews to indoor net and cordage repair. Low-tide rocky foraging stretches stores without sea risk.

Verdict

ACCEPT

Warning And Causal Support

No elimination proposed or warranted; Ternhaven maintains active, vigilant leadership and high domestic health.

T003-D05

Activated Rule Ids

None recorded.

Activated Victory Ids

None recorded.

Changes
fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D05
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Evi, an elder, and a companion reached the southern bank of the northern creek and hailed the boatbuilders across the water in broad daylight with open hands. Keelstrand received the hail with prepared numbers and calm composure; the seasonal gift basket of pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed goods was transferred across the water. Both parties affirmed peaceful intentions and agreed that Marker Beach will serve as a neutral ground for seasonal barter, returning home without crossing the creek.

Subject Id

sound

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player1
Scope

PLAYERS

K-creek-parley-saltmere-view
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Fact Id

fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Holder Id

saltmere-leader

Id

K-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player1

Propagation Path
  • saltmere-c5
Source Type

PROPAGATED

fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D05
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

The rotational creek lookout spotted a three-person party approaching the south creek bank in daylight with open hands. Elders received their hail; the visitors identified themselves as peaceful coastal folk from Saltmere on the southern shallows, offering a seasonal gift basket of fine pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed craft. The gift was accepted across the water, peaceful relations were affirmed, and Marker Beach was agreed as a neutral seasonal meeting ground. Later, Ivo walked the marker beach and aligned three verification stones on a driftwood log.

Subject Id

sound

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player2
Scope

PLAYERS

K-creek-parley-keelstrand-view
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Fact Id

fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Id

K-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player2

Propagation Path
  • keelstrand-c4
Source Type

PROPAGATED

rel-saltmere-keelstrand
Collection

relationships

Field
Id

rel-saltmere-keelstrand

Value
Basis

Initial peaceful parley across the northern creek; Saltmere presented a seasonal gift of salt and smoked fish, Keelstrand acknowledged peaceful terms, and both agreed to Marker Beach as a neutral future barter site.

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Id

rel-saltmere-keelstrand

Intensity

LOW

Obligation Ids

None recorded.

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D05
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Source Id

saltmere-leader

Stance

Peaceful recognition and agreement to meet at Marker Beach for seasonal barter.

Target Id

keelstrand-leader

Visibility
Player Ids

None recorded.

Scope

GM_ONLY

rel-keelstrand-saltmere
Collection

relationships

Field
Id

rel-keelstrand-saltmere

Value
Basis

Saltmere delegation hailed across the northern creek in daylight, presenting a gift basket of salt and smoked fish; Keelstrand received the gift peacefully and agreed to Marker Beach as a neutral seasonal meeting ground.

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Id

rel-keelstrand-saltmere

Intensity

LOW

Obligation Ids

None recorded.

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D05
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Source Id

keelstrand-leader

Stance

Guarded respect and acceptance of Marker Beach as a neutral seasonal meeting ground.

Target Id

saltmere-leader

Visibility
Player Ids

None recorded.

Scope

GM_ONLY

fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D05
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Del and Seli's four-person embassy met High Barley's leader and elders at the stream ford cairn. Jun's crew had erected a sheltered trade lean-to, guide rope, and water-level markers on the western bank. High Barley presented a return gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint. Across the stepping stones, a successful trial barter was conducted: High Barley traded surplus barley grain, thick wool blankets, and medicinal herbs in exchange for clean sea-salt and smoked fish. Both parties agreed to a monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days while keeping the stream boundary uncrossed.

Subject Id

high-barley

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player3
Scope

PLAYERS

K-ford-barter-high-barley-view
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Holder Id

high-barley-leader

Id

K-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player3

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view
Collection

facts

Field
Id

fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Value
Domain

WORLD

Id

fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Provenance
Source Ids
  • T003-D05
Source Kind

APPROVED_DECISION

Statement

Del and Seli led Ternhaven's four-person delegation to the stream ford cairn, meeting High Barley's leader and elders. High Barley received them with a return hospitality gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint beside their new trade lean-to. Across the flat stepping stones, the parties conducted a successful trial barter, trading coastal sea-salt and smoked fish for upland barley grain, heavy woven wool blankets, and dried medicinal herbs. Both clans agreed to hold a regular monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days without uninvited entry into either village.

Subject Id

ternhaven

Value

Not recorded.

Visibility
Player Ids
  • player4
Scope

PLAYERS

K-ford-barter-ternhaven-view
Collection

knowledge

Field
Id

K-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Value
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Fact Id

fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Holder Id

ternhaven-leader

Id

K-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player4

Propagation Path
  • ternhaven-c1

  • ternhaven-c5

Source Type

PROPAGATED

rel-high-barley-ternhaven
Collection

relationships

Field

basis

Id

rel-high-barley-ternhaven

Value

Successful bilateral trial barter conducted across the stream ford stepping stones, exchanging surplus grain and wool for coastal salt and fish, establishing regular monthly low-water exchanges.

rel-high-barley-ternhaven
Collection

relationships

Field

stance

Id

rel-high-barley-ternhaven

Value

Honorable trade partner; values sea-salt and fish in exchange for upland barley and wool across the guarded stream ford.

rel-ternhaven-high-barley
Collection

relationships

Field

basis

Id

rel-ternhaven-high-barley

Value

Trial barter successfully conducted at the stream ford cairn, exchanging salt and fish for grain, wool blankets, and medicinal herbs with agreed monthly low-water barter terms.

rel-ternhaven-high-barley
Collection

relationships

Field

stance

Id

rel-ternhaven-high-barley

Value

Respectful and valued trade partner; prized source of upland barley grain and warm wool blankets across the stream ford.

Eliminated Player Ids

None recorded.

Id

T003-D05

Outcome

Peaceful inter-clan diplomacy is established at both ends of the sound. In the north, Saltmere and Keelstrand parley across the creek barrier, exchange gifts of salt and fish for neighborly goodwill, and agree on Marker Beach as a neutral future barter site. In the southeast, Ternhaven and High Barley complete a fruitful trial barter across the stream ford stepping stones—exchanging coastal sea-salt and fish for upland barley, warm wool blankets, and herbs—and establish a regular monthly Ford Exchange while strictly honoring boundary sovereignty.

Rationale

Both diplomatic operations resolve with flawless coordination, realistic pacing, and profound mutual caution across all four clans. (1) In the northern sound, Saltmere's three-person delegation (Evi, elder, companion) travels the shingle path, halts on the southern bank of the northern creek in daylight with open hands, presents Sava's gift basket of pressed salt, smoked fish, and woven reed goods, and hails the boat yard across the water. Keelstrand's rotational creek watch spots their approach and alerts the settlement, allowing elders to receive the hail with prepared numbers and calm composure. A small craft ferries the seasonal gift across the water without either party trespassing into the other's territory. Both parties agree that Marker Beach—situated neutrally between them—will serve as a future barter ground when conditions permit. Later, Keelstrand scout Ivo patrols the beach and places three verification stones on a driftwood log as a neutral sign. (2) In the southeast, Del and Seli lead Ternhaven's four-person embassy along the alder path to the stream ford cairn. High Barley has erected a sheltered trade lean-to, tensioned guide rope, and water-level markers on their bank. High Barley's leader, Jun, and elders meet them across the water, returning Del's earlier gift with warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried upland mint. The two clans conduct a highly successful trial barter across the flat stepping stones—trading coastal salt and smoked fish for upland barley grain, woven wool blankets, and medicinal herbs—and establish a regular monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days without uninvited entry into either settlement.

Verdict

ACCEPT

Warning And Causal Support

No elimination proposed or warranted; inter-clan interactions were conducted with mutual restraint, strict boundary respect, and zero hostilities.

Program Observations

  • Midpoint Voluntary Attractor Review (Turn 003): Per charter rules, voluntary attractors were evaluated following the completion of Turn 003. While bilateral contact and initial trial exchanges have succeeded at both the Northern Creek (Saltmere & Keelstrand) and the Stream Ford (High Barley & Ternhaven), these interactions currently represent localized pairwise barter and mutual recognition rather than a sustained multi-turn voluntary investment in a shared regional institution, overarching dependency, or recognized victory framework. In accordance with integration instructions ('no promotion is valid'), no victory attractor is promoted or activated at this turn.

  • Contact and Convergence Pacing: Contact across all four communities has emerged strictly along evidenced geographic routes and realistic temporal stages without artificial convergence. Saltmere and Keelstrand communicated across the physical barrier of the northern creek, agreeing to use Marker Beach neutrally; High Barley and Ternhaven established their barter across the stepping stones at the stream ford without entering either settlement. Physical terrain, daylight travel limits, and strict leader precautions prevented premature conflict or overextension.

  • Character Agency, Customs, and Refusal: Named characters exercised decisive agency in accordance with established knowledge, roles, and motives. Fen protected the pan bank from frost heave while Nessa accepted pausing salt boiling to protect domestic firewood; Orin prioritized boat haul-out and low-risk mudflat foraging; Mara and Ivo halted sled logging before ground freeze and shifted to boat shed joinery; Beren kept seed grain isolated under lock; Osa penned goats against mountain gales; Wen constructed smoke louvers to eliminate indoor respiratory hazard; and Del and Seli strictly obeyed boundary non-crossing rules. Domestic institutions (the covered bowl, care rotas, keel vows, and hospitality rules) effectively aligned community action.

  • Persistent Consequences and Embodiment: State continuity was rigorously preserved from prior turns. Keelstrand's underpinned shed post now houses winter boat carpentry; High Barley's dunnage platforms and loft hurdles enabled confident storage hygiene; and Ternhaven's hospitality policy framed external interactions. The trial barter generated immediate material consequences: High Barley acquired coastal salt and smoked fish, while Ternhaven acquired upland barley, heavy wool blankets, and medicinal roots.

  • Causal Clarity and Mundane Physicality: All outcomes adhered to mundane physical principles: clay frost heave mechanics, timber sled friction on thawing soil, stovepipe draft physics in thatched halls, and rough-water boating hazards. High leadership power (P=1.0 across all players) reflected exceptionally detailed, grounded submissions that anticipated bottlenecks and established explicit boundary contingencies, yielding durable operational success without ungrounded narrative shortcuts.

Trope Reviews

PR-T003-01

Actor

None / Not applicable

Capacity

Mundane clan delegation and village watch; no dramatic authority figures or cinematic twists.

Disposition

REJECTED_ALL

Id

PR-T003-01

Knowledge

All actors operate on direct observation and established clan reports; no external narrative knowledge.

Minimum Action

Cautious daylight verbal exchange across water and receipt of seasonal gift token.

Motive

Preserve clan security and explore peaceful trade before winter.

Opportunity

Daylight hail across the creek water barrier.

Precautions

Strict non-crossing boundary orders, daytime approach, and immediate retreat contingency.

Reason

Neither Reasonable Authority Figure nor Bittersweet Ending fits the grounded mundane reality of a cautious cross-water greeting. Archetypes would introduce ungrounded dramatic conventions; existing character agency and precautions fully account for the peaceful, cautious outcome.

Selected Ids

None recorded.

Trigger

Perceived foreign arrival and border encounter at northern creek.

PR-T003-02

Actor

None / Not applicable

Capacity

Direct physical exchange of trade packs across the water barrier.

Disposition

REJECTED_ALL

Id

PR-T003-02

Knowledge

Actors know only their own supplies and the terms spoken across the stream ford.

Minimum Action

Measured bilateral barter of staple goods across stepping stones.

Motive

Securing complementary winter stores (salt/fish for grain/wool) while defending settlement sovereignty.

Opportunity

Scheduled daylight meeting at the stream ford stepping stones.

Precautions

Non-crossing discipline, trade post at the water's edge, water-level markers, and refusal of entry to upland shelf.

Reason

Neither Reasonable Authority Figure nor Bittersweet Ending is causally applicable. The interaction is a mundane, highly pragmatic barter between self-reliant communities preserving strict boundaries, fully explained by established needs and precautions without dramatic embellishment.

Selected Ids

None recorded.

Trigger

Scarcity and contested barter terms ahead of winter.

Disclosures

player1

Player Id

player1

Fact Id

saltmere-conditions

Fact

Id

saltmere-conditions

Statement

The western pan bank is insulated against frost heave beneath a heavy revetment of reed bundles and turf flaps, with brine barreled in covered clay vats and greased pans stored under cover. Fishing skiffs rest lashed hull-up on high timber rollers above storm surges, while low-tide mudflat foraging and Sava's eel traps yield fresh catch. Garden roots are bedded in dry sand clamps, stores sit raised on dunnage, and longhouse hearths are banked for shared evening warmth.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-saltmere-conditions
Id

K-saltmere-conditions

Holder Id

saltmere-leader

Player Id

player1

Fact Id

saltmere-conditions

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Source Type

INITIAL

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Learned Turn

0

player1

Player Id

player1

Fact Id

fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Fact

Id

fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Statement

Fen's crew dressed the western pan bank with a thick revetment of dry reed bundles and heavy turf flaps to shield the clay core from frost heave. Full boiling was suspended to conserve firewood, concentrated brine was barreled in covered clay vats, boiling pans were greased with fish oil, and a thatched timber canopy was erected over the springhead.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Holder Id

saltmere-leader

Id

K-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player1

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player1

Player Id

player1

Fact Id

fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Fact

Id

fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Statement

Orin hauled both fishing skiffs well above storm-tide levels, lashing them hull-up on timber rollers beneath thatched mats. Foraging shifted to tidal shallows and Sava's woven wicker traps in the reed channels, harvesting cockles, mussels, and eels. Daro bedded roots in dry sand clamps, grain was raised on split-timber dunnage, and Sava's weavers shifted indoors to make draft screens and hampers.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Holder Id

saltmere-leader

Id

K-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player1

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player1

Player Id

player1

Fact Id

fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Fact

Id

fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Statement

Evi, an elder, and a companion reached the southern bank of the northern creek and hailed the boatbuilders across the water in broad daylight with open hands. Keelstrand received the hail with prepared numbers and calm composure; the seasonal gift basket of pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed goods was transferred across the water. Both parties affirmed peaceful intentions and agreed that Marker Beach will serve as a neutral ground for seasonal barter, returning home without crossing the creek.

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-creek-parley-saltmere-view
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Fact Id

fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Holder Id

saltmere-leader

Id

K-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player1

Propagation Path
  • saltmere-c5
Source Type

PROPAGATED

player2

Player Id

player2

Fact Id

keelstrand-conditions

Fact

Id

keelstrand-conditions

Statement

All fishing craft are winched onto greased timber skids above storm tides on the gravel terrace. Dwellings are gale-proofed with lattice hold-down poles and doorway baffles, and runoff swales are cleared. The stabilized boat shed serves as an active indoor workshop where Mara shapes framing knees and oars for spring shipbuilding, Pell's apprentices repair nets and cordage, and stores are audited with a 20% winter reserve.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-keelstrand-conditions
Id

K-keelstrand-conditions

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Player Id

player2

Fact Id

keelstrand-conditions

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Source Type

INITIAL

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Learned Turn

0

player2

Player Id

player2

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Fact

Id

fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Statement

Arel's crews maximized the late-autumn fish runs before winching the fishing boat and creek skiffs onto greased log skids on the gravel terrace above storm tides, lashing them securely. Inside the stabilized boat shed, Mara and carpenters spent foul-weather days carving oars, shaping thole pins, drilling trunnels, and pre-fitting framing knees for Arel's spring vessel, while Pell's apprentices repaired nets and conditioned cordage with tallow and pitch.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Id

K-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player2

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player2

Player Id

player2

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Fact

Id

fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Statement

Tor's crews gale-proofed all dwellings with lattice hold-down poles pegged at eaves and chinked walls with moss and clay, hanging hide baffles over doorways. Mara and Ivo completed the final drag-sled run for firewood logs and birch bark before stowing the oiled sleds. Venn audited all winter reserves, establishing a transparent weekly household rationing schedule that preserves an untouched 20% emergency reserve, with seed beans sealed in rafter vessels.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Id

K-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player2

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player2

Player Id

player2

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Fact

Id

fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Statement

Ivo conducted a final pre-frost scout to the southeast ridge before winter weather set in. From concealed observation, he noted that the distant upland pastoralists have moved their pack goat herds off the exposed slopes into sheltered stone pens near their settlement, confirming pastoral winterization, before returning safely.

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Id

K-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player2

Propagation Path
  • keelstrand-c4
Source Type

PROPAGATED

player2

Player Id

player2

Fact Id

fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Fact

Id

fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Statement

The rotational creek lookout spotted a three-person party approaching the south creek bank in daylight with open hands. Elders received their hail; the visitors identified themselves as peaceful coastal folk from Saltmere on the southern shallows, offering a seasonal gift basket of fine pressed salt, smoked fish, and reed craft. The gift was accepted across the water, peaceful relations were affirmed, and Marker Beach was agreed as a neutral seasonal meeting ground. Later, Ivo walked the marker beach and aligned three verification stones on a driftwood log.

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-creek-parley-keelstrand-view
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Fact Id

fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Holder Id

keelstrand-leader

Id

K-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player2

Propagation Path
  • keelstrand-c4
Source Type

PROPAGATED

player3

Player Id

player3

Fact Id

high-barley-conditions

Fact

Id

high-barley-conditions

Statement

Dwellings and storehouses are gale-proofed with stone-weighted thatch ropes and smoke baffles. Grain sacks rest secure on raised timber dunnage under Leth's weekly inspection, with prime seed locked by Beren. Pack goats are housed in sheltered dry-stone pens with winter fodder and salt licks, while fuel is stacked dry on log runners. Shared evening hearths and the faithful observance of the covered bowl maintain community warmth and unity.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-high-barley-conditions
Id

K-high-barley-conditions

Holder Id

high-barley-leader

Player Id

player3

Fact Id

high-barley-conditions

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Source Type

INITIAL

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Learned Turn

0

player3

Player Id

player3

Fact Id

fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Fact

Id

fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Statement

Work parties retied thatch spars and weighted roof ropes with stones along the eaves of all dwellings and the storehouse, adjusting smoke-hole baffles against down-drafts. Winter fuel was stacked on log runners under eaves with drainage furrows. Leth maintained weekly dunnage inspections and rodent trapping, airing surface-chilled sacks on loft hurdles, while Beren kept prime seed grain locked under separate watch.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Holder Id

high-barley-leader

Id

K-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player3

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player3

Player Id

player3

Fact Id

fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Fact

Id

fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Statement

Osa transitioned the pack goats from open slopes into sheltered dry-stone pens, rationing coarse straw, alder browse, and heather while overhauling pack harnesses and maintaining passive watch over the northwest trail. Cal coordinated shared evening hearths across households for fuel efficiency, where resting adults carded wool, spun yarn, and repaired tools while dependents were cared for, with the nightly covered bowl faithfully honored.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Holder Id

high-barley-leader

Id

K-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player3

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player3

Player Id

player3

Fact Id

fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Fact

Id

fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Statement

Del and Seli's four-person embassy met High Barley's leader and elders at the stream ford cairn. Jun's crew had erected a sheltered trade lean-to, guide rope, and water-level markers on the western bank. High Barley presented a return gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint. Across the stepping stones, a successful trial barter was conducted: High Barley traded surplus barley grain, thick wool blankets, and medicinal herbs in exchange for clean sea-salt and smoked fish. Both parties agreed to a monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days while keeping the stream boundary uncrossed.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-ford-barter-high-barley-view
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Holder Id

high-barley-leader

Id

K-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player3

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player4

Player Id

player4

Fact Id

ternhaven-conditions

Fact

Id

ternhaven-conditions

Statement

The landing hall is warm and breathable following Wen's installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath roof vents, with exterior walls banked with earth and doorways baffled. Fishing craft are hauled onto greased skids on the high inner beach, pitched, and lashed under thatch. Ves's storehouse audit establishes measured winter rationing with twice-weekly dunnage checks, wellhead ditches remain clear, and shore teams gather shellfish at spring tides.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-ternhaven-conditions
Id

K-ternhaven-conditions

Holder Id

ternhaven-leader

Player Id

player4

Fact Id

ternhaven-conditions

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Source Type

INITIAL

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Learned Turn

0

player4

Player Id

player4

Fact Id

fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Fact

Id

fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Statement

Wen oversaw the construction and installation of adjustable wattled smoke louvers beneath landing hall roof vents, drawing heavy curing smoke cleanly outside while preserving interior heat. Work crews banked earth and dense reed screens against exterior walls and hung weighted door baffles, while three-foot gravel firebreaks and ready water buckets were established around all hearths, with fuel pre-dried indoors.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Holder Id

ternhaven-leader

Id

K-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player4

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player4

Player Id

player4

Fact Id

fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Fact

Id

fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Statement

Kiri and Ruan winched both fishing boats onto greased timber skids on the high inner beach well above storm tides, pitching seams with tallow and resin before lashing them beneath thatched hurdle covers. Ves completed an itemized inventory of winter provisions, establishing measured rationing and twice-weekly dunnage rotations, while low-tide foraging along the rocky shore yielded mussels, limpets, and kelp.

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

OBSERVED

Fact Id

fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Holder Id

ternhaven-leader

Id

K-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player4

Propagation Path

None recorded.

Source Type

DIRECT_OBSERVATION

player4

Player Id

player4

Fact Id

fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Fact

Id

fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Statement

Del and Seli led Ternhaven's four-person delegation to the stream ford cairn, meeting High Barley's leader and elders. High Barley received them with a return hospitality gift of warm wool cloth, fresh barley loaves, and dried mint beside their new trade lean-to. Across the flat stepping stones, the parties conducted a successful trial barter, trading coastal sea-salt and smoked fish for upland barley grain, heavy woven wool blankets, and dried medicinal herbs. Both clans agreed to hold a regular monthly Ford Exchange on low-water days without uninvited entry into either village.

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Confidence

CONFIRMED

Knowledge

K-ford-barter-ternhaven-view
Confidence

CONFIRMED

Epistemic Status

REPORTED

Fact Id

fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Holder Id

ternhaven-leader

Id

K-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Learned Turn

3

Player Id

player4

Propagation Path
  • ternhaven-c1

  • ternhaven-c5

Source Type

PROPAGATED

Adjudication Review

Approved

true

Causal Consistency

true

Disclosures

player1

Approved

true

Fact Id

saltmere-conditions

Player Id

player1

Rationale

Observed directly by player 1 (Saltmere leader) residing within Saltmere. Covers visible physical conditions of the settlement including the insulated western pan bank, vatted brine, stowed skiffs, sand root clamps, and evening hearth banking. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct daily observation. No information leaks.

player1

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-saltmere-bank-and-pan-winterization

Player Id

player1

Rationale

Observed directly by player 1 overseeing engineering work in Saltmere. Fen's crew dressed the western pan bank with reed revetments and turf flaps, vatted brine, greased pans, and canopied the springhead. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct physical verification. No information leaks.

player1

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-saltmere-stores-and-shallows-foraging

Player Id

player1

Rationale

Observed directly by player 1 in Saltmere. Details the haul-out of skiffs by Orin, shifting foraging to mudflat shellfish and Sava's eel traps, Daro's sand root clamps, elevated grain dunnage, and indoor weaving. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct observation of village work. No information leaks.

player1

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-creek-parley-saltmere-view

Player Id

player1

Rationale

Communicated to player 1 by Evi (saltmere-c5), who led the three-person embassy along the shingle path to the northern creek bank and returned safely. The report describes words spoken openly in broad daylight across the water, the peaceful receipt of Sava's gift basket, and the bilateral agreement to use Marker Beach as a neutral future barter site. Keelstrand identified itself openly and received the hail in view of the emissaries. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by firsthand eyewitness testimony. No hidden facts or internal Keelstrand state are disclosed.

player2

Approved

true

Fact Id

keelstrand-conditions

Player Id

player2

Rationale

Observed directly by player 2 (Keelstrand leader) residing in Keelstrand. Encompasses winched boats on the gravel terrace, gale-proofed dwellings with doorway baffles, cleared swales, indoor joinery and cordage work in the boat shed, and audited stores. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct daily observation. No information leaks.

player2

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-craft-haulout-and-joinery

Player Id

player2

Rationale

Observed directly by player 2 in Keelstrand. Covers Arel's boat haul-out onto greased skids, Mara's indoor joinery preparing framing knees and oars for spring shipbuilding, and Pell's apprentices conditioning cordage and repairing nets. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct observation of settlement labor. No information leaks.

player2

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-shelter-hardening-and-stores

Player Id

player2

Rationale

Observed directly by player 2 in Keelstrand. Details Tor's dwelling roof lattice poles and wall chinking, the final drag-sled firewood run by Mara and Ivo, Venn's store audit with a 20% emergency reserve, and rafter seed storage. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct inspection of village facilities. No information leaks.

player2

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-keelstrand-ridge-winter-observation

Player Id

player2

Rationale

Communicated to player 2 by timber scout Ivo (keelstrand-c4) following his dispatched reconnaissance to the southeast ridge before frost. Ivo observed from concealment that the distant upland pastoralists moved their goat herds off open slopes into sheltered stone pens near their settlement. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by firsthand scout observation from an established elevated ridge vantage point. No private names, internal store figures, or hidden High Barley state are revealed.

player2

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-creek-parley-keelstrand-view

Player Id

player2

Rationale

Communicated to player 2 by the rotational creek lookout, settlement elders, and scout Ivo (keelstrand-c4). Covers the daylight approach of Saltmere's three-person party to the southern creek bank, their open identification and presentation of the gift basket across the water, mutual peace affirmations, agreement on Marker Beach as a barter site, and Ivo's subsequent stone alignment on the beach log. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by multiple village eyewitnesses and physical custody of the gift goods. No unauthorized Saltmere secrets are leaked.

player3

Approved

true

Fact Id

high-barley-conditions

Player Id

player3

Rationale

Observed directly by player 3 (High Barley leader) residing in High Barley. Covers stone-weighted roofs, smoke-hole baffles, elevated grain dunnage under Leth's inspection, locked seed grain, penned pack goats, stacked fuel on runners, and evening hearths honoring the covered bowl. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by continuous daily observation and participation. No information leaks.

player3

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-high-barley-gale-defense-and-stores

Player Id

player3

Rationale

Observed directly by player 3 overseeing High Barley's physical infrastructure. Details roof rope weighting, smoke baffles, fuel consolidation on runners with drainage furrows, Leth's dunnage hygiene and rodent trapping, loft hurdle sack airing, and Beren's seed protection. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct physical verification. No information leaks.

player3

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-high-barley-herd-penning-and-hearths

Player Id

player3

Rationale

Observed directly by player 3 in High Barley. Encompasses Osa penning pack goats in dry-stone shelters, feed rationing, pack harness maintenance, trail watching, and Cal's coordination of communal evening hearths, indoor wool carding, and the covered bowl custom. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct participation. No information leaks.

player3

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-ford-barter-high-barley-view

Player Id

player3

Rationale

Observed directly by player 3, who personally led the council at the stream ford alongside Jun and village elders. Describes the trade lean-to and guide rope, presenting return hospitality gifts (wool cloth, barley loaves, dried mint), conducting trial barter across the stepping stones (salt and fish for barley, blankets, and herbs), and agreeing to monthly low-water exchanges while maintaining the uncrossed stream boundary. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct personal negotiation and physical transfer of goods. No unobserved Ternhaven secrets are leaked.

player4

Approved

true

Fact Id

ternhaven-conditions

Player Id

player4

Rationale

Observed directly by player 4 (Ternhaven leader) residing in Ternhaven. Covers landing hall smoke louvers and banked walls, boat haul-out onto greased beach skids under thatch, Ves's store audit and rationing schedule, clear wellhead drainage, and spring-tide foraging. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct daily observation. No information leaks.

player4

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-ternhaven-hall-louvers-and-fire-safety

Player Id

player4

Rationale

Observed directly by player 4 in Ternhaven, having personally assisted Wen with constructing and fitting the wattled smoke louvers beneath roof vents. Also covers exterior wall banking, door baffles, gravel firebreaks, ready water buckets, and pre-drying firewood. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by hands-on leadership participation and physical verification. No information leaks.

player4

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-ternhaven-craft-haulout-and-store-audit

Player Id

player4

Rationale

Observed directly by player 4 in Ternhaven. Details Kiri and Ruan winching fishing craft onto greased skids above storm tides, pitching seams, lashing under thatched covers, Ves's itemized provision inventory and dunnage rotation, and rocky shoreline foraging. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by direct observation and collaborative inventory review. No information leaks.

player4

Approved

true

Fact Id

fact-ford-barter-ternhaven-view

Player Id

player4

Rationale

Communicated to player 4 by delegation leaders Del (ternhaven-c1) and Seli (ternhaven-c5) upon returning from the stream ford cairn. Describes meeting High Barley's leader and elders, receiving return hospitality gifts (wool cloth, barley loaves, dried mint) beside their trade lean-to, conducting trial barter across stepping stones (salt and fish for barley, wool blankets, and medicinal herbs), and establishing monthly Ford Exchanges without settlement entry. CONFIRMED confidence is justified by firsthand eyewitness accounts and physical custody of acquired upland trade goods. No private High Barley secrets are disclosed.

Issues

None recorded.

Rationale

Comprehensive joint adjudication review for Turn 003 (Late Autumn, Year 1) confirms that the proposed adjudication is causally consistent, mechanistically sound, and fully compliant with all simulation and integration instructions:

  1. Causal Consistency & Physical Prerequisites: All player submissions operate strictly within mundane physical limits and clan capabilities. Labor allocations, seasonal constraints, and resource trade-offs are grounded:
  • Saltmere (Player 1): Suspends firewood-intensive boiling, insulates clay pan banks against frost heave with reed revetments, hauls skiffs onto high timber rollers, beds root crops in sand clamps, and conducts low-tide mudflat foraging.
  • Keelstrand (Player 2): Hauls craft onto greased gravel skids above storm surges, completes a final drag-sled timber run before frozen ruts set in, gale-proofs roofs with lattice hold-down poles, audits stores with a 20% reserve, and converts the boat shed into an indoor joinery workshop.
  • High Barley (Player 3): Weights thatch ropes with stones, consolidates dry fuel on log runners with drainage furrows, maintains granary dunnage hygiene and seed isolation, transitions pack goats into sheltered dry-stone pens, and sustains communal hearths and the covered bowl custom.
  • Ternhaven (Player 4): Resolves indoor curing smoke via adjustable wattled louvers beneath roof vents, banks earth against exterior walls, establishes gravel hearth firebreaks, winches boats onto high beach skids, audits stores, and conducts low-tide shellfish foraging. No missing prerequisites, supernatural explanations, or magical power overrides exist.
  1. Simultaneous Interactions & Contact Pacing: Cross-clan interactions resolve along evidenced geographic paths with strict boundary discipline and realistic temporal pacing:
  • Northern Creek: Saltmere's three-person delegation (Evi, elder, companion) halts on the southern bank and hails across the creek in daylight with open hands, presenting Sava's gift basket and proposing Marker Beach as a neutral barter ground. Keelstrand's rotational lookout detects the approach, and elders receive the hail with prepared numbers and calm dignity across the water barrier. Later, Keelstrand scout Ivo patrols Marker Beach and aligns three verification stones on a driftwood log. Neither clan trespasses.
  • Southeast Ridge & Upland Basin: Keelstrand scout Ivo conducts a pre-frost scout to the southeast ridge and observes that the distant upland pastoralists have moved their goat herds into sheltered stone pens near their settlement, confirming pastoral winterization, before returning safely.
  • Stream Ford: Ternhaven's four-person embassy (Del, Seli, and two companions) reaches the stream ford cairn. High Barley has erected a sheltered trade lean-to, guide rope, and water-level markers. High Barley's leader and elders meet them across the water, presenting return hospitality gifts (wool cloth, barley loaves, dried mint). Both clans conduct a successful trial barter across the stepping stones (trading coastal salt and fish for upland barley, wool blankets, and medicinal herbs) and agree to regular monthly low-water exchanges while scrupulously preserving territorial sovereignty.
  1. Character Agency, Customs, and Dramatic Pressure: Named NPCs across all four clans act strictly according to established knowledge, motives, and local institutions (witnessed stones, keel vows, covered bowls, two-stage hospitality rules). Dramatic-pressure reviews for foreign arrivals and border encounters were properly conducted; trope consultations (PR-T003-01 and PR-T003-02) correctly resulted in REJECTED_ALL dispositions, properly declining contrived literary archetypes in favor of grounded mundane diplomacy.

  2. Rule, Attractor, and Elimination Gates:

  • Attractor Review: Per rules for Turn 003, voluntary attractors were evaluated in program_observations; pairwise barter and neutral recognition have emerged, but no multi-clan voluntary investment in a shared regional institution exists. Correctly, no attractor is promoted ('no promotion is valid').
  • Emergent Rules: None activated.
  • Decision Count: Exactly 5 substantive decisions (T003-D01 through T003-D05), satisfying the validator cap and standard 3–5 target.
  • Eliminations: Zero proposed or warranted; all four leaders remain active and supportive.
  1. Narrative Disclosures & Information Boundaries: All 17 player-visible disclosures were individually audited across both domestic conditions and inter-clan interactions. Each disclosure has a sound causal observation or communication path, justified CONFIRMED confidence, and strict protection against information leaks. No hidden mechanics, GM reasoning, integer scores, power formulas, or private foreign dossiers are leaked. All material approved outcomes are embodied in player-visible facts.

Adjudication Round

1

← Return to the campaign archive